Conquer Club

Ryall55 wrote:Hi,

I still want everyones feedback on this idea

Can't you hear the drums, dont worry about feedback, it's coming.

*****

I would appreciate something like this. Maybe we can develop this idea a little more.

What would I do w all my free time?

As I posted in CLA when this was mentioned...

Well i for one don't mind (and enjoy) running the F400. I think there are other areas to improve clans and focus on since that works already being done. If all those other things get done, they maybe an automated score could be looked at.

Just my $0.02

would love to see this, great idea!

great idea! even if we all appreciate icepack's work it would be a better solution for the long term. A bit like when they created a special medal stats on the side bar. even if we could use maprank, it was a real improvement we all appreciate..

sdh wrote:would love to see this, great idea!

+1

betiko wrote:even if we all appreciate icepack's work it would be a better solution for the long term.

This is the truth.

Having something automated by the site will almost always be a better solution than having a user have to do it. I would appreciate some kind of ranking system that is clearer than F400 too.

chapcrap wrote:

betiko wrote:even if we all appreciate icepack's work it would be a better solution for the long term.

This is the truth.

Having something automated by the site will almost always be a better solution than having a user have to do it. I would appreciate some kind of ranking system that is clearer than F400 too.

The F400 is pretty clear...to me

I like the use of the F-400. It is also nice to have the clan community run its own ratings. What would be good is if the site hosted an official scoreboard using the community data. The clans could then be ordered via either F-400 or DTX, or even a site generated rating if it was introduced.

The use of community data and an official scoreboard would be the perfect combination in my mind.

Anything that adds to clans or integrates them more into the site is a good idea in my book.

at least to have the conqueror's cup integrated in the site, as it's the most important clan event. but i'd like an official ranking from the site. Even if the f-400 is kind of theone we all refer to, there has always been several clan rankings and none is the official.

So maybe something with the following (sortable) columns:

Clan Name; Wars; Victories; F400 rank; DTX rank; Conqueror's Cup Victories

The main problem that I see with this is that it would be a major update. We would basically have to integrate all the stuff that is done manually into some sort of structure OR we would keep doing it manually and somebody would have to keep it updated. I think the former would be better in the long run, but you'd have to have the infrastructure to support it, which I think would mean that you'd have to have a clan war creation page like what tournament organizers have but more complex.

MERGED multiple threads requesting clan rankings. Edited OP.

I think this is a great idea. When I first got my premium a few months ago, clans were the most exciting thing about this site and also the hardest to learn about as a relative newcomer. Everyone seemed to talk about top 10 clans, but it was hard to figure out who they were and what that meant. Bringing clans more to the forefront with an official rank list would be the perfect way to start.