Alphabet Mafia 2Day 6 no night deaths

[thehippo8]

Confirming cult really doesn't help us much for now in terms of setting up cases, at least for now.

Sorry Sam, it may just be me, but I didn't understand what this meant! Are you claiming cult?

[samgrossy]

well crap that cofirms the definate existance of a cult

Hippo - this is what I am talking about. Confirming the existence of a cult is great and all, but it doesn't get us any closer to a case.

[thehippo8]

well crap that cofirms the definate existance of a cult

Hippo - this is what I am talking about. Confirming the existence of a cult is great and all, but it doesn't get us any closer to a case.

Oh! Lol, I read that but didn't get what you were saying? Never mind, but I agree that a closer reading of the thread will help us all!

[aage]

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch

LyLo, great.

Hmh, so we don't know what roles cult had prior to recruitment?

Apparently not.

well crap that cofirms the definate existance of a cult

We already knew there was one..

well crap that cofirms the definate existance of a cult

Hippo - this is what I am talking about. Confirming the existence of a cult is great and all, but it doesn't get us any closer to a case.

Oh! Lol, I read that but didn't get what you were saying? Never mind, but I agree that a closer reading of the thread will help us all!

Let's just go through the player list. Sorry if I give more attention to some player than others, I have limited time to play the game and it's harder for me to get a read on players I'm less familiar with, especially if they post twice a month.

2. Aage - well, me.

4. Nagerous - absent, or at least as far as I'm even aware that Nag is even playing at all. I know you have a full time job but I would appreciate it if you would at least try to make a post this round.

5. Strike Wolf replaced by Hippo 2.0 day 4 - Meh. I dislike dead people replacing, and I detest the idea of investigative roles replacing, but it'll have to work. LSU knows what he's doing. I do suspect that Hippo/SW is either scum or cult member, since he didn't start the day off with OMGUS'ing people who were involved in his death (which would be easily tracked back to myself). I sense caution in his two posts which is strange.

7. Edocsil - same story as Nag, but with the occasional post. I don't like the scumarining. During the first days the reputation of both of you protected you from getting lynched, and now we don't have the game time to extend a discipline vote. I have the feeling he's looking at the game from a distance while he isn't involved himself, and it returns in every one of his posts. I would expect Edoc to be capable of some psychological warfare, and pretend he's not really playing, thus surviving every day and night. Still, I by principle distrust Edoc, so I would ask other players to share because I know I can't trust my own read on him.

8. Safariguy5 - if I read the posts by our busdriver and insane cop correctly, Saf is 100% scum. This of course depends on whether DJ is in fact a town busdriver and not a mafia busdriver messing with us to win the game. vote safariguy. Also a serious FoS on the previous posters who didn't even spend a letter on this, while it is the biggest lead we have.

11. SamGrossy - claimed roleblocker. Got Hippo version 1 lynched by claiming. What bugs me is that with 2 cops and a doctor, the odds of mafia having a roleblocker are high.

12. redhedge47 - absolute scumarine. Doesn't even seem interested in the game, since "all" his posts (at least, the ones I've been looking at the past fifteen minutes) are one sentence long.

14. ShaggyDan - I think I would trust Shaggy to be town most of all other players in the game. Part of it is gut feeling. Another part of it is that even though he isn't around too often, his posts show that he knows his stuff. (As opposed to redhedge's "lynch all liars vote jonty"-kind of posts.)

15. DJFireside - claimed busdriver. Not much to say. Since there are only town people dead (and one cultist, but he was town beforehand) we can't specifically speculate about what kind of roles the mafia has, but since this seems to be an NV game scum has some roles too. Busdriver is on that list, right next to roleblocker. Also (conveniently?) claimed a day late to see Hippo (town tracker) get lynched, and ensure the lynch of an insane cop. Then again, I supported the case at that moment as well, so for me there is no direct reason why that could be scummy.

16. Lord Voldemort - not getting a read on him. His contribution, no offence, is absolutely zero. As far as I can remember, I haven't played with him before extensively. If he is scum, I don't think he would be our priority target.


The problem is I'm getting scumtells on every one of you because every one of you could change alignment every night. The second problem is that Vodean could have been the cultist. (If he is... LSU, screw you.)

[nagerous]

Thanks for the summary aage, I know I've been inactive in this and for that I can only apologise.

My understanding of the situation, is as you so rightly summarised jonty was an insane cop that got a town read of safari, after a bit of bus driving shenanigans came into play as well.

Hence we lynch safari as he is definite scum no?

I would like to hear from him though before I place my vote.

[safariguy5]

I'm not scum, I'm Mr. P the rolecop.

I know what roles aage and strike/hippo are (the other people are all dead), but I'm concerned revealing them would set them up as prime targets for cult recruitment because then cult would have a lower chance of hitting mafia.

I'm perfectly willing to reveal them if that is the wishes of everyone, but I'm a bit concerned about cult recruitment.

[aage]

I'm not scum, I'm Mr. P the rolecop.

I know what roles aage and strike/hippo are (the other people are all dead), but I'm concerned revealing them would set them up as prime targets for cult recruitment because then cult would have a lower chance of hitting mafia.

I'm perfectly willing to reveal them if that is the wishes of everyone, but I'm a bit concerned about cult recruitment.

So there's three cops in this game according to you? And you don't even bother to mention that, since you claim to be town, DJ Fireside must be lying? vote stays.

[aage]

I'm not scum, I'm Mr. P the rolecop.

I know what roles aage and strike/hippo are (the other people are all dead), but I'm concerned revealing them would set them up as prime targets for cult recruitment because then cult would have a lower chance of hitting mafia.

I'm perfectly willing to reveal them if that is the wishes of everyone, but I'm a bit concerned about cult recruitment.

So there's three cops in this game according to you? And you don't even bother to mention that, since you claim to be town, DJ Fireside must be lying? vote stays.

And I might add to that that by making this post, if you were town cop you have just set up Strike/Hippo and me up as recruitment targets anyway?

[samgrossy]

I'm not scum, I'm Mr. P the rolecop.

I know what roles aage and strike/hippo are (the other people are all dead), but I'm concerned revealing them would set them up as prime targets for cult recruitment because then cult would have a lower chance of hitting mafia.

I'm perfectly willing to reveal them if that is the wishes of everyone, but I'm a bit concerned about cult recruitment.

Why are you claiming when you only have on person voting you. This seems suspicious to me. I'm not sure if its scummy or not, but it just doesn't seem like a very good idea.

[safariguy5]

I'm not scum, I'm Mr. P the rolecop.

I know what roles aage and strike/hippo are (the other people are all dead), but I'm concerned revealing them would set them up as prime targets for cult recruitment because then cult would have a lower chance of hitting mafia.

I'm perfectly willing to reveal them if that is the wishes of everyone, but I'm a bit concerned about cult recruitment.

Why are you claiming when you only have on person voting you. This seems suspicious to me. I'm not sure if its scummy or not, but it just doesn't seem like a very good idea.

I'm claiming because the insane cop got an innocent result on me which is basically like a sane cop getting a guilty result on me.

What's interesting here is that aage says that his vote stays because DJ is lying. But not 1-2 pages ago, it was brought up that busdriver could be either mafia or town aligned. So aage just automatically assumes the busdriver is town despite no other person actually confirming alignment. Could be aage got recruited to cult and he's afraid he's going to have to make up some night actions because he lost his actual powers.

[aage]

I'm not scum, I'm Mr. P the rolecop.

I know what roles aage and strike/hippo are (the other people are all dead), but I'm concerned revealing them would set them up as prime targets for cult recruitment because then cult would have a lower chance of hitting mafia.

I'm perfectly willing to reveal them if that is the wishes of everyone, but I'm a bit concerned about cult recruitment.

Why are you claiming when you only have on person voting you. This seems suspicious to me. I'm not sure if its scummy or not, but it just doesn't seem like a very good idea.

I'm claiming because the insane cop got an innocent result on me which is basically like a sane cop getting a guilty result on me.

What's interesting here is that aage says that his vote stays because DJ is lying. But not 1-2 pages ago, it was brought up that busdriver could be either mafia or town aligned. So aage just automatically assumes the busdriver is town despite no other person actually confirming alignment. Could be aage got recruited to cult and he's afraid he's going to have to make up some night actions because he lost his actual powers.

My problem is not that DJ could be mafia. My problem is that your defense is so poorly constructed that you don't even care to mention that DJ has to be scum for you to be telling the truth. Nice try twisting my words. Also nice try at diverting attention towards me as a possible cult recruit (which is, let's be honest, the least of our concerns right now) while there has been a cop claim against you which I have nothing to do with. I hope that whoever is left of town still has their senses about them.

[safariguy5]

I'm not scum, I'm Mr. P the rolecop.

I know what roles aage and strike/hippo are (the other people are all dead), but I'm concerned revealing them would set them up as prime targets for cult recruitment because then cult would have a lower chance of hitting mafia.

I'm perfectly willing to reveal them if that is the wishes of everyone, but I'm a bit concerned about cult recruitment.

Why are you claiming when you only have on person voting you. This seems suspicious to me. I'm not sure if its scummy or not, but it just doesn't seem like a very good idea.

I'm claiming because the insane cop got an innocent result on me which is basically like a sane cop getting a guilty result on me.

What's interesting here is that aage says that his vote stays because DJ is lying. But not 1-2 pages ago, it was brought up that busdriver could be either mafia or town aligned. So aage just automatically assumes the busdriver is town despite no other person actually confirming alignment. Could be aage got recruited to cult and he's afraid he's going to have to make up some night actions because he lost his actual powers.

My problem is not that DJ could be mafia. My problem is that your defense is so poorly constructed that you don't even care to mention that DJ has to be scum for you to be telling the truth. Nice try twisting my words. Also nice try at diverting attention towards me as a possible cult recruit (which is, let's be honest, the least of our concerns right now) while there has been a cop claim against you which I have nothing to do with. I hope that whoever is left of town still has their senses about them.

So is this your way of saying I should reveal your and strike's roles? Because I'm totally willing to do it.

Speaking of your theory as to why there cannot be 3 cops, remember that we had an SKer, cult, AND Mafia in this game. Even if one cop is insane, we need all the help we can get because a cop has a higher chance of being targeted by an anti town role.

[redhedge47]

lets hear it you clearly dont have any guilty results you would have already told us claiming with one vote is fairly scummy if you ask me
Vote Safari

[samgrossy]

The only reason that I think we should be careful here is because a bus driver can screw up any of the claims people are making. If there is more than bus driver it likely many things are screwed up. Claims could get ugly and cases could get confusing.

All that said, I think (for the reasons aage mention directly above) safari seems guilty. So if this makes any sense

VOTE SAFARI, but hoping he doesn't confuse things all the hell.

[samgrossy]

lets hear it you clearly dont have any guilty results you would have already told us claiming with one vote is fairly scummy if you ask me
Vote Safari

This adds to the summary that aage put out. You would think that if someone comes out and calls you a scummariner, you would make a better effort to make a longer post than just one line.

FoS REDHEDGE