Crazy's Super crazy mafia. End Game: PGO wins!

[zimmah]

with 7 people a miss-lynch is quite costly, but on the other hand a no lynch is not very useful either.

still, i'd say, if we don't have a decent lead, i'd vouch for a no lynch, since lynching just for the sake of lynching does not give us enough information to warrant the loss of a player in such a small game, where we may have as little as 5 townies. On the other hand, if there's any reason to assume a lynch will provide a good lead for the next day, we should surely do it, as sacrificing a townie to catch a scum may seriously hurt the mafia since they too have very small numbers.

with so little players the game will probably end in like day 3 no matter what side wins, so even if there are any investigative roles in the game they will have very little opportunity to get some information out, if even they survive that long.

fixed typos

[new guy1]

Well zimmah, the first page says that it will be very unbalanced towards town, making me believe this isnt your normal C9 game, etc.

[crazymilkshake5]

Offical Vote Count

NoS-Vodean
kanin-elon
elon-kanin
vodean-NG1


Deadline will be extended till October (3 ish days)

[vodean]

my vote on NoS was serious. i thought he was jumpy and defensive about the joke-votes on him.

[VioIet]

Well zimmah, the first page says that it will be very unbalanced towards town, making me believe this isnt your normal C9 game, etc.

I re-read through page one to make sure that I wasn't skimming or blatantly missing something. I did not see any posts where crazymilkshake5 referred to this game as a C9. I wonder how I could've missed that? It could be great if someone could quote that post for me.

[zimmah]

Well zimmah, the first page says that it will be very unbalanced towards town, making me believe this isnt your normal C9 game, etc.

I re-read through page one to make sure that I wasn't skimming or blatantly missing something. I did not see any posts where crazymilkshake5 referred to this game as a C9. I wonder how I could've missed that? It could be great if someone could quote that post for me.

Didn't ng1 just state this is not a c9?

[NoSurvivors]

Well zimmah, the first page says that it will be very unbalanced towards town, making me believe this isnt your normal C9 game, etc.

I re-read through page one to make sure that I wasn't skimming or blatantly missing something. I did not see any posts where crazymilkshake5 referred to this game as a C9. I wonder how I could've missed that? It could be great if someone could quote that post for me.

Didn't ng1 just state this is not a c9?

Not sure how to take this.. but I think ng1 said it was not your REGULAR c9 mafia... could be taken as 2 things:

-he thinks its C9 mafia but not an ordinary one
-he was making a reference to this mafia not being regular and COMPARING it to c9 style

[Kanin Usagi]

Well zimmah, the first page says that it will be very unbalanced towards town, making me believe this isnt your normal C9 game, etc.

I re-read through page one to make sure that I wasn't skimming or blatantly missing something. I did not see any posts where crazymilkshake5 referred to this game as a C9. I wonder how I could've missed that? It could be great if someone could quote that post for me.

Didn't ng1 just state this is not a c9?

Not sure how to take this.. but I think ng1 said it was not your REGULAR c9 mafia... could be taken as 2 things:

-he thinks its C9 mafia but not an ordinary one
-he was making a reference to this mafia not being regular and COMPARING it to c9 style

All I saw was the original post by Crazy which said that it was likely to be unbalanced in very small letters at the bottom. I don't think I saw anything else about it.

[Kanin Usagi]

Maybe new guy1 knows something we don't about the roles?

[crazymilkshake5]

Mod Note taken from front page: Front page

Click image to enlarge.

[zimmah]

Well zimmah, the first page says that it will be very unbalanced towards town, making me believe this isnt your normal C9 game, etc.

considering this quote and the above mod post, why does ng1 claim that the game is specifically unbalanced towards town?

[new guy1]

Okay, I dont know which question Im being asked at this point, but I will clarify and say by my quote (that has been quoted above by zimmah) and explain that by "normal c9" I was saying it is not a c9, and I was saying that it is not a c9 because typically c9 setups are balanced, and because he is saying it is going to be unbalanced I figured that it is not a c9 game. If you need more clarification, ask. Also, the mod might have edited it, or I might have been seeing things (most likely answer), but I thought I saw something that said that it was going to be unbalanced towards town, but again I might have read it wrong. Did that answer all your questions?

[elonpuckhog]

Vote Kanin Kanin calls out me and vio for not posting anything of substance while not pointing out two other people that did not post anything of substance. Meanwhile, it was very difficult to tell that they were posting anything of substance. It may not be much, but it sure is a place to start.

[Kanin Usagi]

Vote Kanin Kanin calls out me and vio for not posting anything of substance while not pointing out two other people that did not post anything of substance. Meanwhile, it was very difficult to tell that they were posting anything of substance. It may not be much, but it sure is a place to start.

I never once claimed anything about you two. I was just trying to get the two most inactive to start posting. I pointed out Vio as well, but Vio hasn't once mentioned it, so she obviously isn't as concerned about it. You, on the other hand, have been extremely defensive about it from the beginning. I haven't even mentioned it at all on this page, but you're bringing it back up? And no, it isn't a place to start. New guy1 is a place to start from his (potential) slip, but the moment anyone attempts to focus on that, you try and place everyone's focus on me, something that looks extremely scummy.

Vote elonpuckhog for being extremely defensive about something that I haven't even brought up in two days and trying to get everyone focused on me when they should be trying to work out a potential scum slip.

And lest you think I'm about to go inactive myself, I'm leaving for work in about twenty minutes, so I won't be on again for at least ten hours.

[vodean]

Okay, I dont know which question Im being asked at this point, but I will clarify and say by my quote (that has been quoted above by zimmah) and explain that by "normal c9" I was saying it is not a c9, and I was saying that it is not a c9 because typically c9 setups are balanced, and because he is saying it is going to be unbalanced I figured that it is not a c9 game. If you need more clarification, ask. Also, the mod might have edited it, or I might have been seeing things (most likely answer), but I thought I saw something that said that it was going to be unbalanced towards town, but again I might have read it wrong. Did that answer all your questions?

why would you think its C9? do you have a C9 role? are you mafia goon?

FOS elon for voting with a poor reason, and then FOS kanin for OMGUS. both of you stop it.