Conquer Club

vodean wrote:i think this is a ballsy ploy from ghostly/newguy/edoc. there is nothing on jonty. he shouldnt claim! they probably arent all scum, but i think that two of them might be. we should lynch a late day to find out, imo. or me. whichever we think will give the most intel

How am I in on this? I pegged a scum D1, I think PCM was scum based on his reaction, and I am less certain about the last lynch. TBH I don't see what is particularly compelling to vote jonty.

ghostly447 wrote:Call me a hypocrite and paint a red target sign on my head but Imma vote jonty on this one. When I seemed to have skimmed, I claimed. By being unable to simply look at all those days and then making an incorrect evaluation which would have further caused suspicion cast on me, new guy1, and edoc, it could have turned out bad. I dont have anything better to go on.

I made a mistake, call it skimming if you wish but I made a mistake and that's all it was.

I don't think we should lynch vodean, even for information. I don't really like the idea of mislynching intentionally unless it's for a pretty solid gain.
Not sure who to vote for right now, so I guess I'll have to go with the unvoting majority.

Nendreel wrote:I don't think we should lynch vodean, even for information. I don't really like the idea of mislynching intentionally unless it's for a pretty solid gain.
Not sure who to vote for right now, so I guess I'll have to go with the unvoting majority.

I think no one has a clue on who to vote today anyways....

vodean wrote:i think this is a ballsy ploy from ghostly/newguy/edoc. there is nothing on jonty. he shouldnt claim! they probably arent all scum, but i think that two of them might be. we should lynch a late day to find out, imo. or me. whichever we think will give the most intel

I didnt vote anyone. Therefore, I did not make a ploy.

Unvote. Its been a long past couple days for me in real life, but I was trying to get him to jump.

Will update this tomorrow. 830 AM exam.

Vote Count

Kanin (1) - vodean

Ok, that's a lynch if the deadline of yesterday is observed. If anyone wants me to prod players and extend deadline by 2 days, I will. You have to PM why you think this is a good idea. Also, if anyone objects I won't do it. Once again, object via PM.

Ok. So far we have people in both camps. I will allow a 24 hr extension, from this point. A few people made some good points about the need for an extension. Namely that I didn't provide any vote counts, reminders of deadline or prods during the day.

Prodding pcm, as he is the only one to not post during Day 5.

ok, I see no reason not to say it. No way kanin gets lynched, he is my mason buddy so the only one I fully trust here. If I didn't reveal this now and he got lynched he couldn't have backed me up.

I'll just vote soundman because he isn't participating much and as far as I know any lynch is better than the one of a 100% confirmed town i can privately speak to.

For one, masons are not 100% always town. I know that in past games town has been masoned with mafia. But I will also say that it is better to lynch someone else over someone who is actually masoned with other people who are probably town (I know it's wifomy, but why would he come out and post about it if there was a chance of us still lynching kanin), so I will also vote soundman, but will be prepared to take my vote off if a better candidate should arise.

Sound is supposed to be claimed as a what?

new guy1 wrote:For one, masons are not 100% always town. I know that in past games town has been masoned with mafia. But I will also say that it is better to lynch someone else over someone who is actually masoned with other people who are probably town (I know it's wifomy, but why would he come out and post about it if there was a chance of us still lynching kanin), so I will also vote soundman, but will be prepared to take my vote off if a better candidate should arise.

I'll confirm, yes, I am masoned with Betiko. >_> Didn't know I was that close to a lynch. And both my role/name and his were in blue in our role message, so I'm sure Betiko and I are both town.

edocsil wrote:Sound is supposed to be claimed as a what?

we know nothing about him.

day 1 vodean
night 1: PCM (unknown alignment politician lynched day 6)
day 2 Ghostly (VT?)
night 2:?
day 3:?
night 3?
day 4:?
night 4: NoSurvivors (lynched day 2, VT?)
day 5:?
night 5: Gregwolf (lynched day 1 mafia vote disabler, 100% dead)
day 6 iron butterfly (town? double voter)
night 6: ?
day 7: ?

jonty (claimed town vote stealer)
edocsil (softclaimed town power role)
new guy1 (softclaimed night)
soundman
nendreel
Kanin Usagi (claimed day, betiko claimed town mason with betiko)
betiko (claimed town mason with kanin)


and our role PM clearly stated that we were both town masons in blue, also giving each other the day/night each one of us is. There is no chance they mixed a scum and a town as masons, unless doom did something really really twisted and unballanced. We know between each other that we are 100% clear.

Alright, didnt know.

yeah i didnt really want to lynch kanin. at least not on that info/point in time, and i do even less now. we need a lynch though... unvote vote soundman. i dont support it as a lynch, but i guess its better than nothing.

Obligatory post because of prod.

I'm not going to throw my vote on sound, he is going to get lynched regardless and I don't know if I'll be around to unvote, if he claims a PR.

pancakemix wrote:Obligatory post because of prod.

Fascinating. Do tell more.

edocsil wrote:

pancakemix wrote:Obligatory post because of prod.

Fascinating. Do tell more.

Well, I got a pm from doom that said he understood why I wasn't talking but I hadn't posted yet today. So here I am. Ain't much more to tell.

jonty125 wrote:I'm not going to throw my vote on sound, he is going to get lynched regardless and I don't know if I'll be around to unvote, if he claims a PR.

well if he does show up get ready to come back and vote whatever, there are 2 double voters. hey is your action a day action or a night action jonty?

betiko wrote:

jonty125 wrote:I'm not going to throw my vote on sound, he is going to get lynched regardless and I don't know if I'll be around to unvote, if he claims a PR.

well if he does show up get ready to come back and vote whatever, there are 2 double voters. hey is your action a day action or a night action jonty?

I'm a night action. That's generally how vote stealers work.

jonty125 wrote:OK, I'm going to call bull on this one. Because I'm Town Vote Stealer, and town with two vote stealing roles is OP. I only steal the vote for one day. I need it to become night before I can use my power. So unvote, vote pcm

pancakemix wrote:

edocsil wrote:

pancakemix wrote:Obligatory post because of prod.

Fascinating. Do tell more.

Well, I got a pm from doom that said he understood why I wasn't talking but I hadn't posted yet today. So here I am. Ain't much more to tell.

Yeah. I suppose. I still feel like you should be making an effort to manipulate us. We don't KNOW you are scum, just that a few of us believe it. W/e I suppose it's your call after all.

betiko wrote:I'll just vote soundman because he isn't participating much and as far as I know any lynch is better than the one of a 100% confirmed town i can privately speak to.

By your logic you should be voting IB. He's been participating even less then I have.

This has all been one very long continuous Day 1. All I have left is my gut feeling. And my gut is only a little suspicious of Edoc at this time.

soundman wrote:

betiko wrote:I'll just vote soundman because he isn't participating much and as far as I know any lynch is better than the one of a 100% confirmed town i can privately speak to.

By your logic you should be voting IB. He's been participating even less then I have.

This has all been one very long continuous Day 1. All I have left is my gut feeling. And my gut is only a little suspicious of Edoc at this time.

IB has been participating significantly more than you throughout this game and we know everything about him, not just 100% sure if town or mafia double voter though. He is being less active these last few days but he is one of the guys who contributed the most IMO. He would definitely not be my second choice.

given the time left, you'd rather claim or start a second wagon cause right now you are getting lynched.