General Clan Achievement Medal Badge[poll

[qwert]

well, i think that this thread are go to much forward(and you have poll,where people all ready for long period vote). I think that these be not correct, maybe later when these voting process be finish,and when they create new topic,with new set of possible medals.

[Darwins_Bane]

alright I will leave this here for now then.

[qwert]

thanks darwin

[Dako]

I think it might be worth to PM Andy or lack about this suggestion.

Clan medals (for challenges) would be a great addon!

[qwert]

"by Dako on Tue Oct 12, 2010 3:44 pm

I think it might be worth to PM Andy or lack about this suggestion.

Clan medals (for challenges) would be a great addon!"
Why? when i give sugestions for Unique Map Achivement medal,and Consecutive Wins Medals,i dont contact Andy or Lack- these is sugestion forum,and you post your sugestions,and then Moderators and comunity can give possitiove or negative reply.

[lackattack]

Qwert, this is a great idea! While it will be up to jpcloet and his department on how to award the medal, Andy has instructed me to instal a new medal for clan acheivements. I like your design, but I think it could be better if the shield was modified to look more like a coat of arms and less like a defensive shield. This way it would be more obvious what the medal represents - you belong to a group of players. Maybe something that resembles more like these:








P.S. If we use anyone's design for this medal, the designer will get a General Contribution medal for contributing website graphics.

[eddie2]

ok another quick ? is there going 2 be a medal for the players who take the clan privs on. like the tourney privs get.

[Darwins_Bane]

Stickied.

[qwert]

Qwert, this is a great idea! While it will be up to jpcloet and his department on how to award the medal, Andy has instructed me to instal a new medal for clan acheivements. I like your design, but I think it could be better if the shield was modified to look more like a coat of arms and less like a defensive shield. This way it would be more obvious what the medal represents - you belong to a group of players. Maybe something that resembles more like these:








P.S. If we use anyone's design for this medal, the designer will get a General Contribution medal for contributing website graphics.

Ok,i understand what you mean,i will try something, but you know CC only have red star emblem, and will be hard to find something what its related to CC to represend coat of arms,but i will try to find.

[qwert]

ok ,im work on something to look like coat of arms, but with these small size,i only manage to create these, its will be good that also other give hes shots to.

[jpcloet]

ok another quick ? is there going 2 be a medal for the players who take the clan privs on. like the tourney privs get.

I would say unlikely at this point. The volume is just not there right now, it is under consideration though.

I do have other medal plans

[Sniper08]

I do have other medal plans

care to share the idea with the rest of us

btw dont let this thread die this is a great suggestion.

[jpcloet]

Doesn't really matter at this point what this thread does, it is stickied anyways. Medals has been on the Clan Director's plate since early-mid 2009 and more recent conversations with the CLA group has narrowed the focus around medals and requirements etc.

[qwert]

i think that these tread will not die. Its good that people and moderators move in same direction, and that soon or later these will be implemented. Who will create these ,its not to much importan,its importan that these will be accepted for most of people, like good addition to medal list.

[qwert]

Well news are great,and i hope that i give a little help to new medal, but some thing i belive need to be beter describe

However, in order to receive a Clan Achievement Medal, the war and players will need to meet ALL of the following criteria:

Wars:

A War must be of a minimum 41 games, and must have a specific defined process for determining a winner, prior to the start of the War. A random triples neutral game is recommended.
War restrictions must adhere to the basic restrictions inherently built by clans meaning No Freestyle, No Manual, No Speed
The game composition must comprise 100% Team Games. Recommended setup is 25% Doubles, 25% Triples, 25% Quadruples and 25% Choice of Team Games
Clan Wars must be fairly negotiated
Must be considered a reasonably fair War, meaning farming of medals will not be allowed. Any questionable war will be discussed first by the Clan Directors and if any further discussion is needed, the Clan Leader's Association will be consulted.
A minimum of 10 players must be used.
Both Clans must follow the 1 Clan Rule
Clan War thread must be adequately documented to ensure medals are properly given out, primarily game numbers and winner

Players:

Be on the winning clan
Have played the minimum game requirement (See Example)
Have a minimum of 1 win

like i suggested in topic,in clan forum, its better to change 40+1( in case of tiebreak, minimum of one game its required,to determine winner for clan medal award)

Min Games = Total Spots / Players Used * Participation Factor

Total Spots available (eg 20D 20T 21Q) = (20*2 + 20*3 +21*4) = 184 total spots
Players Used = Example is 15 players
Participation Factor initially set to 50%
The bare minimum, regardless of the formula will be 3 games.

Therefore

Min Games = RoundDown (184 /15 *0.5) = 6 games in this example

.
For these part i can not agree, because you can be in situation where one player participiate in 4-5 games,and he can lost all ,but hes clan can win chalenge,and he dont deserve to get medal??
Im more for rule that need to play in 3 game( no win requirement) to get medal,if hes clan win a chalenge.
In these way if you have 184 spots-then even clan with 60 members can distributed to each member can play 3 games in one chalenge.
Also im against to all members get medal, when he dont play any of game in clan chalenge, these is apsurd,and will get medal for nothing. I hope that jpcloet will reconsider sugestions,to get good rules for apply to clan medal.