Leehar wrote:Of course I know the score, because everyone seemed pretty vigorous on that being a bad move, despite my luck in catching a mafia, so seemed like I should just confirm/clarify the point that I shouldn't kill as vig without actually outing myself.
So when you were talking to the "vig" what was the meaning behind that? To confirm/clarify that you shouldn't have done it? You have been playing for a while and thinking it is a good idea to shoot night 1 as a vig is rather hard to believe.
Also, while you can think of those as preemptive excuses, that honestly was the reasoning that I used to kill him.
OK lets see what your reasons were then
He benefited town so he's cool in my book
I'll ignore this one shall I?
it isn't really dissimilar to the D1 kill that we did yesterday which seemed to be killing for the sake of killing.
There is a world of difference, we got claims and info and we pressured him and could get further information. At the end of all of it we decided to lynch him with a majority of town. Randomly killing a player does not benefit town unless you have a strong scum vibe and just that he was one of many people on a BW is not a sufficient reason. He done it once, that is NOT enough to earn a kill.
Plus, no one has lent any doubt upon my name credentials, and I think I've seen my name mentioned in one of the scenes, so if you really think I'm third party (as eisenhower), you're well and truly bonkers.
This is harder to argue with, but I wouldn't be surprised if the SK was given a fake claim to help him out.