Been rejected more times than anyone can remember!
Definitely needs tweaking then it might be good... with neutrals it would suck
dilbertofaus wrote:Adds a different element to the game, and makes the game purely strategic.
It just means the variables of luck have an even bigger impact than before: drop, play order, and (if you're playing with them) cards.
maybee its time you find yourself another game to play if you dont like playing risk with the dice
Fun or not, it still doesn't seem like Risk.
BaldAdonis wrote:Let's play a game right now. Since you don't need dice, the entire game can be done by writing down your moves, once you know the starting position. You could play by mail! (like Diplomacy, but with fewer rules)
Better yet, head over to forum games, and play there. Then you can figure out your strategies, and it doesn't have to affect anyone who wants to play CC.
Fruitcake wrote:Lastly, your comment is most odd. To say 'it doesn't have to affect anyone who wants to play CC' is EXACTLY what I am saying
You're saying you want it to be considered as a game like CC, which is not what I want to see. When I click on your profile and see that you've won x% of games, I don't want those to be no dice games anymore than I want them to be forum mafia or trivia games (or "guess which number I'm thinking of" games), insofar as they give no information about how well you play Risk.
Fog of War is used in a lot of Risk games where the capability exists. Every Hasbro computer version has it, and it's not a (drastically) different game, you just lose some information.Audax wrote:Since when was fog of war a risk game???? NEVER until CC.
My point is about the records of the games. Since this is an entirely different game (not a probabalistic game, but a solvable game), the records should not be combined with your record on real games. The page doesn't sort game types, so it would not be useful.How do you know what I play to check whether you want to play me....oh yes, you look at the page kindly supplied by the site which shows you!!!!
If you actually want to help, why not do something to address the issues against it, instead of shrugging them off as obstinate? You can already play games exactly like this on this site in a place designed for it. It's called Forum Games. Just make a thread, post your map, and make your moves. You don't need any additional support to do it, and you get the added bonus of being able to use new maps before they're quenched.What is being asked for is an option, not something you HAVE to do. If this became an option, you would have to do one thing....click the dice box rather than the no dice box. How difficult is that?
Hear hear Fruitcake...anything I can do to drum up support, you have my resources at your disposal.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users