Best (Randomness) Of 2012 Game Over!

[gregwolf121]

pancake who did you try to watch on N2

[Nebuchadnezer]

I did not lie. Think about it. Kanin gave me the tracker ability...that's what his role did. Pancake didn't lie either.
I'm not sold on edoc.s claim. It's a convenient way for him to get night kills, without added suspicion. However, I can let him slide for now.

so what were you doing visiting me?

I can tell you what I was NOT doing...I was NOT killing you.

[spiesr]

I can tell you what I was NOT doing...I was NOT killing you.

But, what sort of action would you have where it would make sense to target Chuck last night?

[Nebuchadnezer]

I can tell you what I was NOT doing...I was NOT killing you.

But, what sort of action would you have where it would make sense to target Chuck last night?

I can't answer that without giving away my role.

[rishaed]

I think i figured it out though. Took a few hints for me to catch it.

[pancakemix]

So let's break this down:

2. rishaed - Parker, Bodyguard (Alien) (inclined to believe him, told truth about bus)
7. pancakemix - Rigger, Watcher (Pirate's Life) (It's me. Confirmed by Neb)
10. spieser - Roleblocker (PKMN Ch. 2) (Did block me N2)
11. thechuck51 - Bus gifter (Rolegift 2) (Confirmed)
5. edocsil - Vilkas, 2-shot vig (Skyrim) (Sems sketchy. Blocked and no kill, claimed vig and spoke in hypotheticals about it before)

8. crazymilkshake5 replaced by Nebuchadnezer - unclaimed (Didn't lie about visiting chuck, so may or may not be trustworthy. I'm inclined to think he is.)
6. gregwolf121 - unclaimed (nothing)

Considering this, edoc is likely to be scum. Vote Edoc

Everyone remaining seems to be pretty airtight, at least as far as no one seems to be making anything up. That leaves greg as the last remaining unconfirmed. He seems to be scum by process of elimination unless somebody's fibbing.

[spiesr]

I am in favor of lynching edoc'sil at this point. Is there anything else we need to cover before I hammer?

[Nebuchadnezer]

So let's break this down:

2. rishaed - Parker, Bodyguard (Alien) (inclined to believe him, told truth about bus)
7. pancakemix - Rigger, Watcher (Pirate's Life) (It's me. Confirmed by Neb)
10. spieser - Roleblocker (PKMN Ch. 2) (Did block me N2)
11. thechuck51 - Bus gifter (Rolegift 2) (Confirmed)
5. edocsil - Vilkas, 2-shot vig (Skyrim) (Sems sketchy. Blocked and no kill, claimed vig and spoke in hypotheticals about it before)

8. crazymilkshake5 replaced by Nebuchadnezer - unclaimed (Didn't lie about visiting chuck, so may or may not be trustworthy. I'm inclined to think he is.)
6. gregwolf121 - unclaimed (nothing)

Considering this, edoc is likely to be scum. Vote Edoc

Everyone remaining seems to be pretty airtight, at least as far as no one seems to be making anything up. That leaves greg as the last remaining unconfirmed. He seems to be scum by process of elimination unless somebody's fibbing.

This is what I've been rattling around in my head the past few days. I can't honestly say that any of our claims don't add up. There are scenarios and suggestions that can be made with each of the claimed players, but they require leaps of faith (like, spiesr could really be a mafia roleblocker, and chose not to make a kill last night to set up edoc, or rishaed is not a bodyguard, as he refuses to be forthright with his information the next day, etc, etc.). Out of the players left, pancake and thechuck seem to have the best claims that have been backed up and verified.

So, I will go ahead and vote edoc. That'll be the hammer, so I hope I'm right on this.

FASTPOSTED by spiesr (sorry to steal your hammer...)

[edocsil]

You are of course. My faction only had 2 members and no abilities besides the kill. I contemplated just surrendering after the block, but I figured I had a shot. I didn't look at my early play when I was looking for a a fake, something that has proved to cost me. If the game isn't over with my death look at greg. I suspect there is a cult, so also look for players who have not been able to verify their last actions. I had hoped to steer the town towards that once I was clear of the current case, and become more of the "town" hero, but oh well.

[rishaed]

You are of course. My faction only had 2 members and no abilities besides the kill. I contemplated just surrendering after the block, but I figured I had a shot. I didn't look at my early play when I was looking for a a fake, something that has proved to cost me. If the game isn't over with my death look at greg. I suspect there is a cult, so also look for players who have not been able to verify their last actions. I had hoped to steer the town towards that once I was clear of the current case, and become more of the "town" hero, but oh well.

Your initial post on the case after doom was well made. That alone convinced me that you were town. If it wasn't for the fact that you randomly voted chuck in the run-off I don't know if I would have ever voted you.
So well played.
I honestly think that we got extremely lucky with speisr's roleblocks in the last few Nights, but somehow thats how things work.

[jonty125]

edocsil - Jack (Mafia Goon) has been lynched.

rishaed - Parker (Town Bodyguard) has won
gregwolf121 - Vanilla (Vanilla Townie) has won
pancakemix - Rigger (Town Watcher) has won
Nebuchadnezer - Doc (Town Doctor) has won
spieser - Date Masamune (Town Roleblocker) has won
thechuck51 - Busdrive Gifter (Busdrive Gifter) has won

[jonty125]

show: Day One

show: Night One

show: Day Two

show: Night Two

show: Day Three

show: Night Three

[rishaed]

Ooh! Spiesr good job blocking your killer N1! It really helped. (that and mafia botched their fakeclaims) I would have never suspected edoc. And I really did figure out that Neb was a Doc! So happy we didn't force his claim. That being said mafia was way under powered with so many protection roles in the mix

[rishaed]

Hmm and y did hank lie about his N1 action??

[DoomYoshi]

Good game all.

Watcher 2 doc and a bodyguard is an uphill battle for any mafia.