SAS1982 & mattreuben [cleared]

[b00060]

Secret Diplomacy. Did not target each other at all and only attacked me. Killed me in less than 5 rounds in a trench game. Clearly a one sided game.
Game 12649308
Accused:
mattreuben
SAS1982

The accused are suspected of:

Conducting Secret Diplomacy

[clangfield]

Secret Diplomacy. Did not target each other at all and only attacked me. Killed me in less than 5 rounds in a trench game. Clearly a one sided game.
Game 12649308
Accused:
mattreuben
SAS1982

The accused are suspected of:

Conducting Secret Diplomacy

5 rounds yes, but it's a pretty small map - you only start with 6 regions.
"only attacked me" - not entirely true, blue attacked green at the end of round three.
Bit of a catch 22 this one - can you expect to prove SD after only 3 rounds? Is it not possible that they independently attacked you because you were a) nearest and b) a higher rank?

[b00060]

It was trench.

[Frox333]

lol boo, this is a little ridiculous who conducts secret diplomacy on that map with those settings. PLUS, they have no past game connections with you, so they arent holding a grudge, and also they have never played with eachother before, so they obviously don't know eachother. Do us all a favor and actually be reasonable next time instead of filing a report. it wastes everyone's time

[king achilles]

It's most likely circumstances. Blue took Ardennes while green had Moselle. You got stuck in Müllerthal. When green attacked you and had you into owning 2 regions left, I guess blue thought it was a matter of who will take you out first. You were in between and if green ignored you, you would have been a threat to him. He took a chance and finished you off to take your spoils rather than having blue possibly being the first one to do it instead.

[Frox333]

It's most likely circumstances. Blue took Ardennes while green had Moselle. You got stuck in Müllerthal. When green attacked you and had you into owning 2 regions left, I guess blue thought it was a matter of who will take you out first. You were in between and if green ignored you, you would have been a threat to him. He took a chance and finished you off to take your spoils rather than having blue possibly being the first one to do it instead.

thank you for words of wisdom