Moderator: Community Team
Yeah, I am not buying that claim at all I am afraid. I will be holding my vote for the moment though as I am not ready for the Day to end quite yet. We still have 3(!) players who haven't posted yet this Day. While Commander and Witt are likely to be perpetual dead weight Metsfanmax has been sufficiently active in other games. Did he just forget about this one or something? Can we get a prod on him aage?gregwolf121 wrote:yes i do wish to defend myself, so i am britta perry one-shot town doc, and no i have not used my power yet because it is rather limited and i haven't seen anyone in need of protection yet,
spiesr wrote:Yeah, I am not buying that claim at all I am afraid. I will be holding my vote for the moment though as I am not ready for the Day to end quite yet. We still have 3(!) players who haven't posted yet this Day. While Commander and Witt are likely to be perpetual dead weight Metsfanmax has been sufficiently active in other games. Did he just forget about this one or something? Can we get a prod on him aage?gregwolf121 wrote:yes i do wish to defend myself, so i am britta perry one-shot town doc, and no i have not used my power yet because it is rather limited and i haven't seen anyone in need of protection yet,
TA1LGUNN3R wrote:Honestly I'm always uneasy about lynching a doc claim.
-Tails
spiesr wrote:Can we get a prod on him aage?
gregwolf121 wrote:yes i do wish to defend myself, so i am britta perry one-shot town doc, and no i have not used my power yet because it is rather limited and i haven't seen anyone in need of protection yet,
Metsfanmax wrote:gregwolf121 wrote:yes i do wish to defend myself, so i am britta perry one-shot town doc, and no i have not used my power yet because it is rather limited and i haven't seen anyone in need of protection yet,
This power does seem rather strange but there is no way Britta is not in this game and I find it very unlikely that she is not town. So unless someone counterclaims I am not voting greg.
anamainiacks wrote:Like the others have said, a 1-shot doc does seem rather underpowered, especially for Britta Perry, one of the 7 core characters of the series. Additionally, I'm not sure what about her character would convey such a role. But how many solid roles can there be to appropriately fill the 7 core characters?
Or maybe there is no simple pattern as to which characters are scum. Until one of them turns up dead there is no way to know for sure.jonty125 wrote:WIFOM - Maybe not all the 'core' characters are in the game. Maybe mafia were given 1 or 2 for fakeclaims.
spiesr wrote:Or maybe there is no simple pattern as to which characters are scum. Until one of them turns up dead there is no way to know for sure.jonty125 wrote:WIFOM - Maybe not all the 'core' characters are in the game. Maybe mafia were given 1 or 2 for fakeclaims.
I don't know much of anything about this game's flavor, my objections to gregwolf's claim are based on the role he claimed. I have reason to suspect this game has an actually doctor. As such I don't see why there would be a 1-Shot Doctor in addition to this. Accordingly, his claim looks to me like a poorly done fake, perhaps attempting to draw out the real Doctor. Anyhow, it looks like it is now clear to put my vote back. Vote gregwolf.
Metsfanmax wrote:spiesr wrote:Or maybe there is no simple pattern as to which characters are scum. Until one of them turns up dead there is no way to know for sure.jonty125 wrote:WIFOM - Maybe not all the 'core' characters are in the game. Maybe mafia were given 1 or 2 for fakeclaims.
I don't know much of anything about this game's flavor, my objections to gregwolf's claim are based on the role he claimed. I have reason to suspect this game has an actually doctor. As such I don't see why there would be a 1-Shot Doctor in addition to this. Accordingly, his claim looks to me like a poorly done fake, perhaps attempting to draw out the real Doctor. Anyhow, it looks like it is now clear to put my vote back. Vote gregwolf.
I hate to have to point this out, but it's entirely possible he was lying about the one-shot nature of his doc ability to make himself appear a less attractive night kill to the mafia.
anamainiacks wrote:Metsfanmax wrote:spiesr wrote:Or maybe there is no simple pattern as to which characters are scum. Until one of them turns up dead there is no way to know for sure.jonty125 wrote:WIFOM - Maybe not all the 'core' characters are in the game. Maybe mafia were given 1 or 2 for fakeclaims.
I don't know much of anything about this game's flavor, my objections to gregwolf's claim are based on the role he claimed. I have reason to suspect this game has an actually doctor. As such I don't see why there would be a 1-Shot Doctor in addition to this. Accordingly, his claim looks to me like a poorly done fake, perhaps attempting to draw out the real Doctor. Anyhow, it looks like it is now clear to put my vote back. Vote gregwolf.
I hate to have to point this out, but it's entirely possible he was lying about the one-shot nature of his doc ability to make himself appear a less attractive night kill to the mafia.
Well if he's a full-fledged doctor and lied about it, he's trading in attracting the mafia for attracting a lynch, which isn't entirely wise either.
Out of curiosity, what is this 'reason' you speak of, spiesr?
Metsfanmax wrote:spiesr wrote:Or maybe there is no simple pattern as to which characters are scum. Until one of them turns up dead there is no way to know for sure.jonty125 wrote:WIFOM - Maybe not all the 'core' characters are in the game. Maybe mafia were given 1 or 2 for fakeclaims.
I don't know much of anything about this game's flavor, my objections to gregwolf's claim are based on the role he claimed. I have reason to suspect this game has an actually doctor. As such I don't see why there would be a 1-Shot Doctor in addition to this. Accordingly, his claim looks to me like a poorly done fake, perhaps attempting to draw out the real Doctor. Anyhow, it looks like it is now clear to put my vote back. Vote gregwolf.
I hate to have to point this out, but it's entirely possible he was lying about the one-shot nature of his doc ability to make himself appear a less attractive night kill to the mafia.
jonty125 wrote:Metsfanmax wrote:spiesr wrote:Or maybe there is no simple pattern as to which characters are scum. Until one of them turns up dead there is no way to know for sure.jonty125 wrote:WIFOM - Maybe not all the 'core' characters are in the game. Maybe mafia were given 1 or 2 for fakeclaims.
I don't know much of anything about this game's flavor, my objections to gregwolf's claim are based on the role he claimed. I have reason to suspect this game has an actually doctor. As such I don't see why there would be a 1-Shot Doctor in addition to this. Accordingly, his claim looks to me like a poorly done fake, perhaps attempting to draw out the real Doctor. Anyhow, it looks like it is now clear to put my vote back. Vote gregwolf.
I hate to have to point this out, but it's entirely possible he was lying about the one-shot nature of his doc ability to make himself appear a less attractive night kill to the mafia.
In that case, the logic of Comm9 would have to be used LYNCH ALL LIARS!; but surely he [gregowolf] would come out and tells us about his bluff in this scenario where the pressure remains on him?
blakebowling wrote:jonty125 wrote:Metsfanmax wrote:spiesr wrote:Or maybe there is no simple pattern as to which characters are scum. Until one of them turns up dead there is no way to know for sure.jonty125 wrote:WIFOM - Maybe not all the 'core' characters are in the game. Maybe mafia were given 1 or 2 for fakeclaims.
I don't know much of anything about this game's flavor, my objections to gregwolf's claim are based on the role he claimed. I have reason to suspect this game has an actually doctor. As such I don't see why there would be a 1-Shot Doctor in addition to this. Accordingly, his claim looks to me like a poorly done fake, perhaps attempting to draw out the real Doctor. Anyhow, it looks like it is now clear to put my vote back. Vote gregwolf.
I hate to have to point this out, but it's entirely possible he was lying about the one-shot nature of his doc ability to make himself appear a less attractive night kill to the mafia.
In that case, the logic of Comm9 would have to be used LYNCH ALL LIARS!; but surely he [gregowolf] would come out and tells us about his bluff in this scenario where the pressure remains on him?
I'm going to give gregwolf a bit longer to fess up. If not, I simply don't believe his claim and am in favor of lynching him.
jonty125 wrote:Metsfanmax wrote:spiesr wrote:Or maybe there is no simple pattern as to which characters are scum. Until one of them turns up dead there is no way to know for sure.jonty125 wrote:WIFOM - Maybe not all the 'core' characters are in the game. Maybe mafia were given 1 or 2 for fakeclaims.
I don't know much of anything about this game's flavor, my objections to gregwolf's claim are based on the role he claimed. I have reason to suspect this game has an actually doctor. As such I don't see why there would be a 1-Shot Doctor in addition to this. Accordingly, his claim looks to me like a poorly done fake, perhaps attempting to draw out the real Doctor. Anyhow, it looks like it is now clear to put my vote back. Vote gregwolf.
I hate to have to point this out, but it's entirely possible he was lying about the one-shot nature of his doc ability to make himself appear a less attractive night kill to the mafia.
In that case, the logic of Comm9 would have to be used LYNCH ALL LIARS!; but surely he [gregowolf] would come out and tells us about his bluff in this scenario where the pressure remains on him?
Metsfanmax wrote:jonty125 wrote:Metsfanmax wrote:spiesr wrote:Or maybe there is no simple pattern as to which characters are scum. Until one of them turns up dead there is no way to know for sure.jonty125 wrote:WIFOM - Maybe not all the 'core' characters are in the game. Maybe mafia were given 1 or 2 for fakeclaims.
I don't know much of anything about this game's flavor, my objections to gregwolf's claim are based on the role he claimed. I have reason to suspect this game has an actually doctor. As such I don't see why there would be a 1-Shot Doctor in addition to this. Accordingly, his claim looks to me like a poorly done fake, perhaps attempting to draw out the real Doctor. Anyhow, it looks like it is now clear to put my vote back. Vote gregwolf.
I hate to have to point this out, but it's entirely possible he was lying about the one-shot nature of his doc ability to make himself appear a less attractive night kill to the mafia.
In that case, the logic of Comm9 would have to be used LYNCH ALL LIARS!; but surely he [gregowolf] would come out and tells us about his bluff in this scenario where the pressure remains on him?
I fully disagree. If we had all reached the same conclusion I did, and then kept our mouths shut so as to keep the real town doc alive, then the lie would have been beneficial to town. That being said, I'm not 100% confident of my conclusion so I'm glad it didn't go that route. But now that people are on to him, for better or worse, I guess the jig is up for him. I still won't vote for him though. This is not WIFOM logic; it's just my guess that Britta has to be part of the game. For me, having her out would be equally as silly as not having Jeff in the game.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users