[Abandoned] - Medieval Denmark

[ZeakCytho]

I changed my vote from Syaland to the Dark Red in Sweden. So far, the old font seems to be winning, though.

[Balsiefen]

Yes it definatly seems to be a love it or hate it font, thats quite interesting but also rather complicated

[Balsiefen]

Medieval Denmark 1.2

Click image to enlarge.

Current map comments
Okay chaps, I've redone the boarders after the results of the poll, Any good? I've also kept the old font for now, but left the poll and graphics test up in case we need to come to a new descision on that.

[TaCktiX]

I know this is going to sound crazy, but I think that the map looks "bad" because its borders are TOO accurate. There's no generalization on the edges like in other maps, making any stray pixels look bad instantly. I would say instead of total accuracy, scaling it back a little bit and creating straighter lines will help out the map's look tremendously.

[ZeakCytho]

I rather like the current style of borders. It looks like it was hand-drawn, which is good for a medieval map.

[Balsiefen]

One thing about the boarders, i drew them when the background texture was invisible, for some reason, this made rather unnapealing brown bits in the borders, making them look strange. Anyways, I've already started getting rid of those, but it may take a bit before i get enough free time to compleate it.

As for streightening out boarders, I may try to iron it out in a few places where it compromises graphics, but wheter I go further will have to depend on what other people think.

[Balsiefen]

V1.21

Click image to enlarge.

Touched up the boarders to get rid of those grey bits.

[ZeakCytho]

Some of the borders still look a bit pixely.

Do you have names for the Blue and Red continents? I guess you could call them Mid and South Jutland, if you needed to...

I think the water could be made a bit darker still. I like the relative amount of each color in it, just make it darker.

You need attack lines to connect the many island territories.

This is looking good, though

[Balsiefen]

Thanks Zeak

Some of the borders still look a bit pixely.

Righto, could someone pick me an example so I know what I'm looking for?

Do you have names for the Blue and Red continents? I guess you could call them Mid and South Jutland, if you needed to...

I'll look into that.

I think the water could be made a bit darker still. I like the relative amount of each color in it, just make it darker.

Sure, I was holding back a little as I'm a little worried about it getting too similar to the blue in jutland, I'll have a little play anyway.

You need attack lines to connect the many island territories.

This is looking good, though

Aye aye, I'll take a look at doing that as well. Got a free weekend which should help.

[ZeakCytho]

Some of the borders still look a bit pixely.

Righto, could someone pick me an example so I know what I'm looking for?

I think the continent border between Halland and unplayable Sweden, specifically near Hox and Halmstath, is the best example. Other areas include:
Ostaerst - Unplayable
Barae - Othaens
Istathe - Eilaem
Red (?) - Blue (?) continent borders
Lofraeth - Abo

There may be more, but those happened to catch my eye. Also, the border between Laland and Falstaer isn't fully visible - maybe move the Laland text over to the left so it's more clear?

[TaCktiX]

My comments:

Graphics:
- The legend washes out the teal continent's color, so much so that I can't read it
- The color palette seems so...plain and does not remind me of Denmark's awesomeness as the country that had Beowulf and Hamlet. I don't know how to suggest to fix it, but I suppose do a complete rework of the way the map looks.
- The lack of texture makes the entire map go flat. Putting some on it will do wonders, and may invalidate my second comment on graphics.

Gameplay:
- Hard to make comments here as there are no island attack routes as of yet. I'll suggest some:

• Vaendle to Laeso
• Laeso to Fyaerae
• Abo to Anund
• Anund to Halmstath
• Ostaerst to Burghaendaeholm
• Albo to Burghaendaeholm
• Barae to Fakae
• Moon to Fakae
• Imbrae to Laland
• Istathe to Langaeland
• Sundz to Langaeland
• Laland to Langaeland
• Almundae to Othaens
• Abo to Samso
• Samso to Tuzae
• Stro to Lyuthgud

[Balsiefen]

Thanks again guys, All those points I will try to work on.

TaC, on the first post if you click on the first draft map, you'll see a version with the sea routes. A lot of them are the same or very similar to the ones you suggested, but a couple are different. (I actually shaped the rest of the map with those sea routes in mind for gameplay)

[bryguy]

been meaning to comment on this for like a week now, but only have time to comment on one thing


The territory text is almost impossible for me to read

[The Viking]

I would really like to see a version with really light-brown old paper looking oceans.
Also, I think you could choose a bit more readable font.

[Balsiefen]

Whoops, looks like someone thaught I'd abandoned this. Exams and coursework came up and stopped me doing anything for several months. Anywho, in a week it'll all be finished so I'll leave it in here 'till then but EXPECT A MAJOR GRAPHICS UPDATE!