++No Handlebars[6/11]Endgame:Without a Trace (Mafia Wins!)++

by **aage** on Sun Feb 24, 2013 6:27 pm

rishaed wrote:
aage wrote:
rishaed wrote:I do have a question though. . . Why were you so intent on Vigging S7C aage?

Cause he was scummy as hell. I thought of investigating him, but that would've been way too slow for this small a game. My action getting blocked only confirmed my suspicions.

It needs to be said, though, that town didn't really have much of a chance. Potentially three kills in a night, two investigations at most and two roleblocks? And you put THREE scum in the mafia team? That's two mislynches.
Also, Jonty, why didn't you use your action?

But After hippo lied about tracking you to Jonty, you should have vigged him seeing as it was absolute confirmation that he was scum? I mean doesn't usually go 100% scum over 90%? I mean the fact that he said that he tracked you anywhere should have sent the red flag up considering I would have told him you wouldn't have gone anywhere. (Perfect Camo Attribute). Other than the fact that he claimed you visited Jonty when you visited S7C, claimed two different night actions, and basically should have set off just about every scum sensor that there was.
For Mafia numbers I just did a third, and the fact of two mislynches was exactly why I enforced a No Lynch without a majority. (though that might have killed discussion so I might not do that in the future.) The setup was 7 town 1 survivor (who logically could act as town and as long as he didn't get lynched he was a thorn in the mafias side) and 3 Mafia.

Be warned This game may quite possibly be very unbalanced in gameplay, as I will be testing role ideas, Scum roles are decided randomly so just because a role sounds scummy does not mean automatically that it is a scum role.

It was a judgement call whether he was lying or not. It could have been a weird mechanic. I suspected a busdrive or such. Hence why I wanted to have Jonty lynched; it would make sense for him to have been bulletproof and Hippo tracking me to him.

And honestly, I never bought the camo as an actual power. I distrust mods. (Really? An invisible town JOAT?)

by **rishaed** on Sun Feb 24, 2013 8:53 pm

I did say in the OP that the roles were randomized. Mafia used the forgetfulness of this fact against you. I matched roles/ideas up, the perfect camo was the idea, the role in my mind that went with it in this game is the JOAT. And why would I put in your role discription if it didn't exist as part of your role?? I figured for sure you would have vigged Hippo in the night >.>. Just as Jonty's role could either be Mafia/Town, yours could as well. The only "fixed role" was Witts, because he was practically invincible to night actions, so I made him 3rd party.