Metsfanmax wrote:spiesr wrote:Or maybe there is no simple pattern as to which characters are scum. Until one of them turns up dead there is no way to know for sure.jonty125 wrote:WIFOM - Maybe not all the 'core' characters are in the game. Maybe mafia were given 1 or 2 for fakeclaims.
I don't know much of anything about this game's flavor, my objections to gregwolf's claim are based on the role he claimed. I have reason to suspect this game has an actually doctor. As such I don't see why there would be a 1-Shot Doctor in addition to this. Accordingly, his claim looks to me like a poorly done fake, perhaps attempting to draw out the real Doctor. Anyhow, it looks like it is now clear to put my vote back. Vote gregwolf.
I hate to have to point this out, but it's entirely possible he was lying about the one-shot nature of his doc ability to make himself appear a less attractive night kill to the mafia.
Well if he's a full-fledged doctor and lied about it, he's trading in attracting the mafia for attracting a lynch, which isn't entirely wise either.
Out of curiosity, what is this 'reason' you speak of, spiesr?