Conquer Club

Great Map. I'm liking this one. Bit complicated to get the hang of at first but really good now I've just about figured it.

Woltato wrote:Great Map. I'm liking this one. Bit complicated to get the hang of at first but really good now I've just about figured it.

I hope the changes we have coming make it even better =)

I think there is a problem with the bonus titled: "A Pit Tool and A Pit Jack and A Pit Engine (3)" I believe that this is meant to refer to owning a pink diamond, circle and star (corresponding to fuel tires, engine respectively). However my opponent is being given that bonus despite only owning two of the three.

Game 12676962



Key - Yellow is standard bonus
Blue is correctly awarded bonuses
Red is the wrongly awarded bonus

agentcom wrote:I think there is a problem with the bonus titled: "A Pit Tool and A Pit Jack and A Pit Engine (3)" I believe that this is meant to refer to owning a pink diamond, circle and star (corresponding to fuel tires, engine respectively). However my opponent is being given that bonus despite only owning two of the three.

Game 12676962



Key - Yellow is standard bonus
Blue is correctly awarded bonuses
Red is the wrongly awarded bonus

yah it's a bug

I'm not sure when the revised XML dealing with this bug will go live, but it should be soon.

As you noted the bonus for yellow is actually correct ... there is no standard territory bonus ... or at least there should not be... However there is also a minimum bonus of +3 for territories regardless.

Red is indeed a bug that should be fixed shortly.

=D=

Update happened!!!

All bonuses seem to be working as intended now

=D=

like that the bugs are gone, however 2 remarks:

• why remove the bonus for all pieces of 1 pit equipment?
• and are you gonna add a loopback to not get stuck in the pit equipment?

waauw wrote:like that the bugs are gone, however 2 remarks:

• why remove the bonus for all pieces of 1 pit equipment?
• and are you gonna add a loopback to not get stuck in the pit equipment?

It was never intended that all pit equipment get a bonus just for holding 1 of them. It put the focus on the pits and not on the track where I intended it.

As for a loopback ... well it has been discussed.

I have a few thoughts on pit equipment that might help.

• 3 of a single equipment could be changed to grant you another bonus ... maybe +2 ... this way individual pieces are 0 but sets across and down grant bonuses and take the pit equipment from 15 bonus for holding the while thing to 25.
• 3 of a single piece of equipment could open a route to attack the pit row from that piece of equipment.
• Would changing it so that all pit equipment can assault all other pit equipment help in the case that a pit crew gets nuked out.

But first lets see how the games play out and what feedback we can garner from the latest changes.

=D=

Probably not a good idea, but I'll throw it there anyways. If people are concerned about not getting back to their Pit Crew, can you have the Pit Equipment assault the Pit Crew??

isaiah40 wrote:Probably not a good idea, but I'll throw it there anyways. If people are concerned about not getting back to their Pit Crew, can you have the Pit Equipment assault the Pit Crew??

It might be a good idea if we add a conditional border that links the pit equipment back to the crew as long as you control a car condition (fuel, tires or engine) that way we have a way of knowing which crew is yours. However if you lose all of your car and your crew then too bad for you.

=D=

dolomite13 wrote:

isaiah40 wrote:Probably not a good idea, but I'll throw it there anyways. If people are concerned about not getting back to their Pit Crew, can you have the Pit Equipment assault the Pit Crew??

It might be a good idea if we add a conditional border that links the pit equipment back to the crew as long as you control a car condition (fuel, tires or engine) that way we have a way of knowing which crew is yours. However if you lose all of your car and your crew then too bad for you.

=D=

This could be a good way to go.

well gotta hand it to ya, you are succesfull in making the games more fair at the start. Don't think it matters who begins first now.

So far in the games I have played it seems more balanced off the start.

I am still about 50% sure that the pit should remain as it is and 50% of the opinion it could use some tweaks. Anyone have any feedback about this?

=D=

Just as long as there are no dead ends then I'm happy.

thehippo8 wrote:Just as long as there are no dead ends then I'm happy.

Currently we still have dead ends in the pits. I am still thinking that the pits need a way out... I am seriously considering "hold 3 of a given pit equipment and you can assault the pit row from those locations" ... It is a way out but conditional on holding territories.

I also think the pit bonus is a little weak and no-spoils games seem to get bogged down a lot. I was considering +2 if you hold all 3 of a given pit equipment.

=D=

dolomite13 wrote:

thehippo8 wrote:Just as long as there are no dead ends then I'm happy.

Currently we still have dead ends in the pits. I am still thinking that the pits need a way out... I am seriously considering "hold 3 of a given pit equipment and you can assault the pit row from those locations" ... It is a way out but conditional on holding territories.

I also think the pit bonus is a little weak and no-spoils games seem to get bogged down a lot. I was considering +2 if you hold all 3 of a given pit equipment.

=D=

I like that idea ... I think it needs to be quite hard to get back into the game ... but just not impossible. Your suggestion works for me.

Just thinking out loud here ... hoping for a sanity check...

=======================================================================

Bonuses

When we look at the two half's of the map. Pits and Track it currently breaks down as this.

Track - 10 segments (20), 1 location in each segment (40) or a max total of 60 troops.

Pits - One Crew (2 auto), One whole car (5), All pit equipment (15) or a max total of 22 troops.
*Note that you can start with 2 crew so that would add 7 more for a total 29.

If we add the proposed bonus structure change it would add 10 possible troops to the pit side making the max 32/39.

Does that sound like enough of a bonus?

==================================================================

Dead Ends - Pits

I think adding a conditional border based on holding some combination in the pits is a good idea.

However the question remains as to what that should be. It is quite easy to take over a single column in the pits (ie all of the tools) as they are adjacent to one another. So should that be the trigger? And what should it trigger? I was considering making that specific column open to assault the pit row.

But what if we instead went with a harder to accomplish one of each piece of equipment to unlock the connection to pit row but unlock all of your pit equipment to assault the pit row when you have accomplished this.

Alternately or in addition holding all 3 tires could unlock the ability to assault your car's tires from those spaces (this would be the same for engine and fuel). However it would also require you hold a crew or the car to identify which car you could attack. I am less inclined to move towards this solution for the dead end of the pit equipment.

Any Thoughts?

===================================================================

Thanx

D

I have a question regarding the degrading car conditions. I've noticed on other maps that if degrading positions are at 1 when your turn begins, they don't drop out to neutral but stay at 1. Is that the case here? If so, is the only disadvantage to not loading them up that you're more susceptible to attack from the pit equipment? Apologies if this is not the appropriate place for these questions. I'm new to the site and still poking to see where everything is.

GeeksAreMyPeeps wrote:I have a question regarding the degrading car conditions. I've noticed on other maps that if degrading positions are at 1 when your turn begins, they don't drop out to neutral but stay at 1. Is that the case here? If so, is the only disadvantage to not loading them up that you're more susceptible to attack from the pit equipment? Apologies if this is not the appropriate place for these questions. I'm new to the site and still poking to see where everything is.

You are correct. They decay 1 per turn till they reach 1 and the only reason to load em up is because all 3 together are a +5 bonus and they can indeed be bombarded by the pit equipment..

=D=

dolomite13 wrote:

thehippo8 wrote:Just as long as there are no dead ends then I'm happy.

Currently we still have dead ends in the pits. I am still thinking that the pits need a way out... I am seriously considering "hold 3 of a given pit equipment and you can assault the pit row from those locations" ... It is a way out but conditional on holding territories.

I also think the pit bonus is a little weak and no-spoils games seem to get bogged down a lot. I was considering +2 if you hold all 3 of a given pit equipment.

=D=

I think you could just link the pits to pit row as a 1-way attack. it's a 20 neutral reset so it's not an easy way out anyway. This would also add an extra tactical dimension to the map when an opponent is trapped in the pits and you need to get onto the track. ie attacking pit row will let them escape more easily.

No spoils games always get bogged down anyway but an extra pit bonus would be good. These territories are highly vulnerable to attack from lots of different places so I would suggest more than a 2 bonus would be appropriate.

This is a nice map. Quite tactical but not too complicated. Great work.

I like the suggestion of linking all pit equipment to the pit row. With that 20 reset it would keep them clogged there till someone decided to break that down. I have noticed that once someone takes pit row everyone follows them back onto the track.

I think there are a few ways to go with pit equipment bonuses...

We could have +3 for 3 of the same pit equipment. I know that's an easier bonus to grab because they are connected to one another but that would bump up the overall pit bonus. So instead of +15 for the entire pits it would be +30

Another option is +2 for 3 of same equipment and an additional +15 for holding all pit equipment which would make it +40 and more on par with the big track bonus.

And a final option that might make people really fight in the pit equipment area would be to have a +5 synergy bonus for each full set of all 5 pit equipment. So the entire pits would grant +30.

Still not sure but I know I want to increase the current +15 for the entire pits to at least 30 I am just not certain which of these would give that bonus without changing the overall strategy too much and without taking focus away from the track.

=D=

dolomite13 wrote:I like the suggestion of linking all pit equipment to the pit row. With that 20 reset it would keep them clogged there till someone decided to break that down. I have noticed that once someone takes pit row everyone follows them back onto the track.

I think there are a few ways to go with pit equipment bonuses...

We could have +3 for 3 of the same pit equipment. I know that's an easier bonus to grab because they are connected to one another but that would bump up the overall pit bonus. So instead of +15 for the entire pits it would be +30

Another option is +2 for 3 of same equipment and an additional +15 for holding all pit equipment which would make it +40 and more on par with the big track bonus.

And a final option that might make people really fight in the pit equipment area would be to have a +5 synergy bonus for each full set of all 5 pit equipment. So the entire pits would grant +30.

Still not sure but I know I want to increase the current +15 for the entire pits to at least 30 I am just not certain which of these would give that bonus without changing the overall strategy too much and without taking focus away from the track.

=D=

I can't imagine that the entire pits bonus will ever be much of a factor. It's almost half the board so by the time a player has all of those territories secured they're almost certain to have the game won anyway.

The 40 track bonus is a nice idea though. Doubt anyone would be allowed to take it during a sunny game but it's one that might go unnoticed under fog.

Played a couple more games on this map now and I like the fact that it's nice and open. I'm wondering though if maybe it's a bit too open with the winners circle being accessible from anywhere on the track. Just throwing in a few ideas here but it might be better if the winners circle was a bit less accessible. e.g. if it was only accesible from one territory in each segment of track rather than anywhere on the track. Or maybe have a bigger neutral army on the winners circle.

Woltato wrote:Played a couple more games on this map now and I like the fact that it's nice and open. I'm wondering though if maybe it's a bit too open with the winners circle being accessible from anywhere on the track. Just throwing in a few ideas here but it might be better if the winners circle was a bit less accessible. e.g. if it was only accesible from one territory in each segment of track rather than anywhere on the track. Or maybe have a bigger neutral army on the winners circle.

A bigger neutral on the winners circle isn't a good idea. It's hard enough to kill someone as is already. Also I don't think making only one piece per segment connectable to the winners circle will change much.