Conquer Club

Accused:

gcohen11


The accused is suspected of:

Other: Abuse of the ratings system.


Comments:
After a torrid game with this player, he left me the poorest ratings possible ....all 1 stars, 4 poor tags. Given his attitude in the game, I wasn't entirely surprised, although it was considerably more excessive than necessary (or justified) and considerably worse than I left him. No matter.

I hadn't actually thought any more about it until, on a visit here to the forum, I saw something about a similar situation. Anyway, decided to look into it further and was shocked when I looked deeper into his ratings. He has played just 167 games and left 134 ratings .... almost all of which are all sh*t like my own. It's quite astonishing to be honest.

The bottom line is I think the guy is abusing the system awfully. Anyone who plays him risks a garbage rating simply for playing the game. Not sure he should be able to get away with it.

For these type of reports, we ask the the accuser gives us 5 examples for us to go from.

I'll go get them ....although a simple glance at his 'Ratings Left' would tell you in an instant.

His last 15 ratings are all a mix of 1 or 0 stars and all with poor tags (as are the bulk of his 134 ratings left).

The last 7 as examples are....

Stars, tags, his opponent, game(s)
1,1,1 - Complainer, Paranoid, Suicider, Vindictive - m1ndgames, 12137205
1,1,1 - Coward, Irrational, Clueless, Poor Strategy - Iceman13, 12226871
1,1,1 - Deadbeat, Irrational, Suicider, Poor Strategy - Rebecca Gavin, 12226871
1,1,1 - Irrational, Vindictive, Cheap Tactics, Follower - prior680, 12202856
1,1,1 - Suicider, Vindictive, Clueless, Good Strategy - saran, 12115407
1,1,1 - Irrational, Suicider, Vindictive, Poor Strategy - albiestar, 12137205, 12117495, 12115407
1,1,1 - Complainer, Sore Loser, Cheap Tactics, Poor Strategy - russtynails, 12202856, 12115407, 12026545

I can't say anything about albiestar (since I've heard the rumors), buut the rest of them. On second thought I get to over Saran, he gives him a one star on Gameplay, but says he has good strategy. ^.^ ROFL

rishaed, I'm sure there may be some justification for some of them ...but for (almost) all of his 134 left? ....nah...

Thank you, will try to look over them tonight.

m1ndgames wrote:rishaed, I'm sure there may be some justification for some of them ...but for (almost) all of his 134 left? ....nah...

I wasn't defending him at all. I just noticed that albie was in there, who I've heard is a perpetual point dumping deadbeat. The rest of them I haven't played against and until I do they have a clean sheet of paper from me.
I am still laughing about the fact that he rated Saran 1 star on gameplay, yet said he had good strategy

gcohen11 has been Warned for Ratings Abuse.

Thanks TFO