Medal Discussions and Index of Medal Suggestions

[Metsfanmax]

I like the ideas with more medals (and I am obviously not the only one...) since it allows people to set different personal goals.

A general thought having read through this and voted: think that no medal should be unatainable. For example, win percentage. That would be unatainable for people who enjoy playing 8-player games. They can be really good at it, but it destroys the win percentage. And that goes for a couple of other medals as well depending on how the rules for them are set. Don't think a particular medal should be out of reach for anyone.

Yes. That seems like a pretty bad idea for a medal.

And once again I'll note that I hate this thread.

Seems to be the first note of this...

This thread is the place where good medal suggestions go to die.

[agentcom]

Seems to be the first note of this...

You may be right ... I think it may have been something I posted in the mod forum. Basically, I don't like mega-topics that merge together disparate ideas. There's no way that this thread will ever be moved to implemented because there's such a mixture of ideas here. And it's hard to keep a topic of discussion alive and well when there are 20 different topics within the same thread. Basically, I agree with this:

This thread is the place where good medal suggestions go to die.

[blakebowling]

Seems to be the first note of this...

You may be right ... I think it may have been something I posted in the mod forum. Basically, I don't like mega-topics that merge together disparate ideas. There's no way that this thread will ever be moved to implemented because there's such a mixture of ideas here. And it's hard to keep a topic of discussion alive and well when there are 20 different topics within the same thread. Basically, I agree with this:

This thread is the place where good medal suggestions go to die.

IIRC, I said it was a bad idea to begin with; but that point is moot.

I'm hoping to get some time to compile all of the medal suggestions, so that they can be easily reviewed.

[agentcom]

We may just have to salvage what we can from this thread and try to separate out all the medal suggestions and then index them somewhere. Then we'd have to scrap the rest in some archive. It's incredibly time consuming work though to go through and un-merge a topic. Oh well, maybe someday we'll get around to this.

[chapcrap]

We may just have to salvage what we can from this thread and try to separate out all the medal suggestions and then index them somewhere. Then we'd have to scrap the rest in some archive. It's incredibly time consuming work though to go through and un-merge a topic. Oh well, maybe someday we'll get around to this.

This is the project that I have been working on...slowly.

Hopefully I can accomplish this when I have a week off before Christmas.

[Dukasaur]

MORE MEDALS!!!!

Why not more cowbell?

[chapcrap]

Split topic a lot and created new OP with links to multiple threads.

[chapcrap]

Updated the OP with a few more medal links.

[chapcrap]

Added two more medals to the list. The newly suggested, Explorer Medal, and the possibly defunct idea of the Lack Sucks Medal.

All told, we're up to 32 separate ideas for medals, achievements, and ribbons that haven't been implemented or rejected yet.

[chapcrap]

Added the Think Fast Medal to the list in the OP.

[chapcrap]

Added this one: BETA Map Medal