betiko wrote:basically here is the deal:
1) NG first
pros: we reach the final day knowing everybody's role and with just jonty to lynch if it's not game over. If they are both mafia it's the only way to win.
cons: if jonty votes before both of us mafia wins.
pros: there has been a double voter all game and his claim + slips make us think it's him
cons: if he is not scum or if they are both scum we lose
I'd like other people's opinion, like nendreel's
1): If NG1 gets lynched now, I don't think all the roles will be revealed. There'll still be the N3 gap because of either you or Kanin being alive. Also if you go to D7 at all knowing the roles won't matter as the only person left is jonty.
2)Whether double voter or vote stealer, he'll have two votes on D7, and you and Kanin have to get your votes in before him.
So, going by what edoc said jonty hasn't gone anywhere, this would mean he's a natural DV rather than a VS. That means we only have one Power we know about in the works, and it seems to be jonty. If NG1 has an ability it hasn't manifested itself yet. NG1 was also willing to vote himself when the idea first came up and I don't think mafia would lynch themselves, especially if the only possibility of a Town win was by killing NG1 first.
My gut says jonty is the last mafia, but if you and Kanin believe you can get your votes in before jonty then I would suggest taking a guaranteed win.