Moderator: Cartographers
Evil DIMwit wrote:natty_dread wrote:To be honest I think your pirate map has more potential. Like I said to grifftron on his bull map, it will be an uphill battle. I'm not saying the map shouldn't be made, but you'll face lots of obstacles on a map like this... the Foundry isn't very receptive to abstract/non-geographical map ideas, so you will need to do a lot of convincing to get this through.
I disagree. We've already got a couple of pirate maps, and in any case beef diagrams are one of those abstract images that are so recognizable that I think people are likely to go along with it. Yes, it might be a novelty, but I don't think that makes it not worth making.
natty_dread wrote:The mapmaker seems to have disappeared...
Industrial Helix wrote:natty_dread wrote:The mapmaker seems to have disappeared...
I kind of foresaw that. But he's logged in today and is taking his turn on games. I hope he does return because he's got some interesting ideas.
Industrial Helix wrote:I wonder if permission is even needed, something similar could be made in a separate thread.
FrancisBoyle wrote:I think there should be a PETA or some other animal rights group territory that can bombard all territories on the cow.
natty_dread wrote:Industrial Helix wrote:I wonder if permission is even needed, something similar could be made in a separate thread.
You can't copyright an idea. Anyone is free to make a map of the same subject. Otherwise we wouldn't have umpty-zillion maps of europe and north-america...
natty_dread wrote:Perhaps it would be best to enquire whether he intends to resume working on this project, before we start looking for a substitute for finishing his job...
army of nobunaga wrote:i like small maps, i like new art ideas... but im not sure if this will play without some kind of gameplay tweak ... at least im rooting for a gameplay tweak
Return to Melting Pot: Map Ideas
Users browsing this forum: No registered users