Moderator: Community Team
yeti_c wrote:I actually disagree with the above 2 posters - not everyone plays in set teams - and sometimes comms aren't reliable here at CC...
The problem however is how to display this information.
C.
AAFitz wrote:yeti_c wrote:I actually disagree with the above 2 posters - not everyone plays in set teams - and sometimes comms aren't reliable here at CC...
The problem however is how to display this information.
C.
perhaps it could somehow be listed in team chat when someone gets card... I imagine this is easier to say than do
yeti_c wrote:I actually disagree with the above 2 posters - not everyone plays in set teams - and sometimes comms aren't reliable here at CC...
The problem however is how to display this information.
C.
AAFitz wrote:yeti_c wrote:I actually disagree with the above 2 posters - not everyone plays in set teams - and sometimes comms aren't reliable here at CC...
The problem however is how to display this information.
C.
perhaps it could somehow be listed in team chat when someone gets card... I imagine this is easier to say than do
Bruceswar wrote:yeti_c wrote:I actually disagree with the above 2 posters - not everyone plays in set teams - and sometimes comms aren't reliable here at CC...
The problem however is how to display this information.
C.
Negative... weather this is your first game with someone or 500th matters not. Ask them to list their cards. If they do not likely you do not want to team with them as they are not looking at chat anyhow.
yeti_c wrote:Bruceswar wrote:yeti_c wrote:I actually disagree with the above 2 posters - not everyone plays in set teams - and sometimes comms aren't reliable here at CC...
The problem however is how to display this information.
C.
Negative... weather this is your first game with someone or 500th matters not. Ask them to list their cards. If they do not likely you do not want to team with them as they are not looking at chat anyhow.
Well indeed - but you are already teamed with them - because like I say - some people just join games regardless of who's on their team...
You are saying you don't want this because you play with set team members - and these team members are obviously good at team games (I assume this because you say that you wouldn't want to team with people that don't list their cards)... This means that you don't want this addition because you want your opposing team to not have this advantage...
I wish people around here would purvey their opinions based on the good of the site or the good of the game - and not the good of their score.
C.
Bruceswar wrote:yeti_c wrote:Bruceswar wrote:yeti_c wrote:I actually disagree with the above 2 posters - not everyone plays in set teams - and sometimes comms aren't reliable here at CC...
The problem however is how to display this information.
C.
Negative... weather this is your first game with someone or 500th matters not. Ask them to list their cards. If they do not likely you do not want to team with them as they are not looking at chat anyhow.
Well indeed - but you are already teamed with them - because like I say - some people just join games regardless of who's on their team...
You are saying you don't want this because you play with set team members - and these team members are obviously good at team games (I assume this because you say that you wouldn't want to team with people that don't list their cards)... This means that you don't want this addition because you want your opposing team to not have this advantage...
I wish people around here would purvey their opinions based on the good of the site or the good of the game - and not the good of their score.
C.
The good of the game as lack intended ( I hope) would be for skill to win out over things like this. In a game where only so many moves can be made, small things like this separate the good from the not so good many more times than not. BTW I play with random partners. If they do not post their cards I am not likely to play with them again if it was a key situation. This is what separates the men from the boys. Why try and make everybody equal? Where does skill come into play and or attention to detail?
At this rate we might as well have a script that will predict an optimal move for us, and tell us where and how to drop and attack. Seems like where all this is headed.
BTW my most regular partners need not say much in chat at all. We know what to expect from each other. We do all still list our cards.
My not so regular partners and or randoms, I use chat to see what plan they are on and also we list our cards. If someone does not at least read chat or post cards then well you know.
Bruceswar wrote:Terrible idea... if your team cannot take the 2 seconds needed to post what cards you have then you are not a very good teammate. Post your cards, or suck it up. 100% not needed.
Rocketry wrote:Bruceswar wrote:Terrible idea... if your team cannot take the 2 seconds needed to post what cards you have then you are not a very good teammate. Post your cards, or suck it up. 100% not needed.
BOB isn't needed.... all the info it provides could be worked out yourself by hand if you took enough notice of the game from the beginning but this suggestion would make the process easier, just like BOB. Would like to see it implemented!
Rocket.
rockfist wrote:Bruceswar wrote:yeti_c wrote:Bruceswar wrote:
Negative... weather this is your first game with someone or 500th matters not. Ask them to list their cards. If they do not likely you do not want to team with them as they are not looking at chat anyhow.
Well indeed - but you are already teamed with them - because like I say - some people just join games regardless of who's on their team...
You are saying you don't want this because you play with set team members - and these team members are obviously good at team games (I assume this because you say that you wouldn't want to team with people that don't list their cards)... This means that you don't want this addition because you want your opposing team to not have this advantage...
I wish people around here would purvey their opinions based on the good of the site or the good of the game - and not the good of their score.
C.
The good of the game as lack intended ( I hope) would be for skill to win out over things like this. In a game where only so many moves can be made, small things like this separate the good from the not so good many more times than not. BTW I play with random partners. If they do not post their cards I am not likely to play with them again if it was a key situation. This is what separates the men from the boys. Why try and make everybody equal? Where does skill come into play and or attention to detail?
At this rate we might as well have a script that will predict an optimal move for us, and tell us where and how to drop and attack. Seems like where all this is headed.
BTW my most regular partners need not say much in chat at all. We know what to expect from each other. We do all still list our cards.
My not so regular partners and or randoms, I use chat to see what plan they are on and also we list our cards. If someone does not at least read chat or post cards then well you know.
He is correct on this. I have a team of Trips where we have won a no spoils game and the only things we said were "nice round" or "bad dice" in the entire game. When you play a lot together you don't need to say a lot, but you do communicate cards. There is no need to dummy down the game.
Gilligan wrote:AK_iceman wrote:I don't like it. Team games are all about communication, if you want to know what cards your partner has, then just ask them.
But, in a very good chance, another partner doesn't even look at the chat. If they do end up losing because of this reason, it's not fair to person that wants to communicate but the other partner won't reply in the chat.
Return to Archived Suggestions
Users browsing this forum: No registered users