Best (Randomness) Of 2012 Game Over!

[jonty125]

Vote Count
edocsil (2) - rishaed; thechuck51

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch, deadline is Thursday 14 March @ 1600 GMT.

[pancakemix]

One point on the list: Kanin was a Watchmaker, not a Watchkeeper. Went and looked into that role.

show

I'm inclined to vote edoc, but I'll not jump the gun and vote him yet being that we are in potentially dangerous territory.

[spiesr]

One point on the list: Kanin was a Watchmaker, not a Watchkeeper. Went and looked into that role.

show

I'm inclined to vote edoc, but I'll not jump the gun and vote him yet being that we are in potentially dangerous territory.

I have to wonder if that role might have been modified for this game for some reason. The only person to have claimed to have had any watcher or tracker action was Kanin Usagi himself.

Edos'sil, if you have anything you would like to say before you are at L-1 I suggest that you do so now. Tomorrow I will put you at that point unless something changes my mind.

[rishaed]

I will confirm Kanin is the original role. I got a tracker action N2, but was in a rush to put my action in that night that I completely forgot about it. I was going to call BS if Kanin claimed he had recieved a gift that night. But since Kanin got himself MK'd I figured it wasn't relevant anymore, and until I found out that he was my "Gifter" I was waiting to see if someone else claimed to gift ppl.

[Nebuchadnezer]

I will confirm Kanin is the original role. I got a tracker action N2, but was in a rush to put my action in that night that I completely forgot about it. I was going to call BS if Kanin claimed he had recieved a gift that night. But since Kanin got himself MK'd I figured it wasn't relevant anymore, and until I found out that he was my "Gifter" I was waiting to see if someone else claimed to gift ppl.

Well, I got the Tracker gift to use last night. (I actually received it N2 to use N3). And glory be, I tracked Edoc. What a waste. Nothing like scum play to attract all the attention of the power roles. Sure enough, he visited nobody last night.

Rishaed. Edoc was at one point on your "almost guaranteed" town list earlier. Has his recent play erased that feeling for you?

Edoc. L-2. Claim. I am fully expecting a VT claim...

Once we have that claim, then we can figure out what to do. That will leave only 3 of us unclaimed at that point.

Neb

[thechuck51]

Well, I got the Tracker gift to use last night. (I actually received it N2 to use N3). And glory be, I tracked Edoc. What a waste. Nothing like scum play to attract all the attention of the power roles. Sure enough, he visited nobody last night.

Rishaed. Edoc was at one point on your "almost guaranteed" town list earlier. Has his recent play erased that feeling for you?

Edoc. L-2. Claim. I am fully expecting a VT claim...

Once we have that claim, then we can figure out what to do. That will leave only 3 of us unclaimed at that point.

Neb

why would you point reveal this info now instead of waiting until after he claimed? you know so, assuming you are telling the truth, you could catch him in a lie if he fake claimed some sort of PR instead of throwing up a giant billboard that says "EDOC, CLAIM VT!!!!"

you are "fully expecting a VT claim". no kidding

you are claiming an action that cannot be verified and this reeks of one scum trying to protect another. FOS Neb

[rishaed]

Gut feeling, goes with Edoc is experienced enough of a player, that I expect that he wouldn't make such an obvious slip in a 24hr run off period. However I'm still leaning town on Edoc, maybe not as much though. It goes without saying that I feel that a claim is in order.
Minor note: Don't forget he was RB'd so the tracker action proves nothing.

[rishaed]

Minor FOS on Neb coming out with the tracker action for a defense/action is useless.

[Nebuchadnezer]

Well, I got the Tracker gift to use last night. (I actually received it N2 to use N3). And glory be, I tracked Edoc. What a waste. Nothing like scum play to attract all the attention of the power roles. Sure enough, he visited nobody last night.

Rishaed. Edoc was at one point on your "almost guaranteed" town list earlier. Has his recent play erased that feeling for you?

Edoc. L-2. Claim. I am fully expecting a VT claim...

Once we have that claim, then we can figure out what to do. That will leave only 3 of us unclaimed at that point.

Neb

why would you point reveal this info now instead of waiting until after he claimed? you know so, assuming you are telling the truth, you could catch him in a lie if he fake claimed some sort of PR instead of throwing up a giant billboard that says "EDOC, CLAIM VT!!!!"

you are "fully expecting a VT claim". no kidding

you are claiming an action that cannot be verified and this reeks of one scum trying to protect another. FOS Neb

What did you think I would catch Edoc claiming? That he was a cop and got a "guilty" result last night? Come on, Chuck, pay attention. Spiesr already claimed roleblocking Edoc. My information confirms that Edoc didn't go anywhere, and that Spiesr's claim and action are believable. I have no idea how you make a connection that I would be scum trying to protect him.

Minor FOS on Neb coming out with the tracker action for a defense/action is useless.

So, I shouldn't be forthcoming with information? My tracking confirms that Spiesr's claim of roleblocking is plausible. Not 100%, but nothing is out of place based on ALL the information we have. I wouldn't call it useless.

Holy cow, I thought sharing all the information we have was a good thing!

[thechuck51]

Fair enough Neb, when I read your post I wasn't doing it with the fact that Edoc was blocked in mind. However, rereading it now, it takes on a different context (if that is the right term). so unFOS

[rishaed]

Well, in my eyes Information is power, so no the information isn't completely useless. However I do think that there is a time when information should be given. The timing of your information seemed off to me, thus a minor FOS and not a vote. Speisr doesn't NEED complete confirmation IMO, he is CONFIRMED. The fact that he called Doomyoshi out makes that clear to me. On the other hand Edoc could be scum who got RB'd, I just highly doubt it b/c of my gut feeling that I got from him D1.

[pancakemix]

I'm not entirely sure how a roleblock would affect a track. Would they still go to their target or would they stay home?

[Nebuchadnezer]

I'm not entirely sure how a roleblock would affect a track. Would they still go to their target or would they stay home?

Are you really trying to confuse us with this post? Talk about useless...

[jonty125]

Mod Note:

Rishaed was a watchmaker. Apologies for mistake on my part.

[pancakemix]

I'm not entirely sure how a roleblock would affect a track. Would they still go to their target or would they stay home?

Are you really trying to confuse us with this post? Talk about useless...

No, I'm actually curious because I saw you visit chuck (actually me) last night. So I'm trying to figure out if you're making things up and letting edoc get pushed for no good reason.

You are still the scummiest person in my eyes, so don't think you can push me either. I will push back.