Best (Randomness) Of 2012 Game Over!

[edocsil]

Ok. Two scenarios:
Scenario one: vodean doesn't open his message. Jonty First checks the timestamp and sees vodean has been gone for a couple weeks. I would think jonty wouldn't say anything in the thread.
Scenario two: the message is opened. Jonty wonders why vodean opened the message but isn't posting. He asks in thread why vodean isn't posting.

QED?

QEFail. Jonty sees PM is unopened and that vode is gone, posts in thread saying he will start even if vodean is not seen. Scene starts the game shortly after. Also, Scenario 2 doesn't paint him as scum. It would be unlikely that jonty was looking for vode just because he didn't confirm. He must have seen the unopened PM to notice it.

Source: Lots of modded games and the past times I have done the same thing.

[edocsil]

Ok. Two scenarios:
Scenario one: vodean doesn't open his message. Jonty First checks the timestamp and sees vodean has been gone for a couple weeks. I would think jonty wouldn't say anything in the thread.
Scenario two: the message is opened. Jonty wonders why vodean opened the message but isn't posting. He asks in thread why vodean isn't posting.

QED?

QEFail. Jonty sees PM is unopened and that vode is gone, posts in thread saying he will start even if vodean is not seen. Scene starts the game shortly after. Also, Scenario 2 doesn't paint him as scum. It would be unlikely that jonty was looking for vode just because he didn't confirm. He must have seen the unopened PM to notice it.

Source: Lots of modded games and the past times I have done the same thing.

Vote Doom for being hasty in conclusions

[jonty125]

Hank44Soccer replaces vodean.

[jonty125]

DoomYoshi (3) - rishaed; spiesr; edocsil
Kanin Usagi (2) - gregwolf121; crazymilkshake5
crazymilkshake5 (1) - Kanin Usagi

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch, as things stand a no lynch would be enforced.

Deadline is Wednesday 23 January at 1600 GMT.

[DoomYoshi]

Jonty, was my vote removed due to replacement or am I voteless?

[jonty125]

Jonty, was my vote removed due to replacement or am I voteless?

All votes for vodean, we're not passed on to his replacement.

[Hank44Soccer]

If you vote for me you have a tiny penis!

That was really stupid...

Vote CM5

[rishaed]

Just a quick thought when claiming we really should include the Game that it was from. It makes things easier to check, and town should have no problem doing so seeing as there's no reason to worry about fakeclaiming.

[thechuck51]

If you vote for me you have a tiny penis!

That was really stupid...

Vote CM5

unvote vote hank, welcome to the game

[DoomYoshi]

If you vote for me you have a tiny penis!

That was really stupid...

Vote CM5

unvote vote hank, welcome to the game

Vote thechuck

For stealing my line, and not being shield.

[jonty125]

DoomYoshi (3) - rishaed; spiesr; edocsil
Kanin Usagi (2) - gregwolf121; crazymilkshake5
crazymilkshake5 (2) - Kanin Usagi; Hank44Soccer
Hank44Soccer (1) - thechuck51;
thechuck51 (1) - DoomYoshi;

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch, as things stand a no lynch would be enforced.

Deadline is Wednesday 23 January at 1600 GMT.

[spiesr]

Alright, gotta keep discussion happening or this Day will be a bust.
So let's see, we've got 12 players here. Assuming a straight breakdown with just town and a single scum faction (which I don't know if we can be confident about at this point in time) there would probably like 3 scum members right? Maybe 4? Do we think we can expect a single kill per night or is this going to a be very short? With the role supposed decidedly sort of randomly I don't realy know what to think about how this will all play out.

Anyhow, I still support DoomYoshi and the number one candidate at the moment.

[Kanin Usagi]

Alright, gotta keep discussion happening or this Day will be a bust.
So let's see, we've got 12 players here. Assuming a straight breakdown with just town and a single scum faction (which I don't know if we can be confident about at this point in time) there would probably like 3 scum members right? Maybe 4? Do we think we can expect a single kill per night or is this going to a be very short? With the role supposed decidedly sort of randomly I don't realy know what to think about how this will all play out.

Anyhow, I still support DoomYoshi and the number one candidate at the moment.

There's really no telling, but I would expect at least one third party as well. So maybe three/four scum, one third-party, and six/seven town?

[DoomYoshi]

Spiesr, at what point is it acceptable to advocate the lynch of an absentee player?

[thechuck51]

Vote thechuck

For stealing my line, and not being shield.

it was unintentional I assure you.

Vodean hasn't been on since January 6th. I think we should replace him,

Soundman, however, hasn't posted anything since his confirm but he has been active in other threads. I think we need to get him involved unvote vote soundman