Battle of Waterloo [Quenched]

[PLAYER57832]

All map suggestions belong in the maps thread in the Map Foundry (Waterloo's thread can be found here)

Oh yeah, Welcome to CC, I hope you enjoy it

I tried to point that out as a problem (that it be better explained) when it FIRST came out, but I was told by the creator that he did not think it was a problem. That was several months ago.

[BaldAdonis]

Uxbridge 04 looks like it touches Picton 02 (it's got a single pixel overlap), but it's not directly connected in the xml. Any chance of moving the hedge over a smidgen?

[cairnswk]

Uxbridge 04 looks like it touches Picton 02 (it's got a single pixel overlap), but it's not directly connected in the xml. Any chance of moving the hedge over a smidgen?

Done

http://i155.photobucket.com/albums/s282 ... o_V29S.jpg

http://i155.photobucket.com/albums/s282 ... o_V29L.jpg

[BaldAdonis]

Very nice. Fixed up a few other slightly ambiguous parts as well.
Is that field of earth between von Blucher 02 and 03 a different colour? I hate to be nitpicky, but I figured someone would mention it

[Ogrecrusher]

Firstly I love this map, but one question. The bonus values seem very arbitrary. I have no idea why uxbridge is an 8 while Ziethen is a 5 for example.

[Joodoo]

For the artillery bombardments, what does it mean by "marked territories"?

[yeti_c]

For the artillery bombardments, what does it mean by "marked territories"?

"Enemy-marked territories"

Subtle difference...

C.

[Joodoo]

does that mean if you hold an artillery territory, you can bombard all enemy territories except for Wellington/Napoleon?

[cairnswk]

does that mean if you hold an artillery territory, you can bombard all enemy territories except for Wellington/Napoleon?

Joodoo
Below is part of the xml for the territory M01 - Imperial Guard 1.
As you can see it can bombard a lot of territories that are marked as the opposition.

Code: Select all

<territory>
<name>Imperial Guard 01</name>
<borders>
      </borders>
−
<bombardments>
<bombardment>Chässe 01</bombardment>
<bombardment>Chässe 02</bombardment>
<bombardment>Chässe 03</bombardment>
<bombardment>Clinton 01</bombardment>
<bombardment>Clinton 02</bombardment>
<bombardment>Clinton 03</bombardment>
<bombardment>Clinton 04</bombardment>
<bombardment>Clinton 05</bombardment>
<bombardment>Clinton 06</bombardment>
<bombardment>Clinton 07</bombardment>
<bombardment>Clinton 08</bombardment>
<bombardment>Clinton 09</bombardment>
<bombardment>Alton 01</bombardment>
<bombardment>Alton 02</bombardment>
<bombardment>Alton 03</bombardment>
<bombardment>Alton 04</bombardment>
<bombardment>Alton 05</bombardment>
<bombardment>Uxbridge 01</bombardment>
<bombardment>Hougomont 01</bombardment>
<bombardment>Hougomont 02</bombardment>
</bombardments>
−
<coordinates>
<smallx>128</smallx>
<smally>577</smally>
<largex>171</largex>
<largey>762</largey>
</coordinates>
</territory>

Click image to enlarge.

[Joodoo]

thanks carinswk

[Ogrecrusher]

For the artillery bombardments, what does it mean by "marked territories"?

Territories with some kind of Soldier icon infantry/cavalry/artillery. Some have none, eg the villages, so these cannot be bombarded.

[cairnswk]

Firstly I love this map, but one question. The bonus values seem very arbitrary. I have no idea why uxbridge is an 8 while Ziethen is a 5 for example.

Well the record should be in the thread if you want to check.

[ManBungalow]

It's a beautiful map, thanks

[sm8900]

hi. you guys need to post more of the rules for this map. such as that an artillery space can't attack any space which belongs to the the same region as itself.

[Joodoo]

hi. you guys need to post more of the rules for this map. such as that an artillery space can't attack any space which belongs to the the same region as itself.

see this:

For the artillery bombardments, what does it mean by "marked territories"?

"Enemy-marked territories"

Subtle difference...

C.

[sm8900]

does that mean if you hold an artillery territory, you can bombard all enemy territories except for Wellington/Napoleon?

Joodoo
Below is part of the xml for the territory M01 - Imperial Guard 1.
As you can see it can bombard a lot of territories that are marked as the opposition.

Code: Select all

<territory>
<name>Imperial Guard 01</name>
<borders>
      </borders>
−
<bombardments>
<bombardment>Chässe 01</bombardment>
<bombardment>Chässe 02</bombardment>
<bombardment>Chässe 03</bombardment>
<bombardment>Clinton 01</bombardment>
<bombardment>Clinton 02</bombardment>
<bombardment>Clinton 03</bombardment>
<bombardment>Clinton 04</bombardment>
<bombardment>Clinton 05</bombardment>
<bombardment>Clinton 06</bombardment>
<bombardment>Clinton 07</bombardment>
<bombardment>Clinton 08</bombardment>
<bombardment>Clinton 09</bombardment>
<bombardment>Alton 01</bombardment>
<bombardment>Alton 02</bombardment>
<bombardment>Alton 03</bombardment>
<bombardment>Alton 04</bombardment>
<bombardment>Alton 05</bombardment>
<bombardment>Uxbridge 01</bombardment>
<bombardment>Hougomont 01</bombardment>
<bombardment>Hougomont 02</bombardment>
</bombardments>
−
<coordinates>
<smallx>128</smallx>
<smally>577</smally>
<largex>171</largex>
<largey>762</largey>
</coordinates>
</territory>

wow, quick reply. thanks very much.

not to be nit-picky, but what about the above-quoted post? I didn't see a reply to that one. thanks.

[cairnswk]

hi. you guys need to post more of the rules for this map. such as that an artillery space can't attack any space which belongs to the the same region as itself.

I have to ask sm8900, when playing a map that is essentially a two-sided game, why would you want to attack your own space.
I can see what you're getting at though.
This was the way the map was designed.

[Incandenza]

Tho that does give me an idea... since CC still doesn't have proper map guides, it might not be a bad idea to have a FAQ for a given complex map in the first post of the thread (especially since now there's a link to the development thread in each map's game finder image).

[sm8900]

hi. you guys need to post more of the rules for this map. such as that an artillery space can't attack any space which belongs to the the same region as itself.

I have to ask sm8900, when playing a map that is essentially a two-sided game, why would you want to attack your own space.
I can see what you're getting at though.
This was the way the map was designed.

um I would want to attack a space in the same region if it is held by the other side.

[Capitino]

It looks like Ney04 cannot attack Reille06 at the moment, but it should be able to do so since Ney04 is cavalry and it can therefor attack Reille06 through ImperialGuard08

[yeti_c]

It looks like Ney04 cannot attack Reille06 at the moment, but it should be able to do so since Ney04 is cavalry and it can therefor attack Reille06 through ImperialGuard08

Capitano would appear to have a point here - surprised this has never been spotted before!!!

The current code is as follows:

Code: Select all

   <territory>
      <name>Ney 04</name>
      <borders>
         <border>Ney 05</border>
         <border>Alton 03</border>
         <border>Alton 01</border>
         <border>Clinton 09</border>
         <border>Imperial Guard 08</border>
         <border>Ney 03</border>
         <border>Ney 06</border>
         <border>Alton 02</border>
         <border>Alton 04</border>
         <border>Imperial Guard 07</border>
         <border>Clinton 08</border>
         <border>Clinton 02</border>
         <border>Clinton 03</border>
         <border>Hougomont 02</border>
      </borders>
      <coordinates>
         <smallx>230</smallx>
         <smally>296</smally>
         <largex>308</largex>
         <largey>386</largey>
      </coordinates>


C.

[cairnswk]

It looks like Ney04 cannot attack Reille06 at the moment, but it should be able to do so since Ney04 is cavalry and it can therefor attack Reille06 through ImperialGuard08

Capitano would appear to have a point here - surprised this has never been spotted before!!!
....
C.

Perhaps no-one has tried that attack before.

Anyways, has anyone checked for anything further before i upload this again to MrBenn.

[the.killing.44]

Well shit, he's right. Update it, cairns.

[cairnswk]

Well shit, he's right. Update it, cairns.

When some has checked if there are no others to be included in the update...perhaps you could take on that task

[the.killing.44]

Well shit, he's right. Update it, cairns.

When some has checked if there are no others to be included in the update...perhaps you could take on that task

I checked the cavalry and didn't see any other errors:

http://h1.ripway.com/killing44/Waterloo.xml

Second opinion would be good I presume.