Haha woodruff and Thezzaruz...you both make very good points. But, it would decrease the amount of point dumping greatly b/c if one person continually lost games while dumping, they would slowly become unsuccessful. It would also give them more of a reason not to dump. I also believe that it would decrease the amount of multis much more than you think, as I have a friend (he had like 8 accounts and was busted) who made more accounts b/c he wanted to play more games (this is just one example). Also, the population on the site would increase because of less multis and dumpers, less people will be banned. Yes, CC already has many privileges that other sites do not, but this could inspire older higher ranked freemiums to rejoin the site, and also encourage new recruits who thought they could play more to continue to play. In regards to noob farming, it would decrease because there would be less noobs to farm. They would gain more experience much quicker, thus not being noobs after a certain amount of time. Also, the money made by the site would not necessarily decrease. However, since all of the points from both sides of the argument are borderline questionable, could CC possible put this plan or something like it in for a week, and see what results? That may be the only answer, instead of constantly arguing over the same ideas (which will never resolve it).
Haha...i wrote all of that and then saw jp's post. So I will respond to that in this post as well. I highly doubt that it would increase multis b/c the freemiums may be more satisfied now (but I may easily be wrong here). Clans do want premium members (although the one I am in accepts both), but if this plan was put in place clans would want freemiums b/c they could play in more clan games. Noobs are everywhere, but they would gain experience much quicker, thus getting rid of them much quicker. Point-dumping is done mostly by premiums, but freemiums to do it sometimes as well, thus decreasing it a little. All of your points are legitimate, I just feel that my plan COULD improve the site.