Moderator: Tournament Directors
crispybits wrote:Excellent, I get to beat slytown 13 times
kizkiz wrote:Looked at the 3 games
the second i don't think he did anything you could have seen?
the third he posted his move 17 minutes later
the first game is the only one without action. Did it make a difference tot the game?
If so, i'll adjudicate on it. Possible points lost for that tie
Chewie1 wrote:kizkiz wrote:Looked at the 3 games
the second i don't think he did anything you could have seen?
the third he posted his move 17 minutes later
the first game is the only one without action. Did it make a difference tot the game?
If so, i'll adjudicate on it. Possible points lost for that tie
Personally I think the rule sucks.
I only posted because rules are rules.
If part of the answer is:
"i don't think he did anything you could have seen?" and " Did it make a difference tot the game?"
Whats the point of the rule?
kizkiz wrote:Chewie1 wrote:kizkiz wrote:Looked at the 3 games
the second i don't think he did anything you could have seen?
the third he posted his move 17 minutes later
the first game is the only one without action. Did it make a difference tot the game?
If so, i'll adjudicate on it. Possible points lost for that tie
Personally I think the rule sucks.
I only posted because rules are rules.
If part of the answer is:
"i don't think he did anything you could have seen?" and " Did it make a difference tot the game?"
Whats the point of the rule?
the fog rule is a courtesy rule. At the end of the day it sometimes puts you at a slight tactical disadvantage if not adhered to, rather than full on cheating
He claims not to have known what the rule meant and rectified his other mistake.
I'm using a bit of discretion rather than immediately ruling, that's all
kizkiz wrote:Just going through the scores and rule breaks for the chewie/notyou2 vs mint murray/CC
Vanilla score was 12-8 to mint/cc
We have 12 hour rule breaks in
route 66 - he did nothing chewie/notyou could have seen, so no need for 12 hour wait
third crusade - rule breakers lost game anyway
labyrinth - he did nothing chewie/notyou could have seen, so no need for 12 hour wait
classic - match forfeited by mint/cc for breaking 12 hour rule and not clearly rectifying it.
So revised score is 11-9 - winners still mint murray/CC
Users browsing this forum: No registered users