samgrossy wrote:ShaggyDan wrote:Alright sorry for inactivity guys, it's a long story.
I am Mr X. Town JOAT (I'm guessing an algebra reference where x can be different values?)
Night one: Doc'd Geegel
Night two: Made self bulletproof (Wasn't told that this didn't work)
Night three: Tracked Elonpuckhog (Sigh)
Night four: No action (saving final ability)
I can't remember the rationale for each of these choices (seems so long ago...) but I can re-read and do my best if its a big deal.
I'm not fully caught up yet, just saw that this was desperately needed, going to catch up briefly on other games then come back here.
Just in case you wanted my input, this passed my test. JOAT can do all sorts of things. X is the most common variable in math. IMHO shaggy is telling the truth.
This day can't be going on much longer. We need to really make a decision about the lynch.
I'm still not very comfortable with relying so heavily on flavor to verify a claim. There seems to be a lot of rationalizing after the fact.
For example, could you tell me what zimmah (Mr. T) was? If zimmah came out and claimed something, than you would come up with some reason for his flavor to fit his role. But it's not like you can use that solely to clear/incriminate someone.
I'd like to bring up a very quick aside as the vodean modkill. We know there were 2 kills on Night 1. One was mafia and one was SKer. After vodean was modkilled, we haven't had more than 1 NK a night for 2 consecutive nights. If the SKer was still alive, it would incredible luck to kill the same person as the mafia/have the target be saved twice in a row. While I don't have concrete evidence, the numbers seem to point at vodean being the SKer.