Random League III-close pls

[IcePack]

As it doesn't say in the first post, is trench allowed?

Well if it doesn't say it's not allowed

I asked a straight question, you obviously couldn't give a straight answer. Initially created games dropped, someone else from FISO may or may not take this on, I withdraw, I've wasted enough of my time on it,

Wow, didn't take much to have you drop out. IMO it was pretty straight forward.
Kinda seems like an extreme reaction to a small problem (if you can call it a problem).

[Vid_FISO]

As it doesn't say in the first post, is trench allowed?

Well if it doesn't say it's not allowed

I asked a straight question, you obviously couldn't give a straight answer. Initially created games dropped, someone else from FISO may or may not take this on, I withdraw, I've wasted enough of my time on it,

Wow, didn't take much to have you drop out. IMO it was pretty straight forward.
Kinda seems like an extreme reaction to a small problem (if you can call it a problem).

Maybe (it's even more extreme than just this) I have my issues, I have my reasons. Life is incredibly shit at times and when it's made more shit then it's time to walk away from those things that make it worse.

[benga]

FISO is removed from Random League, if this is a problem, then problem is solved now.

[kizkiz]

Am I right in thinking its gone something like this....
1. Vid asks if trench is allowed and TO says yes
2. Tournament starts and games created
3. Dynasty throw toys out of pram at thought of playing 6 whole trench games
4. TO changes rules to ban trench

We've played an entire clan war in trench and iirc only one game went more than 20 rounds. Just stick a round limit on trench games if that's the issue?
Or are dynasty just scared they might lose? Lol

[kizkiz]

As it doesn't say in the first post, is trench allowed?

Well if it doesn't say it's not allowed

I asked a straight question, you obviously couldn't give a straight answer. Initially created games dropped, someone else from FISO may or may not take this on, I withdraw, I've wasted enough of my time on it,

Wow, didn't take much to have you drop out. IMO it was pretty straight forward.
Kinda seems like an extreme reaction to a small problem (if you can call it a problem).

There's more to it than just that.
Rules appear to have been changed after the tourney has started purely to benefit one clan. I'm not privy to exactly what has been said in pm, but hopefully benga can clarify on here.

[happyfeet]

Am I right in thinking its gone something like this....
1. Vid asks if trench is allowed and TO says yes
2. Tournament starts and games created
3. Dynasty throw toys out of pram at thought of playing 6 whole trench games
4. TO changes rules to ban trench

We've played an entire clan war in trench and iirc only one game went more than 20 rounds. Just stick a round limit on trench games if that's the issue?
Or are dynasty just scared they might lose? Lol

no you are wrong the TO never said it was allowed. its not listed as an option. he said if it doesnt say then its not allowed. you just need to read the rules.

[IcePack]

As it doesn't say in the first post, is trench allowed?

Well if it doesn't say it's not allowed

I asked a straight question, you obviously couldn't give a straight answer. Initially created games dropped, someone else from FISO may or may not take this on, I withdraw, I've wasted enough of my time on it,

Wow, didn't take much to have you drop out. IMO it was pretty straight forward.
Kinda seems like an extreme reaction to a small problem (if you can call it a problem).

There's more to it than just that.
Rules appear to have been changed after the tourney has started purely to benefit one clan. I'm not privy to exactly what has been said in pm, but hopefully benga can clarify on here.

We will see. Doesn't matter at this point anyway since FISO quit.

[kizkiz]

Am I right in thinking its gone something like this....
1. Vid asks if trench is allowed and TO says yes
2. Tournament starts and games created
3. Dynasty throw toys out of pram at thought of playing 6 whole trench games
4. TO changes rules to ban trench

We've played an entire clan war in trench and iirc only one game went more than 20 rounds. Just stick a round limit on trench games if that's the issue?
Or are dynasty just scared they might lose? Lol

no you are wrong the TO never said it was allowed. its not listed as an option. he said if it doesnt say then its not allowed. you just need to read the rules.

Actually, he said it was. The sentence he wrote needed a comma in the middle to make it a negative. At best the answer was ambiguous

[happyfeet]

ALLOWED SETTINGS
-all games are auto & seq
-spoils: no, flat, escalating and nuclear
-reinforcements: adjacent, chained and unlimited
-fog on or off

is this clear? in the first post.

[IcePack]

Am I right in thinking its gone something like this....
1. Vid asks if trench is allowed and TO says yes
2. Tournament starts and games created
3. Dynasty throw toys out of pram at thought of playing 6 whole trench games
4. TO changes rules to ban trench

We've played an entire clan war in trench and iirc only one game went more than 20 rounds. Just stick a round limit on trench games if that's the issue?
Or are dynasty just scared they might lose? Lol

no you are wrong the TO never said it was allowed. its not listed as an option. he said if it doesnt say then its not allowed. you just need to read the rules.

Actually, he said it was. The sentence he wrote needed a comma in the middle to make it a negative. At best the answer was ambiguous

Pretty clear as happy pointed out, it's not lists under ALLOWED settings. It's not allowed.

[kizkiz]

ALLOWED SETTINGS
-all games are auto & seq
-spoils: no, flat, escalating and nuclear
-reinforcements: adjacent, chained and unlimited
-fog on or off

is this clear? in the first post.

Yes, that's clear
'twas the clarification that caused confusion. A simple yes or no would have saved any trouble.
Anyway, I apologise to dynasty for any aspersions cast and hope everyone enjoys the tourney.
Vid has a few things going on in real life, and appears to have pulled us out. First any of the rest of us have heard about any of this.

[benga]

Trench is not allowed and I never stated otherwise, seems to me all understood that except FISO.

Hopefully everything is ok in his life.

[kizkiz]

Trench is not allowed and I never stated otherwise, seems to me all understood that except FISO.

Hopefully everything is ok in his life.

I'll leave you with a quick example of why correct punctuation is important
Lets eat, grandpa
Lets eat grandpa

[HOWITZERHAL]

Am I right in thinking its gone something like this....
1. Vid asks if trench is allowed and TO says yes
2. Tournament starts and games created
3. Dynasty throw toys out of pram at thought of playing 6 whole trench games
4. TO changes rules to ban trench

We've played an entire clan war in trench and iirc only one game went more than 20 rounds. Just stick a round limit on trench games if that's the issue?
Or are dynasty just scared they might lose? Lol

ALLOWED SETTINGS
-all games are auto & seq
-spoils: no, flat, escalating and nuclear
-reinforcements: adjacent, chained and unlimited
-fog on or off

is this clear? in the first post.

Yes, that's clear
'twas the clarification that caused confusion. A simple yes or no would have saved any trouble.
Anyway, I apologise to dynasty for any aspersions cast and hope everyone enjoys the tourney.
Vid has a few things going on in real life, and appears to have pulled us out. First any of the rest of us have heard about any of this.

lmao.....no offense taken my friend......all i did was, when FISO pm'med me about his games being ready..... I looked at everyone elses games. What I found was that only FISO made trench games...I mean all 6 of them were trench......I remembered FISO's earlier post regarding trench and sent a cordial reply to FISO and benga asking for clarification of the "no trench rule".....Actually I love trench, since I didn't make the rulz, I feel that I (and the rest of us) should abide by them...didn't kow it would cause a shit storm.......too funny


BTW here is the post I to sent to FISO and benga, asking for clarification:

As it doesn't say in the first post, is trench allowed?

Well if it doesn't say it's not allowed

Hi

our home games have been created, all random, trench, none, chained, fog

12178908 dubs
12178909 dubs
12178912 trips
12178910 trips
12178913 quads
12178914 quads

good luck!

Dave

didn't you say that trench is not allowed????? lol

just checkin'