Moderator: Cartographers
Coleman wrote:A map must provide balanced game play. The first player to move must not be able to win 60% or more of the time in any situation,
Coleman wrote:no player should be guaranteed victory based on placement,
Coleman wrote:and no player should be able to be eliminated before they can take a turn.
oaktown wrote:* A map must provide balanced game play.
oaktown wrote:It should be reasonably clear that the the player that draws the first turn does not have a significant advantage,
oaktown wrote: nor should it be likely that any player will be eliminated in the first round of a game.
DiM wrote:since this rule was created to stop the production of WoF i'm going to use it as a reference.oaktown wrote:* A map must provide balanced game play.
balanced gameplay. i agree with that. that's what we aim for. equal chances and no clear strategies that always succeed.
in this case WoF is THE most balance map ever. each player has EXACTLY the same chance as the other guys.oaktown wrote:It should be reasonably clear that the the player that draws the first turn does not have a significant advantage,
define significant advantage. because at the moment on any map and any setting the first player always has the advantage simply because he's the first.oaktown wrote: nor should it be likely that any player will be eliminated in the first round of a game.
this is another problematic issue because on most maps an elimination is possible and on some an elimination is probable.
Yes. Be quiet.yeti_c wrote:DiM wrote:since this rule was created to stop the production of WoF i'm going to use it as a reference.oaktown wrote:* A map must provide balanced game play.
balanced gameplay. i agree with that. that's what we aim for. equal chances and no clear strategies that always succeed.
in this case WoF is THE most balance map ever. each player has EXACTLY the same chance as the other guys.oaktown wrote:It should be reasonably clear that the the player that draws the first turn does not have a significant advantage,
define significant advantage. because at the moment on any map and any setting the first player always has the advantage simply because he's the first.oaktown wrote: nor should it be likely that any player will be eliminated in the first round of a game.
this is another problematic issue because on most maps an elimination is possible and on some an elimination is probable.
Please - just drop it...
C.
WidowMakers wrote:Name 1 map where elimination is 100% guaranteed every time with any number of players in the first round where only one player moves.
on most maps an elimination is possible and on some an elimination is probable.
Coleman wrote:He said something about 100%, because unless someone doesn't attack that's pretty much what you have. I could tell you exactly if I could find the app I used but that will have to wait.
DiM doesn't like my jokes.DiM wrote:instead of all the "stupid" "retarded" "let's throw rotten tomatoes" mockery crap. all i asked from the beginning was an intelligent and to the point valid answer. i got that on pm.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users