Moderators: Global Moderators, Discussions Team

spiesr wrote:This is not an option right now.
If you want to have this option be available in the future you should post in this suggestion thread.

spiesr wrote:This is not an option right now.
If you want to have this option be available in the future you should post in this suggestion thread.
Gillipig wrote:spiesr wrote:This is not an option right now.
If you want to have this option be available in the future you should post in this suggestion thread.
No point in posting in an archived suggestion thread, he should make a new thread, with a slightly different suggestion.
Which he could do here:
viewforum.php?f=4

chapcrap wrote:Gillipig wrote:spiesr wrote:This is not an option right now.
If you want to have this option be available in the future you should post in this suggestion thread.
No point in posting in an archived suggestion thread, he should make a new thread, with a slightly different suggestion.
Which he could do here:
viewforum.php?f=4
No. That's completely wrong. If you want to suggest something and a thread is already there, then post in it. Threads can be moved out of archives.
Gillipig wrote:chapcrap wrote:Gillipig wrote:spiesr wrote:This is not an option right now.
If you want to have this option be available in the future you should post in this suggestion thread.
No point in posting in an archived suggestion thread, he should make a new thread, with a slightly different suggestion.
Which he could do here:
http://www.conquerclub.com/forum/viewforum.php?f=4
No. That's completely wrong. If you want to suggest something and a thread is already there, then post in it. Threads can be moved out of archives.
But they usually aren't. If he want to suggest something and be taken seriously he need to modify the old suggestion somewhat, and if he does that, it's no longer the same suggestion and should have it's own thread.

chapcrap wrote:Gillipig wrote:chapcrap wrote:Gillipig wrote:spiesr wrote:This is not an option right now.
If you want to have this option be available in the future you should post in this suggestion thread.
No point in posting in an archived suggestion thread, he should make a new thread, with a slightly different suggestion.
Which he could do here:
viewforum.php?f=4
No. That's completely wrong. If you want to suggest something and a thread is already there, then post in it. Threads can be moved out of archives.
But they usually aren't. If he want to suggest something and be taken seriously he need to modify the old suggestion somewhat, and if he does that, it's no longer the same suggestion and should have it's own thread.
I'm a mod in that area and I am letting you know that's how we prefer it. We don't want multiple threads for the same thing. We can edit the OP as the discussion goes in a different direction. If that thread gets going again, I'll gladly move it back from archives.
chapcrap wrote:We don't want multiple threads for the same thing.
Gillipig wrote:chapcrap wrote:Gillipig wrote:chapcrap wrote:Gillipig wrote:spiesr wrote:This is not an option right now.
If you want to have this option be available in the future you should post in this suggestion thread.
No point in posting in an archived suggestion thread, he should make a new thread, with a slightly different suggestion.
Which he could do here:
viewforum.php?f=4
No. That's completely wrong. If you want to suggest something and a thread is already there, then post in it. Threads can be moved out of archives.
But they usually aren't. If he want to suggest something and be taken seriously he need to modify the old suggestion somewhat, and if he does that, it's no longer the same suggestion and should have it's own thread.
I'm a mod in that area and I am letting you know that's how we prefer it. We don't want multiple threads for the same thing. We can edit the OP as the discussion goes in a different direction. If that thread gets going again, I'll gladly move it back from archives.
I'm speaking from the users perspective and I'm telling you how it works. If he wants attention for his suggestion, posting in an archived thread is not the way to get it! Because people don't go lurking in there. Besides, I never said he should interfere with this:chapcrap wrote:We don't want multiple threads for the same thing.
I said he should modify the suggestion and make a new thread.
Gillipig wrote:Obviously the old suggestion was archived so it was never going to fly. Only a new improved suggestion could stand a chance to be implemented. Unless you want to tell me that you discard suggestions prematurely.

chapcrap wrote:Gillipig wrote:Obviously the old suggestion was archived so it was never going to fly. Only a new improved suggestion could stand a chance to be implemented. Unless you want to tell me that you discard suggestions prematurely.
When suggestions die, they go to archived because people stop caring enough to continue the discussion. Archived is not Rejected. There are separate forums for each. Archived threads are ALL up for grabs and can be moved back to Suggestions.


Jippd wrote:I see what gillipeg is saying though.
So you mean to tell me as mods if someone posts an updated thought in an archived thread you will move it out of archived into suggestions because of that one post?
Because if you don't then as gillipeg says nobody else will see it and the idea may not get the exposure that it deserves. I have never once checked an archived forum since I have been on CC.

Jippd wrote:well if you do that then I agree there is nothing wrong with posting in archives. I shouldn't be spending any time on these forums at all I can't add more to my to check list.

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests