[Official] Circus Maximus REVAMP [Quenched]

[wicked]

Sooo.... how are you going to change playibility? that's what sucks about this map, not the graphics.

[Coleman]

Sooo.... how are you going to change playibility? that's what sucks about this map, not the graphics.

Completely disagree. The playability is why it gets played when it does.

[mibi]

WM this maps looks fantastic, you are very talented... how did you make the people?

[WidowMakers]

WM this maps looks fantastic, you are very talented... how did you make the people?

They are an actual picture of people in a stadium. I them deleted out spaces with different eraser shapes. I added a bevel to the entire crowd to help with the lighting.

[DiM]

since my post seems to be ignored i'll quote it again:

if you look at the bottom image put by molacole you'll see the gates are symmetrical. on top of the gate you have 2 lateral towers and a center one. the center one is really in the center at equal distance from the lateral ones. in your map the center tower is a bit towards the left tower. and this looks strange.

There are many different pictures or renderings of it on the web. I used a different one.



I used different aspects of several images and my own touch. Plus the actual Length to Width of the circus and the map is no where near the same. I have had to make adjustments.

well, in the picture you used the gates are symmetrical while in your map there is clear difference. this kind of asymmetry would have never been accepted in roman architecture. that's why it bugs me.

here's an image to make things clearer:



notice on the photo how the middle tower is right in the middle and the number of arches is the same on each side?

now look at your map. not only the middle tower is not centered but the arches are wrong. you have 4 small arches on the right side and 2 larger ones on the left.

i like that you added the emperor's stand but you should also add the entrance in the lower part. near caligula.


also on the chariots bit. making them bigger would greatly enhance the feel. at the moment they look like fleas. make them bigger and you'll have a nice effect. don't exaggerate with how big you make them though.

the shapes in the middle. the chariots are nice but the rest don't quite fit. where are the dolphins? and what about the symmetry? the have no order, those are just random cubes and cones.


PS: one thing i just noticed. the flags on the emperor's side are waving in the wind while the ones in the bottom part are simple triangles. make those wavy too.

[mibi]

WM this maps looks fantastic, you are very talented... how did you make the people?

They are an actual picture of people in a stadium. I them deleted out spaces with different eraser shapes. I added a bevel to the entire crowd to help with the lighting.

well it looks great, the perspective is really well done.

[Wisse]

also from the symmetry DIM is talking about the things where the crowd is:
the side in the front looks much higher than the other side
and the one in the front the thin part is to thin

It is called perspective. The point of view of the camera makes the close side look thinner. That is the nature of 3D.

yeah but if you would paint a line from thin part near caligvla you will see that part is much thicker while it is not much distance from eachother
and also if you want to make perspective then you must change the thick part to i guess

[yeti_c]

WM this maps looks fantastic, you are very talented... how did you make the people?

They are an actual picture of people in a stadium. I them deleted out spaces with different eraser shapes. I added a bevel to the entire crowd to help with the lighting.

Could you change the colouring of the crowd?

Someone else pointed out that they are mostly Red...

Could you have sections of different supporters for each team taking place?

i.e. a red, green, blue, yellow, cyan and pink section?

C.

PS I prefered my Hoardings idea for names but not sure if it would work?
PPS Prefered the bumpier track.

[plysprtz]

are the arrows still going to be on the track?

[yeti_c]

are the arrows still going to be on the track?

They already are.

C>

[hulmey]

I agree with wicked. Nobody plays this map because game playability is shit. Do you they will play it now because the graphics are better??

It's a tricky one lol

[Coleman]

I thought we all agreed that the rules for revamps are graphic overhalls only. If anyone wants to make a Circvs Maximvs 2.0 go for it.

[AndyDufresne]

There is a difference between people not playing a map because they don't like the style of play it promotes, and people not playing a map because the gameplay is broken. I may not like the style of play Circus Maximus promotes, but I don't think it's broken. I think it is fine and should stay the way it is.


--Andy

[johloh]

I may not like the style of play Circus Maximus promotes, but I don't think it's broken. I think it is fine and should stay the way it is.

exactly. its an original style of gameplay...and people love it or hate it. either way it shouldnt be changed....make a new map if you want different gameplay.

[hulmey]

Exactly why i said its a tricky one lol