Page 64 of 82
Re: Surrender as a game setting / special "move"
Posted:
Wed Nov 28, 2012 1:43 pmby Trephining
Ah, I hadn't gotten as far as thinking of how it would get abused (which would have instantly prompted me to think of how the abuse opportunity could be removed from the function preemptively).
Sorry for the repeat and the misplacement of the thread.
Re: Surrender as a game setting / special "move"
Posted:
Sat Dec 01, 2012 11:57 pmby Little Witt
Only thing that would have a slim chance would be....
If the game has not gone past round 1 and no turns have started, and every player agrees to you leaving. In 1vs1, game is voided and no points or % is gained or lost. In more than 1vs1 player games, leaving player's territories are turned to neutral 3's or whatever the default neutral number is for that map(this shouldn't effect anything at all since it would be round one.
Otherwise, this Idea won't have much of a chance since it has been suggested and rejected many times.
EDIT:....they could also put in a little heads up warning like when a player is ending an assault or deployment or something. You guys all know what I'm talking about
right?
right.
Except this would not be able to be turned off, and would be only for casual games, speed games should be speedy enough there should be no problem.
Re: Surrender as a game setting / special "move"
Posted:
Sun Dec 02, 2012 12:59 amby tkr4lf
It would be nice to have a surrender option that depended on one player holding a certain majority of the terits and/or troops. Say you're in a Das Schloss 1v1 game, and red has most of the board, 3-4 times as many troops as much as green. There is no chance for green to win. Yet, due to the map, it will still be 5-10 rounds before the game can be finished. I can't see something like this being abused much since it still requires a whole game being played, only allowing surrender when defeat was already inevitable.
Re: Surrender as a game setting / special "move"
Posted:
Sun Dec 02, 2012 1:15 amby Little Witt
tkr4lf wrote:It would be nice to have a surrender option that depended on one player holding a certain majority of the terits and/or troops. Say you're in a Das Schloss 1v1 game, and red has most of the board, 3-4 times as many troops as much as green. There is no chance for green to win. Yet, due to the map, it will still be 5-10 rounds before the game can be finished. I can't see something like this being abused much since it still requires a whole game being played, only allowing surrender when defeat was already inevitable.
I don't agree, there are some maps like you said where it would just prolong the game a few rounds, but there are other maps that might also take a while to finish when there seems to be a clear winner and it is just a matter of finishing off your opponent. But I have had a few games where I was on a map and my opponent and me both said gg "knowing" I was gonna win, when soon after that I had the worst dice ever and he came back to win from 5- territories. Who cares if it delays the game a couple of turns that's life.
What I posted above is not the same. I suggested we modify Trephining's idea to just the start of the game for the cases when a player made an error in the game joining and both players would like to end the game quickly without damage to their stats. Since I am well aware this happens a lot I would think my idea would be a lot less subject to abuse since there is no gain. And it would keep people from deadbeating games... like the player
here
Surrendering
Posted:
Sat Dec 08, 2012 12:35 amby TheBudMan
As much as I love playing games on conquer club, and though I dislike losing, a surrender button/option should be implemented. While I've been on this site I've had games where you know for a fact that you're going to lose, but you have to go through every agonizing moment of losing space by space, being slowly pushed back. This is EXTREMELY prominent in Trench games, and it's just painful and boring to play like that. It would be appreciated for something to be implemented, thanks!
Re: Surrender/Resign/Forfeit Button [Rejected]
Posted:
Sat Dec 08, 2012 2:24 pmby chapcrap
TheBudMan wrote:As much as I love playing games on conquer club, and though I dislike losing, a surrender button/option should be implemented. While I've been on this site I've had games where you know for a fact that you're going to lose, but you have to go through every agonizing moment of losing space by space, being slowly pushed back. This is EXTREMELY prominent in Trench games, and it's just painful and boring to play like that. It would be appreciated for something to be implemented, thanks!
This is rejected already.
MOVED and
MERGED.
Re: Surrendering
Posted:
Sun Dec 09, 2012 12:01 amby ender516
TheBudMan wrote:As much as I love playing games on conquer club, and though I dislike losing, a surrender button/option should be implemented. While I've been on this site I've had games where you know for a fact that you're going to lose, but you have to go through every agonizing moment of losing space by space, being slowly pushed back. This is EXTREMELY prominent in Trench games, and it's just painful and boring to play like that. It would be appreciated for something to be implemented, thanks!
It's been said before: if you don't have the patience for a long game, don't play Trench.
Re: Surrender/Resign/Forfeit Button [Rejected]
Posted:
Fri Dec 14, 2012 8:10 amby Gillipig
Suggested a hundred times, rejected a hundred times. When will people get it's a bad idea?
Re: Surrender/Resign/Forfeit Button [Rejected]
Posted:
Sat Dec 22, 2012 1:17 pmby scutzer
I can see both sides, and play other sites that allow this option. Implemented correctly it does work. I might be nice to try it out on 1v1 games to see if it would be useful there and/or when you get down to 1v1 players in a individual/team game.
I assume that this is not wanted since it can give a player an unfair advantage by not having to battle someone, but if there are only 2 people or teams left there is no hard in allowing a surrender. Has this variation on the theme been discussed. If so, I'd love to know the reason why it was rejected. Surely this is an easy feature to implement.
Re: Surrender/Resign/Forfeit Button [Rejected]
Posted:
Sat Dec 22, 2012 5:48 pmby Metsfanmax
scutzer wrote:I can see both sides, and play other sites that allow this option. Implemented correctly it does work. I might be nice to try it out on 1v1 games to see if it would be useful there and/or when you get down to 1v1 players in a individual/team game.
I assume that this is not wanted since it can give a player an unfair advantage by not having to battle someone, but if there are only 2 people or teams left there is no hard in allowing a surrender. Has this variation on the theme been discussed. If so, I'd love to know the reason why it was rejected. Surely this is an easy feature to implement.
The idea has been, if you can surrender with only two players in a game, then multis will make a bunch of games against each other and just surrender for really easy points, or something like that.
Re: Surrender/Resign/Forfeit Button [Rejected]
Posted:
Sat Dec 22, 2012 9:12 pmby Kaskavel
SirSebstar wrote:it HAS been abused in the past, heavely abused. I can think of various ways it can be abuse in this day and age.
Trust me, there is no way this suggestion can ever work without heavy monitoring.
and also, suppose you are in that KC2 game, and the power goes out for the other guy. bazinga, you win...
but yea, pro tip, do not play trench in hives
Hive still needs a resign button even without the trench setting.
Re: Surrender/Resign/Forfeit Button [Rejected]
Posted:
Sat Jan 12, 2013 4:01 pmby chapcrap
MERGED an old surrender thread I found.
Re: Surrender/Resign/Forfeit Button [Rejected]
Posted:
Tue Jan 15, 2013 12:00 amby Metsfanmax
chapcrap wrote:MERGED an old surrender thread I found.
Congrats on getting us up to 100 pages
Need a Forfeit Button
Posted:
Thu Jan 24, 2013 3:47 pmby jeffbroomhead
This will help provide a gentlemanly way to concede when it's obvious that we have lost and don't want to waste everyone's time by either throwing the game to one of the players or to force a 3-turn missed a turn exit.
Re: Need a Forfeit Button
Posted:
Thu Jan 24, 2013 4:15 pmby greenoaks
jeffbroomhead wrote:This will help provide a gentlemanly way to concede when it's obvious that we have lost and don't want to waste everyone's time by either throwing the game to one of the players or to force a 3-turn missed a turn exit.
you need to become friends with 'search'
Re: Surrender/Resign/Forfeit Button [Rejected]
Posted:
Thu Jan 24, 2013 4:36 pmby chapcrap
Metsfanmax wrote:chapcrap wrote:MERGED an old surrender thread I found.
Congrats on getting us up to 100 pages
Thanks. Just got another one
MERGED.
jeffbroomhead wrote:This will help provide a gentlemanly way to concede when it's obvious that we have lost and don't want to waste everyone's time by either throwing the game to one of the players or to force a 3-turn missed a turn exit.
Jeff, this has been rejected before because people can abuse the surrender option to give someone else a lot of points.
Forfeit Button
Posted:
Sun Jan 27, 2013 11:48 amby qwertylpc
Concise description:- When a player doesn't have a chance in a game, they will surrender, kind of like chess, knocking over your king.
Specifics/Details:- When a player doesn't have a chance in a game, they will surrender.
- It will be for standard games (it could cause huge problems with terminator and assassin, team games can be discussed below)
- If it were implemented for team games, then all members of the team would have to agree.
How this will benefit the site and/or other comments:- I understand some people say this will be abused, but with trench, it is now more important than ever especially on a large map.
- Maybe limit it to after 10 rounds this button will work
- Maybe only limit it to 1v1 because it could significantly alter a 3 player game.
You can select 2 poll options, because 1 is the type of game it would be in, and the other deals with the trench settings
Re: Forfeit Button
Posted:
Sun Jan 27, 2013 12:03 pmby Seulessliathan
search is your friend
Re: Surrender/Resign/Forfeit Button [Rejected]
Posted:
Sun Jan 27, 2013 1:27 pmby chapcrap
MERGED this one.
qwertylpc wrote:Concise description:- When a player doesn't have a chance in a game, they will surrender, kind of like chess, knocking over your king.
Specifics/Details:- When a player doesn't have a chance in a game, they will surrender.
- It will be for standard games (it could cause huge problems with terminator and assassin, team games can be discussed below)
- If it were implemented for team games, then all members of the team would have to agree.
How this will benefit the site and/or other comments:- I understand some people say this will be abused, but with trench, it is now more important than ever especially on a large map.
- Maybe limit it to after 10 rounds this button will work
- Maybe only limit it to 1v1 because it could significantly alter a 3 player game.
You can select 2 poll options, because 1 is the type of game it would be in, and the other deals with the trench settings
Re: Surrender/Resign/Forfeit Button [Rejected]
Posted:
Wed May 22, 2013 7:31 pmby Melkor52
I have a suggestion on the Surrender button topic. Perhaps it was suggested in the 100 pages that I didn't read, and sorry if it was. But why not make the Surrender Button an option on the side stats for each player. When clicked (you should be able to toggle it off or on), it means you realize that the game is beyond hope and are willing to surrender. It would only work if everyone but one player (the winner) also clicked their surrender button as well.
This way no one could abuse the thing, and no one would gain an advantage due to a single player leaving the game. It's only use would be to end a game that everyone is ready to concede as lost. I personally like trench games, but sometimes it can be tedious to play out a game that has already been decided but will take another week to finish because of slow movement on a large map.
Just my $0.02
Melkor52
Re: Surrender/Resign/Forfeit Button [Rejected]
Posted:
Tue May 28, 2013 6:31 pmby Metsfanmax
Melkor52 wrote:I have a suggestion on the Surrender button topic. Perhaps it was suggested in the 100 pages that I didn't read, and sorry if it was. But why not make the Surrender Button an option on the side stats for each player. When clicked (you should be able to toggle it off or on), it means you realize that the game is beyond hope and are willing to surrender. It would only work if everyone but one player (the winner) also clicked their surrender button as well.
An example of why this doesn't solve the abuse problem is that you could just have two friends join up a game together in a 1v1, and have one of them click surrender to intentionally give the other points.
Re: Surrender/Resign/Forfeit Button [Rejected]
Posted:
Tue May 28, 2013 6:50 pmby Melkor52
Metsfanmax wrote:Melkor52 wrote:I have a suggestion on the Surrender button topic. Perhaps it was suggested in the 100 pages that I didn't read, and sorry if it was. But why not make the Surrender Button an option on the side stats for each player. When clicked (you should be able to toggle it off or on), it means you realize that the game is beyond hope and are willing to surrender. It would only work if everyone but one player (the winner) also clicked their surrender button as well.
An example of why this doesn't solve the abuse problem is that you could just have two friends join up a game together in a 1v1, and have one of them click surrender to intentionally give the other points.
True that, but if that was someone's goal they need only start a game and deadbeat for the other. But I do see your point. Perhaps, the surrender option would only show up after 10 or 15 rounds to avoid the abuse, or say five days. Then just dead beating would have been quicker and easier.
Well anyway, I'm not going to flog a dead horse. I would just like to have had a way to finish up a large trench game when the outcome is unquestioned. So I just threw in my two cents to see if it would have helped. Thanks for your time and effort in helping to improve the site.
Melkor52....
Re: Surrender/Resign/Forfeit Button [Rejected]
Posted:
Wed May 29, 2013 4:43 amby SirSebstar
lack of the surrender button makes no game for certain until it ends. a player could go missing for 3 days and give your the win........
and you would miss out if you had already surrendered....
Trench concede button
Posted:
Fri Jun 28, 2013 10:00 amby IanG7
Concise description:- Would help get rid of the annoyance of having to spend so many rounds finishing off a clearly defeated opponent by allowing them to concede, thereby lifting the trench restriction of the person they are being defeated by.
Specifics/Details:- There are times in games where it becomes obvious that there's no coming back but due to the trench restriction on the winning team it takes 10+ rounds for a stack of 50 troops to knock off 10 single territs.
I propose that teams/ individuals that are clearly defeated should have the option of a concede button which would lift the trench setting, only from the would be victor (to avoid a concession and a hidden stack to run wild from the conceded team), so that the games can be closed out more quickly.
Game 12860133 is a decent enough example to illustrate, we have 25 guys on Elslab stacked up against their singles to the West and they've conceded that there's no coming back
How this will benefit the site and/or other comments:- This would help tournament organizers as they can move to the next rounds of their tournaments more quickly and in general all trench games from the nuisance of a delayed finish.
Re: Trench concede button
Posted:
Fri Jun 28, 2013 10:10 amby BGtheBrain
*****