Conquer Club

Suggestion Medal




Concise description:
Get a medal if your suggestion that YOU suggested in the suggestion forum was implemented into the site we know as CC.

This medal could be just another General Achievement medal or its own medal.

I think it would be nice to look on players walls and see what suggestions they have suggested and were put into the site, congratulate them on a great idea and slap lefty and righty.



How this will benefit the site and/or other comments:
Medals can drive some people to crazy over the edge kind of things and those type of people who might not normally suggest something knowing they wont get a medal for it might start suggesting brilliant site changing ideas... oh and its always nice for others to have a nice shiny new medal.


-griff

I tihnk you just want a medal for this sugg

But why a medal? It's a sugg that takes 3/4 years to implent, but medals aren't everything...

Extreme Ways wrote:I tihnk you just want a medal for this sugg

But why a medal? It's a sugg that takes 3/4 years to implent, but medals aren't everything...

Never even thought of that one! haha... no I was a little disappointed when my last suggestion with "avatar" pictures on wall posts was implemented yet my name was not mentioned at all that I had suggested it... I worked hard digging in to that suggestion at the time making sure that I had the right facts on the lag it might cost and other things that I had to jump across to different sites and email people to figure out when asked, then when implemented not even a mention... hope it doesn't happen to others, but a medal would be a good start for all who have worked hard to get suggestions put into the site.

-griff

grifftron wrote:

Extreme Ways wrote:I tihnk you just want a medal for this sugg

But why a medal? It's a sugg that takes 3/4 years to implent, but medals aren't everything...

Never even thought of that one! haha... no I was a little disappointed when my last suggestion with "avatar" pictures on wall posts was implemented yet my name was not mentioned at all that I had suggested it... I worked hard digging in to that suggestion at the time making sure that I had the right facts on the lag it might cost and other things that I had to jump across to different sites and email people to figure out when asked, then when implemented not even a mention... hope it doesn't happen to others, but a medal would be a good start for all who have worked hard to get suggestions put into the site.

-griff

You make suggestion for the benefit of the website, not to wallow in your own glory.

edit: sorry that was funny Nola... and you are correct...

But after seriously thinking of it... awarding something for someone that has helped out the site known as CC even if it is just with a small digi medal will make those (maybe not all) have the will and strength to continue with more suggestions to make this site better...therefore...

Gonna say yes to this one,More recogniton for the benefit of CC should get you a medal, Dang near everything else will get you a medal, Why shouldnt a medal be given for an implemented suggestion

I'm all for this as I was the one who suggested separating the 'Suggs from the Bugs' (as it used to be called) creating out of one forum, two. I believe it were a positive change. ...and medals are pretty


viewtopic.php?f=470&t=88051

jgordon1111 wrote:Gonna say yes to this one,More recogniton for the benefit of CC should get you a medal, Dang near everything else will get you a medal, Why shouldnt a medal be given for an implemented suggestion

What? gordon agreeing with something I posted? Is this a joke? If not pass this suggestion already.

LOL Griff, I never said I disagreed with your Idea's. Just you seem brash on occassion. But this is a Idea that I think has the merit to go forward.

I support this suggestion as well

I support this suggestion if this suggester doesn't get the suggested medal :p

IcePack wrote:I support this suggestion if this suggester doesn't get the suggested medal :p

LOL! I wouldn't care about getting a medal for this suggestion but I WOULD like one for my other one!

although I wouldn't mind if given one for this one if passed

I support this if any suggestion I have ever made qualifies me. BTW, wouldn't this just be the general contribution medal?

shanksdigs wrote:I support this if any suggestion I have ever made qualifies me. BTW, wouldn't this just be the general contribution medal?

no, this would be its own medal.

all medals given out are different if they have their own forum such as maps and tournaments.

greenoaks wrote:

shanksdigs wrote:I support this if any suggestion I have ever made qualifies me. BTW, wouldn't this just be the general contribution medal?

no, this would be its own medal.

all medals given out are different if they have their own forum such as maps and tournaments.

Yeah, I think that would be best, although if thought best I would be OK with it just being a GC medal

I support either GC or separate medal

I'm not sure whether you should limit it to just the original poster though. I haven't followed suggestions, but there HAVE to be times when the original suggester isn't the driving force behind the eventual approval. The mods of a given suggestion thread should be able to hand out medals to people who actively contribute to the implementation.

I realize that this might cause complaints of arbitrariness, but CC gives out medals for spotting the differences between pictures and other such "official event" nonsense. I don't care and I find those events fun. But I don't think we should be too worried about "devaluing" the GC medal

In the case above then both players would probably be awarded the medal if 1 suggested it, then died off for a while and someone else came in to finish it off and get it implemented.. only sounds fair

can we have an shit map suggestion medal?

anyone who asks for a hasbro world risk map or lord of the rings map get's a stamped on turd on a ribbon medal

well i think that any sugestion who are submited,give you imediatly sugestion medal,because who can waith 3-5 years for idea to be implemented, maybe we will not be alive to see these medal. Beter to get when we still alive,right.

Qwert is right and give him a medal for suggesting you get one now instead of some undetermined time down the road

Pedronicus wrote:can we have an shit map suggestion medal?

anyone who asks for a hasbro world risk map or lord of the rings map get's a stamped on turd on a ribbon medal

Great idea, but will need its own thread

qwert wrote:well i think that any sugestion who are submited,give you imediatly sugestion medal,because who can waith 3-5 years for idea to be implemented, maybe we will not be alive to see these medal. Beter to get when we still alive,right.

I only understood 3 words in the above post but I don't think I agree...

If a suggestion is top notch and is passed by the mods, then lack would see it in the approved suggestions thread and pass them through.. so this suggestion is only for those whos suggestions are implemented will get medals.

grifftron wrote:

Pedronicus wrote:can we have an shit map suggestion medal?

anyone who asks for a hasbro world risk map or lord of the rings map get's a stamped on turd on a ribbon medal

Great idea, but will need its own thread

qwert wrote:well i think that any sugestion who are submited,give you imediatly sugestion medal,because who can waith 3-5 years for idea to be implemented, maybe we will not be alive to see these medal. Beter to get when we still alive,right.

I only understood 3 words in the above post but I don't think I agree...

If a suggestion is top notch and is passed by the mods, then lack would see it in the approved suggestions thread and pass them through.. so this suggestion is only for those whos suggestions are implemented will get medals.

Do you realised that you need to waith 5 years for sugestion to be implemented? Do you have some informacion that yours sugestion will be implemented fast??
If some sugestion are not going to be implemented,then i dont see purpose of Submited forum.

5 years? Comon qwert

My last suggestion was implemented in a year or so... if a suggestion is boarderline maybe 2 years max.. but 5 years? That is a little over the top my friend.

5 years is far too long. i'll implement it immediately. here is your medal