Moderator: Clan Directors
drunkmonkey wrote:I'm filing a C&A report right now. Its nice because they have a drop-down for "jefjef".
Chariot of Fire wrote:Take the total number of official maps on CC (add a few betas that will go 'live' within 6 months), find a number that divides nicely into the total e.g 11, 12, 13, 14, then put that number of clans in the league. Each fortnight a clan creates its home games (if there are 144 maps and 12 clans, then this figure would be 12) and in the week in between it plays 12 away games. Every map on CC is to be used, and once only. This would really decide who is the best 'all round' clan on CC.
IcePack wrote:I agree...there are so many leagues, I'd like to see what clans prefer. This one is easier to schedule / administer, and also easier to plan for as a clan which is entering.
One of the biggest concerns people have voiced about ICL is the schedule and so many little sets with no easy way to plan. This would alleviate a lot of those concerns.
What do the other clans think? I'd like to see a consolidation of all these leagues into something.
IcePack
chapcrap wrote:I do like the setup. I would agree with IcePack about lowering the number in each league to 10-13. This is to makes all leagues more even in numbers and shorten the season a little bit.
Here is the problem, can we just have one league? I don't care if it's ICL or this or something else, but let's have one clan league, and one Cup, and have it end at that.
freakns wrote:chapcrap wrote:I do like the setup. I would agree with IcePack about lowering the number in each league to 10-13. This is to makes all leagues more even in numbers and shorten the season a little bit.
Here is the problem, can we just have one league? I don't care if it's ICL or this or something else, but let's have one clan league, and one Cup, and have it end at that.
this x10000000000000000000000000000000
benga wrote:freakns wrote:chapcrap wrote:I do like the setup. I would agree with IcePack about lowering the number in each league to 10-13. This is to makes all leagues more even in numbers and shorten the season a little bit.
Here is the problem, can we just have one league? I don't care if it's ICL or this or something else, but let's have one clan league, and one Cup, and have it end at that.
this x10000000000000000000000000000000
So why did you start ICL?
Also I really haven't seen anywhere that your or any other clan must participate in every event?
Again I am repeating, qwert's suggestion here is about improving CL!!!
benga wrote:qwert is here proposing format for CL5
not another league
----------------------------------------by MichelSableheart Ā» Sat May 19, 2012 11:27 am
I like the idea of a promotion/degradation league system, but I have some doubts whether it's maintainable. My main concern is the stability of the clan world. With a season lasting a year, I'm affraid we may see more changes then a promotion/degradation system can handle. Clans split, fall apart, new clans are formed, clans can pick up a set of strong players...
If I remember correctly, Tofu had to start in the bottom division as a new clan in CL2, but due to it's roster everyone knew that they would trounce that division. Similar problems may happen in this structure, where new but very good clans get paired against the weakest clans around. Also, what would happen if one of the top clans in the premier division disbanded?
In footbal, a promotional/degradational system works because you can be reasonably sure that teams won't vary in strength too much from season to season.
I like the idea of a promotion/degradation league system, but I have some doubts whether it's maintainable. My main concern is the stability of the clan world. With a season lasting a year, I'm affraid we may see more changes then a promotion/degradation system can handle. Clans split, fall apart, new clans are formed, clans can pick up a set of strong players...
If I remember correctly, Tofu had to start in the bottom division as a new clan in CL2, but due to it's roster everyone knew that they would trounce that division. Similar problems may happen in this structure, where new but very good clans get paired against the weakest clans around. Also, what would happen if one of the top clans in the premier division disbanded?
In footbal, a promotional/degradational system works because you can be reasonably sure that teams won't vary in strength too much from season to season.
jefjef wrote:Ok. I read OPs post and chaps and Ice's post above me.
What I do NOT like is:
"Clan's cannot use the same map more than one time in League."
What I DO like is:
Clans may use same map twice but different team size.
Chariot of Fire wrote: Every map on CC is to be used, and once only. This would really decide who is the best 'all round' clan on CC.
IcePack wrote:I think my changes to the suggestion would be this:
Premier League: top 12
First League: 13-24
Second League: 25-36
I would add a playoff (even if its technically a seperate "event") that includes top 4 of Premier, top 2 of First and Second League.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users