Page 4 of 12
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - Map on page 1
Posted:
Wed Apr 30, 2008 11:12 amby bryguy
second time for me to drop in here to look at the map now, first time to comment, and like usual im not gonna comment that much until later
for now, i have some comments/questions
1) whats the weather usually like for luxembourg? the color scheme makes me think that its cold....
2) maybe up the bonus for the esch continent and the reisdorf continent and remich continent to 4? that way they could deploy 1 on each of that continents territories, yet still have 1 to use for attacks
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - New Update on pages 1 and 5
Posted:
Wed Apr 30, 2008 5:43 pmby rocky mountain
the mini-map looks much better
i think that the top region should be worth more because it has the most territories (5). I know it only has 2 bordering territories, but still. I think the other bonuses are fine though.
also, if there's going to be a blue border around Luxembourg city, then can you make it more evident on the bottom of it as well?
Lastly, i think that the coat-of-arms and the flag should be switched. I believe flags should be displayed more than coat of arms...
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - Map on page 1
Posted:
Wed Apr 30, 2008 7:09 pmby Ruben Cassar
bryguy wrote:second time for me to drop in here to look at the map now, first time to comment, and like usual im not gonna comment that much until later
for now, i have some comments/questions
1) whats the weather usually like for luxembourg? the color scheme makes me think that its cold....
2) maybe up the bonus for the esch continent and the reisdorf continent and remich continent to 4? that way they could deploy 1 on each of that continents territories, yet still have 1 to use for attacks
It's cold but not as cold as Scandinavia for example. Anyway I live in a warm place so I don't care! :p
The bonuses are right I think...no need to up them.
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - New Update on pages 1 and 5
Posted:
Wed Apr 30, 2008 7:13 pmby Ruben Cassar
rocky mountain wrote:the mini-map looks much better
i think that the top region should be worth more because it has the most territories (5). I know it only has 2 bordering territories, but still. I think the other bonuses are fine though.
also, if there's going to be a blue border around Luxembourg city, then can you make it more evident on the bottom of it as well?
Lastly, i think that the coat-of-arms and the flag should be switched. I believe flags should be displayed more than coat of arms...
Glad that you like the new mini map. Even though the top region has the most territories of them all, it is also the easiest to hold so I think the bonus is right. Luxembourg City is technically part of the greater region (light blue) even though it is a standalone territory, that's why the bottom border is not blue. Hmm, the coat of arms would be too small and its details would be lost if used in the mini map. I tried that before posting. I like the way they are set right now.
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - New Update on pages 1 and 6
Posted:
Thu May 01, 2008 10:17 amby Ruben Cassar
Version 1.9 - Added region names to the mini map
I decided to add the region names to the mini map after all since these could prove helpful while playing the game on the map.
- Click image to enlarge.
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - New Update on pages 1 and 6
Posted:
Thu May 01, 2008 10:43 amby bryguy
also, i dont care for the texture
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - New Update on pages 1 and 6
Posted:
Thu May 01, 2008 11:47 amby Ruben Cassar
bryguy wrote:also, i dont care for the texture
Post number 3665! That's quite a lot.
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - New Update on pages 1 and 6
Posted:
Thu May 01, 2008 2:10 pmby RjBeals
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - New Update on pages 1 and 6
Posted:
Thu May 01, 2008 8:05 pmby fireedud
The texture would be better if it wasn't so strong.
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - New Update on pages 1 and 6
Posted:
Fri May 02, 2008 5:56 amby Ruben Cassar
fireedud wrote:The texture would be better if it wasn't so strong.
I like the texture as it is. I won't be changing it. The majority of people seem to like it as well.
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - New Update on pages 1 and 6
Posted:
Fri May 02, 2008 10:47 amby AndyDufresne
The texture is alright, but the divisions between continents stand out and look more like fault lines than region dividers.
--Andy
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - New Update on pages 1 and 6
Posted:
Fri May 02, 2008 11:08 amby Ruben Cassar
AndyDufresne wrote:The texture is alright, but the divisions between continents stand out and look more like fault lines than region dividers.
--Andy
You mean you prefer the regional borders to be like those in the mini map of Version 1.7 without any bevel and embossing?
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - New Update on pages 1 and 6
Posted:
Fri May 02, 2008 11:42 amby RjBeals
not me. I like the bevel on the region borders. Gives the map a different feel than others.
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - New Update on pages 1 and 6
Posted:
Fri May 02, 2008 12:13 pmby Ruben Cassar
RjBeals wrote:not me. I like the bevel on the region borders. Gives the map a different feel than others.
Actually even I like it and think it makes the map different. Hmm.
I think I'm going to stick with it Andy if it's not such a big issue?
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - New Update on pages 1 and 6
Posted:
Fri May 02, 2008 12:28 pmby RjBeals
Ruben Cassar wrote:RjBeals wrote:not me. I like the bevel on the region borders. Gives the map a different feel than others.
Actually even I like it and think it makes the map different. Hmm.
I think I'm going to stick with it Andy if it's not such a big issue?
I don't think Andy can come up with a strong enough counter to influence the group it should be changed - but I would love it if he tried!
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - New Update on pages 1 and 6
Posted:
Fri May 02, 2008 1:26 pmby Ruben Cassar
RjBeals wrote:Ruben Cassar wrote:RjBeals wrote:not me. I like the bevel on the region borders. Gives the map a different feel than others.
Actually even I like it and think it makes the map different. Hmm.
I think I'm going to stick with it Andy if it's not such a big issue?
I don't think Andy can come up with a strong enough counter to influence the group it should be changed - but I would love it if he tried!
I wouldn't, so don't give him strange ideas.
And anyway what group? Barely no one posts in this thread apart from 3 or 4 people! Hehe.
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - New Update on pages 1 and 6
Posted:
Fri May 02, 2008 2:39 pmby ZeakCytho
I like the beveled look more too
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - New Update on pages 1 and 6
Posted:
Fri May 02, 2008 3:54 pmby Ruben Cassar
ZeakCytho wrote:I like the beveled look more too
Thanks for the support.
Anyway I won't be doing any updates for the time being until this map makes it to the foundry. I am quite happy with the way it looks and don't know what else to add to it.
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - New Update on pages 1 and 6
Posted:
Fri May 02, 2008 4:21 pmby wcaclimbing
Ruben Cassar wrote:ZeakCytho wrote:I like the beveled look more too
Thanks for the support.
Anyway I won't be doing any updates for the time being until this map makes it to the foundry. I am quite happy with the way it looks and don't know what else to add to it.
You'll have to keep doing updates (as long as there are good suggestions).
Getting into the map foundry doesn't really change anything. You get the same suggestions and the same people, the threads just moved to a different place.
Keep working on it. they won't move you to the foundry if you quit updating....
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - New Update on pages 1 and 6
Posted:
Fri May 02, 2008 4:42 pmby Ruben Cassar
wcaclimbing wrote:Ruben Cassar wrote:ZeakCytho wrote:I like the beveled look more too
Thanks for the support.
Anyway I won't be doing any updates for the time being until this map makes it to the foundry. I am quite happy with the way it looks and don't know what else to add to it.
You'll have to keep doing updates (as long as there are good suggestions).
Getting into the map foundry doesn't really change anything. You get the same suggestions and the same people, the threads just moved to a different place.
Keep working on it. they won't move you to the foundry if you quit updating....
And what should I update? I got no further suggestions. I have nothing further to add at the moment and no one suggested anything else.
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - New Update on pages 1 and 6
Posted:
Fri May 02, 2008 4:50 pmby Kaplowitz
Well this is a perfect example of how DiM's logic is flawed. He would say that this has no support, and therefore no comments, but that doesnt seem true.
Maybe you could advertise or something. I think some people send a pm to like everyone on the site advertising their maps. Its really annoying, but i end up clicking on it anyway...even if ive already checked the map like 5 seconds ago! (i have a clicking problem)
But dont go on strike, the only real way to get comments is to update. Im sure once a mod checks this over, you will get moved.
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - New Update on pages 1 and 6
Posted:
Fri May 02, 2008 4:56 pmby Ruben Cassar
Kaplowitz wrote:Well this is a perfect example of how DiM's logic is flawed. He would say that this has no support, and therefore no comments, but that doesnt seem true.
Maybe you could advertise or something. I think some people send a pm to like everyone on the site advertising their maps. Its really annoying, but i end up clicking on it anyway...even if ive already checked the map like 5 seconds ago! (i have a clicking problem)
But dont go on strike, the only real way to get comments is to update. Im sure once a mod checks this over, you will get moved.
Haha. I am not going on strike don't worry. I genuinely don't have anything to add to the map at the moment. I am happy with it as it is so I will have to wait for further user comments to develop the map further. Also it doesn't necessarily mean that there is something else to update. Maybe people are happy with it as it is like I am for the time being.
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - New Update on pages 1 and 6
Posted:
Sat May 03, 2008 9:11 pmby fireedud
In the legend you have written Luxembourg city and its surroundings, is surroundings what it will be called in the XML? If not, you may want to rename it.
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - New Update on pages 1 and 6
Posted:
Sun May 04, 2008 4:45 amby Ruben Cassar
fireedud wrote:In the legend you have written Luxembourg city and its surroundings, is surroundings what it will be called in the XML? If not, you may want to rename it.
Thanks but I am not an XML expert so I don't really know what you mean, but I will talk to Yeti about that when the time comes and if there's a problem we'll fix it.
I will worry about the XML later, probably the last thing after graphics and gameplay...let's get the idea approved first!
Re: Luxembourg - Vote in Poll - New Update on pages 1 and 6
Posted:
Sun May 04, 2008 7:42 amby gimil
How many neutral units should Luxembourg City start with?
Poll ended at Fri May 02, 2008 1:54 pm
1 neutral unit
2
9%
2 neutral units
3
13%
3 neutral units
17
77%
Total votes : 22
