Haydena wrote:Oh, I dunno Marv, that is kinda arrogant . I think on aesthetics alone this will be more appealing than the Brazil map, it's also not a complete Classic map clone like your map is, I remember some of your comments... "I'll study the classic map"...
I think it'll be played more than the Brazil map... It's a lot better in my opinion, your map is starting to look out of date with all these new good looking maps (Not including mine lol)
rocksolid wrote:Also, suggestion for Midlands - name is fine, but an alternative is Mide, the old kingdom that used to be in that spot before Leinster spread to its size.
And are you sure you want to identify the water off Cork as St. George's channel? I assume it's accurate, but in the spirit of the map, you might prefer to just refer to the Irish Sea.
kevinc wrote:So I changed it to have 6 regions. 3 are easy to hold, 2 are quite tough and 1 is very difficult.
kevinc wrote:Maybe I should switch them back though, or make Connaught 2 aswell.
A question regarding The Pale. It is central and has 4 borders, like Europe on the classic map. Why do people think it is so unholdable?
. Though flip flopping wouldn't be so bad either. I see where you are coming from, and even though Munster is easy to hold, I'm afraid 3 borders for a 2 bonus might not be worth the trouble.Jota wrote: I'd likely make them both 3 before making them both 2
It indeed is in a tough location. Though I'm not sure there is much you can do in this area, so you might just go ahead and leave that as is, It could indeed make for interesting gameplay, which I think this map will have.Jota wrote:...it's a matter of location...
Frigidus wrote:but now that it's become relatively popular it's suffered the usual downturn in coolness.
kevinc wrote:Marvaddin. Yes I am stubborn, but someone needs to be. Nothing good gets created with compromise. A map designed by commitee would be useless. I don't intend to scrafice playability for accuracy, but it's important not to redraw borders when a better solution can be found. Also, I have a general suggestion for you. Making impolite comments is not an effective way to make people agree with you.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users