Moderator: Community Team
Players dropped: NeroTolScaeva (You are already playing 4 games - please upgrade to Premium Membership to remove this limitation.)
saxitoxin wrote:Serbia is a RUDE DUDE
may not be a PRUDE, but he's gotta 'TUDE
might not be LEWD, but he's gonna get BOOED
RUDE
chapcrap wrote:It looks like you already have 4 games going on, so they probably didn't give you a game because of that. Looks like about 51 people didn't get a game because of this. Check it out: https://www.conquerclub.com/player.php? ... ment_id=86
Serbia wrote:If you're going to have auto-tournaments, you should develop some method of weeding out the ineligible players BEFORE the thing starts, just like any community-based organizer would have to do.
NeroTolScaeva wrote:chapcrap wrote:It looks like you already have 4 games going on, so they probably didn't give you a game because of that. Looks like about 51 people didn't get a game because of this. Check it out: https://www.conquerclub.com/player.php? ... ment_id=86
Oh. I didn't see any rules about that and it said Entry: All comers. Seems a bit unfair to have let me sign up for it then.
Anyways, I'll just make sure I have an open slot for any future tournaments. Thank you for the reply!
saxitoxin wrote:Serbia is a RUDE DUDE
may not be a PRUDE, but he's gotta 'TUDE
might not be LEWD, but he's gonna get BOOED
RUDE
Serbia wrote:I'm officially protesting this whole entire tournament. If you're going to have auto-tournaments, you should develop some method of weeding out the ineligible players BEFORE the thing starts, just like any community-based organizer would have to do.
Metsfanmax wrote:Serbia wrote:I'm officially protesting this whole entire tournament. If you're going to have auto-tournaments, you should develop some method of weeding out the ineligible players BEFORE the thing starts, just like any community-based organizer would have to do.
What you're asking for is literally impossible. Since the game load is only one game at a time, the only way to know whether they're ineligible is to check at the start of the tournament whether they have four games or not (we could in principle only allow people to join the tournament if they don't have four games active at the time of joining, but this doesn't make much sense and obviously wouldn't solve the problem). At that point, there are only two choices: force them to lose the round, or boot them from the tournament and wait until another 50 players sign up. The former makes much more sense.
In the world of community tournaments, how would this problem be resolved for tournaments with only one game at a time, aside from making it premium only? If there were a 512 person tournament run by a TO, the exact same types of problems would happen. The only thing community tournaments have that autos don't, in this respect, is reserves.
sempaispellcheck wrote:Metsfanmax wrote:Serbia wrote:I'm officially protesting this whole entire tournament. If you're going to have auto-tournaments, you should develop some method of weeding out the ineligible players BEFORE the thing starts, just like any community-based organizer would have to do.
What you're asking for is literally impossible. Since the game load is only one game at a time, the only way to know whether they're ineligible is to check at the start of the tournament whether they have four games or not (we could in principle only allow people to join the tournament if they don't have four games active at the time of joining, but this doesn't make much sense and obviously wouldn't solve the problem). At that point, there are only two choices: force them to lose the round, or boot them from the tournament and wait until another 50 players sign up. The former makes much more sense.
In the world of community tournaments, how would this problem be resolved for tournaments with only one game at a time, aside from making it premium only? If there were a 512 person tournament run by a TO, the exact same types of problems would happen. The only thing community tournaments have that autos don't, in this respect, is reserves.
Why not allow people to sign up as reserves for auto-tourneys, then? Even if it means people have to wait, it's much more fair than simply letting the opponent through.
sempai
DoomYoshi wrote:Just do a check on their slots and book it for them. Easy.
Metsfanmax wrote:DoomYoshi wrote:Just do a check on their slots and book it for them. Easy.
These tournaments could take weeks to fill. Seems unfair to book the slot for all that time.
Return to Conquer Club Discussion
Users browsing this forum: No registered users