Moderator: Community Team
Iliad wrote:The upside of calling everyone scum and making 1000 predictions is that statistically you should get a few right.
DoomYoshi wrote:spiesr or Rodion for capturing jak so quickly. They were voices of reason in the cacophony of bullshit I was trying to push.I think it's a bit unfair for certain players to see how much effort they've put into this and lost, and the shoggoth and elder things doing absolutely nothing and being quite useless all won quite in spite of them!
This is the reason people hate cults on mafiascum, although here on CC, we love them.
rishaed wrote:Honestly speaking I would say we had different MVP's throughout the game. At the beginning I think Doom did very well in that aspect. Then it changed to the Yith, and late in game somewhere between me/betiko (i know bad form and all that). Picking one for me isn't really viable, as an overall MVP. (Oh and did I forget about Nendreel, who made an insane good call on who to revive throughout the game?)
jak111 wrote:Personally, even though I seen through Hippo though I was dead to be able to say anything... I'd say Hippo for MVP for lasting sooo long. He was a con artist and none of you could see through him until basically only town remained. Which in my eyes was pretty sad. He even got two worshippers. Which again was good on his part.
I still believe my offer should of held more water than it did especially with now looking at everyone's roles. Only 4 people as far as I can tell would have lost. LittleWitt, Ghostly, CMS, and Lord Voldemort. Due to win conditions everyone else could have won XD Making 22/26 winners
Nendreel wrote:My first suggestion for MVP would be NG1, with his goal of being a Survivor he certainly earned it by being the ONLY person who wasn't killed in this game.
Betiko, even if he is tooting his own horn, still had a tough Post Restriction and Role to deal with and lasted so long while being a very active player.
Rishaed, while in a similar boat wasn't as active so he gets a lower rating the Betiko.
I think the last suggestion I'll make is Hippo for lasting so long even when being pretty scummy, both before and after achieving his WC.
rishaed wrote:After looking through the actions. . . . Why were the yith trying to kill so many people off????!!!
betiko wrote:by the way /, how long did it take you to adjust the whole concept and game mechanics? you added player roles at some point, what were they, extra unaligned normal humans?
betiko wrote:does / gets to vote? I see he remains neutral, but he's the one who has been monitoring absolutely everything and understanding (or not!) everyone's motives in all situations. definitely the best to judge.
other idea, since it's so hard to chose an MVP for this game as we all had our ups and downs, and we all agree that this was the best/one of the best games ever on this site I vote MVP /.
by the way /, how long did it take you to adjust the whole concept and game mechanics? you added player roles at some point, what were they, extra unaligned normal humans?
/ wrote:betiko wrote:by the way /, how long did it take you to adjust the whole concept and game mechanics? you added player roles at some point, what were they, extra unaligned normal humans?
Not too long, it was pretty much a sliding scale if I recall.
If player # was <X I would lessen certain factions to 2, if it was greater I would add an extra Elder thing, Shoggoth, etc.
I even had a few extra roles to throw into the mix if it was extra huge, actually I believe Shoggoth was one of the roles added to balance out the mix.
I think there was a rough ratio to be added to each faction to do a quick balance.
Also, thanks I appreciate the sentiment, but I don't want MVP. Even on the occasions I do play, I can't handle more than three or so games, sorry.
Rodion wrote:So, my WC reverted back to "town" when I died?
/ wrote:Actually, Nendreel could reanimate zombies back to normal humans while they were still "alive" once he achieved his win condition. I hinted at such, mentioning he could use his action on certain players in the "alive" list, but I suppose he either didn't want to, or didn't catch the hint.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users