Page 5 of 18

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Sun Jan 13, 2013 8:30 pm
by TA1LGUNN3R
Metsfanmax wrote:
thechuck51 wrote:
rishaed wrote:
TA1LGUNN3R wrote:
jonty125 wrote:unovte (if needed) vote rishaed for ending the joke phase way too early.


This post and its position in relation to others bothered me. unvote vote jonty

Mmmhh... I wholeheartedly support rule 13.

Annie's Boobs better be a character in this game.

-Tails

I guess its something, and somewhere to go vote Jonty

Rishaed, are you voting because "its something" or is it because its somebody other than you?


That case is incredibly thin, even for a day one vote.


Not sure which you're referencing here. Chuck's point against rishaed or my vote against jonty?

-Tails

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Sun Jan 13, 2013 8:53 pm
by anamainiacks
TA1LGUNN3R wrote:
jonty125 wrote:unovte (if needed) vote rishaed for ending the joke phase way too early.


This post and its position in relation to others bothered me. unvote vote jonty

Mmmhh... I wholeheartedly support rule 13.

Annie's Boobs better be a character in this game.

-Tails

I don't get what's so suspicious about the post and its positioning... Care to explain more, or was that a joke vote that you randomly threw out?

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Mon Jan 14, 2013 12:47 am
by TA1LGUNN3R
anamainiacks wrote:
TA1LGUNN3R wrote:
jonty125 wrote:unovte (if needed) vote rishaed for ending the joke phase way too early.


This post and its position in relation to others bothered me. unvote vote jonty

Mmmhh... I wholeheartedly support rule 13.

Annie's Boobs better be a character in this game.

-Tails

I don't get what's so suspicious about the post and its positioning... Care to explain more, or was that a joke vote that you randomly threw out?


It was just sort of riding that wave of where general criticism was on rishaed for 'ending' the joke vote phase. Y'know, going with the flow.

It's D1, don't expect great things.

-Tails

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Mon Jan 14, 2013 10:49 am
by jonty125
Rishaed's vote on me is plain OMGUS.

TA1LGUNN3R wrote:It was just sort of riding that wave of where general criticism was on rishaed for 'ending' the joke vote phase. Y'know, going with the flow


I've already explained why my vote is 3rd on the wagon, I was giving rishaed a chance to fight his corner; but I can see where you're coming from.

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Mon Jan 14, 2013 1:17 pm
by Metsfanmax
TA1LGUNN3R wrote:
Metsfanmax wrote:
thechuck51 wrote:
rishaed wrote:
TA1LGUNN3R wrote:
jonty125 wrote:unovte (if needed) vote rishaed for ending the joke phase way too early.


This post and its position in relation to others bothered me. unvote vote jonty

Mmmhh... I wholeheartedly support rule 13.

Annie's Boobs better be a character in this game.

-Tails

I guess its something, and somewhere to go vote Jonty

Rishaed, are you voting because "its something" or is it because its somebody other than you?


That case is incredibly thin, even for a day one vote.


Not sure which you're referencing here. Chuck's point against rishaed or my vote against jonty?

-Tails


My comment is in reference to the vote against jonty. Obviously jonty's statement is weird, and he doesn't have a real case, but I don't see anything vote-worthy about it. Sorry for the confusion.

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Mon Jan 14, 2013 3:43 pm
by Commander9
jonty125 wrote:It's D1, we're not going to get much of a case, and rishaed's slip is probably the best thing we're going to get (barring lynch the inactive.)


I normally am against lynching the innactives - it's better to get them replaced. So far, I see absolutely no reason why should we hurry and do the lynch just yet...

TA1LGUNN3R wrote:Annie's Boobs better be a character in this game.

-Tails


That would be very cool - who doesn't love Annie's Boobs?

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Tue Jan 15, 2013 9:44 pm
by thechuck51
The game is slowing down... I suggest we pressure rishaed for a claim to get things moving againsince he has been acting the scummiest in my opinion.

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Tue Jan 15, 2013 9:52 pm
by rishaed
Hmmm. . . the hints i have left haven't been enough huh. Like I said, you really don't want to lynch me unless you are scum. Should I bold/make large the important part of that sentence. Now find some other tree to bark up. You really are wasting time on me, I hate repeating myself when I was trying to leave clues behind for those who are clever enough to get them.

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Tue Jan 15, 2013 9:53 pm
by Metsfanmax
rishaed wrote:Hmmm. . . the hints i have left haven't been enough huh. Like I said, you really don't want to lynch me unless you are scum. Should I bold/make large the important part of that sentence. Now find some other tree to bark up. You really are wasting time on me, I hate repeating myself when I was trying to leave clues behind for those who are clever enough to get them.


This is not a particularly compelling case. Saying "please don't kill me guys" is unlikely to throw attention off of you, and you should know that. I don't think that the case is strong enough against you to force a claim just yet, but you're getting there.

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Tue Jan 15, 2013 10:15 pm
by anamainiacks
Metsfanmax wrote:
rishaed wrote:Hmmm. . . the hints i have left haven't been enough huh. Like I said, you really don't want to lynch me unless you are scum. Should I bold/make large the important part of that sentence. Now find some other tree to bark up. You really are wasting time on me, I hate repeating myself when I was trying to leave clues behind for those who are clever enough to get them.


This is not a particularly compelling case. Saying "please don't kill me guys" is unlikely to throw attention off of you, and you should know that. I don't think that the case is strong enough against you to force a claim just yet, but you're getting there.

Well to be fair, the case against him wasn't particularly strong in the first place, so what are we expecting him to say to defend himself, other than 'sorry for ending the joke vote phase early'?

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Tue Jan 15, 2013 10:21 pm
by Metsfanmax
anamainiacks wrote:
Metsfanmax wrote:
rishaed wrote:Hmmm. . . the hints i have left haven't been enough huh. Like I said, you really don't want to lynch me unless you are scum. Should I bold/make large the important part of that sentence. Now find some other tree to bark up. You really are wasting time on me, I hate repeating myself when I was trying to leave clues behind for those who are clever enough to get them.


This is not a particularly compelling case. Saying "please don't kill me guys" is unlikely to throw attention off of you, and you should know that. I don't think that the case is strong enough against you to force a claim just yet, but you're getting there.

Well to be fair, the case against him wasn't particularly strong in the first place, so what are we expecting him to say to defend himself, other than 'sorry for ending the joke vote phase early'?


That might be a start. There's not enough of a wagon on him at this point, to be defending himself so strenuously.

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Wed Jan 16, 2013 2:54 am
by rishaed
rishaed wrote:
blakebowling wrote:
rishaed wrote:Okay, nobody has posted a Joke Vote in awhile so first off unvote. Unfortunately I really don't think anyone slipped up in the phase so I got nothin'. OF course that might not be true tomorrow.

I'm curious as to why you "ended" the joke-vote phase so quickly. Honestly, why you felt you needed to end it at all.

Okay, maybe it was my mistake, I'm usually on quite a bit during the day off and on so the time elapsed in a Mafia game for me feels long, and I mistakenly thought we had gone through 1/2 days. I'm still bad in guessing where the Joke Vote phase ends, I guess I never really get the meaning of it, other than to have fun and maybe catch something interesting. So excuse me for ending it you guys can go right ahead like Witt. :P

This was my reason why earlier (jonty viewed this as a slip?) my reasons and explanation haven't changed.. B/c it's honestly what I was thinking. And I guess it did start generating meaningful discussion. So the original post wasn't completely useless. So if you aren't happy with this I don't know what to tell you.

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Wed Jan 16, 2013 3:35 am
by aage
7. You may vote ‘no lynch’ to end the day without a death.

8. Maximum length of game days is 14 actual days.

Just a reminder.

Also, in my benevolence I may decide to end the day on Friday/Saturday if activity stays low.

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Wed Jan 16, 2013 10:39 am
by jonty125
rishaed wrote:I was trying to leave clues behind for those who are clever enough to get them.


48/72 hours until deadline, I think we should get rish to claim, its the best we've seen so far today. And also, if you've been breadcrumbing (dropping hints, call it what you like), I find that scummy as if one person can read your claim then everyone can including scum, so its effectively softclaiming under little/no pressure.

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Wed Jan 16, 2013 11:38 am
by anamainiacks
Metsfanmax wrote:
anamainiacks wrote:
Metsfanmax wrote:
rishaed wrote:Hmmm. . . the hints i have left haven't been enough huh. Like I said, you really don't want to lynch me unless you are scum. Should I bold/make large the important part of that sentence. Now find some other tree to bark up. You really are wasting time on me, I hate repeating myself when I was trying to leave clues behind for those who are clever enough to get them.


This is not a particularly compelling case. Saying "please don't kill me guys" is unlikely to throw attention off of you, and you should know that. I don't think that the case is strong enough against you to force a claim just yet, but you're getting there.

Well to be fair, the case against him wasn't particularly strong in the first place, so what are we expecting him to say to defend himself, other than 'sorry for ending the joke vote phase early'?


That might be a start. There's not enough of a wagon on him at this point, to be defending himself so strenuously.

True not much of a wagon yet, but it sounds like the only one currently being called under suspicion by the people posting is him, so a wagon would easily form if that were the case? After looking through his posts again though, it sounds like he's implying he's in a role that benefits the townies.

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Wed Jan 16, 2013 11:45 am
by jonty125
anamainiacks wrote:it sounds like he's implying he's in a role that benefits the townies.


Would he claim anything that benefits scum?

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Wed Jan 16, 2013 7:37 pm
by gregwolf121
a claim would benefit scum

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Wed Jan 16, 2013 8:50 pm
by anamainiacks
jonty125 wrote:
anamainiacks wrote:it sounds like he's implying he's in a role that benefits the townies.


Would he claim anything that benefits scum?

Well no, but I'm just pointing it out because people are starting to pressure for a claim, and that's the closest to one he's given so far (:

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Thu Jan 17, 2013 10:36 am
by jonty125
I meant claim a role that benefits scum.

@Gregwolf, claims can benefit scum, yes but they can also benefit town.

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Thu Jan 17, 2013 1:30 pm
by rishaed
If you guys feel a claim is necessary, I'll be more than willing to give one. However if possible I would really like not to give one.

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Sat Jan 19, 2013 4:44 pm
by rishaed
Anyone there? It seems like things are stalling. . . so what are we gonna do? I'm going to have to look back through to see what I can pick up.

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Sat Jan 19, 2013 11:03 pm
by Hank44Soccer
Could we get a vote count?

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Sun Jan 20, 2013 4:11 pm
by thechuck51
we are close to going into night 1 with a no lynch. to me rish has been the scummiest and i think we need to at least pressure him for a claim so we go into the night with something. then we could at least test his claim then go on from there.

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Mon Jan 21, 2013 3:59 am
by jonty125
thechuck51 wrote:we are close to going into night 1 with a no lynch. to me rish has been the scummiest and i think we need to at least pressure him for a claim so we go into the night with something. then we could at least test his claim then go on from there.


+1, he's been softclaiming throughout the thread but that's no good.

Re: Community [13/13] Day one

PostPosted: Mon Jan 21, 2013 11:58 am
by aage
Votecount

jonty (3) Blake, Tailgunner, rishaed
Rishaed (5) Chuck, Little Witt, Iron Butterfly, Jonty, Hank44soccer
Blake (1) Gregwolf
Tailgunner (1) Commander9
Hank44Soccer (1) Anamainiacs


Scene will be posted in a few minutes. As of now, day one has ended.

Since Vodean has been replaced in other games I will do the same.