Conquer Club

I support either GC or separate medal

I'm not sure whether you should limit it to just the original poster though. I haven't followed suggestions, but there HAVE to be times when the original suggester isn't the driving force behind the eventual approval. The mods of a given suggestion thread should be able to hand out medals to people who actively contribute to the implementation.

I realize that this might cause complaints of arbitrariness, but CC gives out medals for spotting the differences between pictures and other such "official event" nonsense. I don't care and I find those events fun. But I don't think we should be too worried about "devaluing" the GC medal

In the case above then both players would probably be awarded the medal if 1 suggested it, then died off for a while and someone else came in to finish it off and get it implemented.. only sounds fair

can we have an shit map suggestion medal?

anyone who asks for a hasbro world risk map or lord of the rings map get's a stamped on turd on a ribbon medal

well i think that any sugestion who are submited,give you imediatly sugestion medal,because who can waith 3-5 years for idea to be implemented, maybe we will not be alive to see these medal. Beter to get when we still alive,right.

Qwert is right and give him a medal for suggesting you get one now instead of some undetermined time down the road

Pedronicus wrote:can we have an shit map suggestion medal?

anyone who asks for a hasbro world risk map or lord of the rings map get's a stamped on turd on a ribbon medal

Great idea, but will need its own thread

qwert wrote:well i think that any sugestion who are submited,give you imediatly sugestion medal,because who can waith 3-5 years for idea to be implemented, maybe we will not be alive to see these medal. Beter to get when we still alive,right.

I only understood 3 words in the above post but I don't think I agree...

If a suggestion is top notch and is passed by the mods, then lack would see it in the approved suggestions thread and pass them through.. so this suggestion is only for those whos suggestions are implemented will get medals.

grifftron wrote:

Pedronicus wrote:can we have an shit map suggestion medal?

anyone who asks for a hasbro world risk map or lord of the rings map get's a stamped on turd on a ribbon medal

Great idea, but will need its own thread

qwert wrote:well i think that any sugestion who are submited,give you imediatly sugestion medal,because who can waith 3-5 years for idea to be implemented, maybe we will not be alive to see these medal. Beter to get when we still alive,right.

I only understood 3 words in the above post but I don't think I agree...

If a suggestion is top notch and is passed by the mods, then lack would see it in the approved suggestions thread and pass them through.. so this suggestion is only for those whos suggestions are implemented will get medals.

Do you realised that you need to waith 5 years for sugestion to be implemented? Do you have some informacion that yours sugestion will be implemented fast??
If some sugestion are not going to be implemented,then i dont see purpose of Submited forum.

5 years? Comon qwert

My last suggestion was implemented in a year or so... if a suggestion is boarderline maybe 2 years max.. but 5 years? That is a little over the top my friend.

5 years is far too long. i'll implement it immediately. here is your medal

The light bulb idea was what I was thinking of.. but more along the lines of those below



or

grifftron wrote:The light bulb idea was what I was thinking of.. but more along the lines of those below



or

i think your first pic is

grifftron wrote:5 years? Comon qwert

My last suggestion was implemented in a year or so... if a suggestion is boarderline maybe 2 years max.. but 5 years? That is a little over the top my friend.

Then you have some connection with lackattack,otherwise i dont see how its possible to be implemented so fast

I have 4 submited sugestions,and one whas hit 3 years in Sumbited forums,all other are over a year.
Do you know that we have sugestions in submited forum,who are old over 5 years?
Unfortunatly,any sugestion who can give money benefit,have more chances to be implemented much faster,then sugestion who only bring fun.

qwert wrote:

grifftron wrote:5 years? Comon qwert

My last suggestion was implemented in a year or so... if a suggestion is boarderline maybe 2 years max.. but 5 years? That is a little over the top my friend.

Then you have some connection with lackattack,otherwise i dont see how its possible to be implemented so fast

I doubt he does. lack had, from what I remember, the Tech team do his update.

Well this IS going to be a suggestion medal for only suggestions that get implemented, if someone wants to suggest a different medal for suggestions that just pass into the "accepted suggestions" thread be my guest...

I like the medal. Did you just add that or did I miss it when I first saw this topic?

agentcom wrote:I like the medal. Did you just add that or did I miss it when I first saw this topic?

just added it a couple days ago, glad you like it, it needs some editing if it were going to be used, let the pros edit and mess with it, my skills are pretty basic graphic wise

Not a fan of this idea, we'd have people suggesting all kinds of crazy stuff just to get the medal which wastes everyone's time.

SimplyObsessed wrote:Not a fan of this idea, we'd have people suggesting all kinds of crazy stuff just to get the medal which wastes everyone's time.

False.

Suggestions are good and important. If people suggest stupid things, they'll get called on it AND the suggestion won't be implemented. You only get the medal if something is implemented.

chapcrap wrote:

SimplyObsessed wrote:Not a fan of this idea, we'd have people suggesting all kinds of crazy stuff just to get the medal which wastes everyone's time.

False.

Suggestions are good and important. If people suggest stupid things, they'll get called on it AND the suggestion won't be implemented. You only get the medal if something is implemented.

Thanks chap for clearing that up... hate when people post before reading what the hell is going on

I suggest we implement this suggestion.

L M S wrote:I suggest we implement this suggestion.

no that would be my suggestion thank you

I suggested we have suggestions, so there. (my dad can beat up your dad)

ya i too will

rapunzel3 wrote:ya i too will

this is not my multi, i swear it