betiko wrote:Seriously... you consider finishing 4 times 4th comparable to finishing 1st once?
At the end you only remember the winners. No one cares about 4th.
You can play with numbers all you want, lhdd has acheived more than fall as of right now.
Idk why you’re getting so defensive. I thought it would be interesting to see what a points system would look like, created the system, and then scored. I also said when I posted I wasn’t sure whether or not I agreed with it or not, and expressed surprise that LHDD wasn’t higher / closer.
Regarding your question, I’m not looking to see who has the most titles with this excersize. I also said that up front, trophy’s are easy to look at and compile. It’s looking at the broader picture of “top 10 clans of all time”. That includes top 2, 3, 4 finishes etc not just titles. Even rockfist mentioned some sports teams who might win the title twixe but suck the rest of the years, vs teams that win once and do well every year. Idk what my stance is. But yeah, top 2’s and 3’s and 4’s etc also earn you points towards “best clan of all time” not just titles, which is why I included those too.
I’m not sure how winning CL 2nd Div should be somehow more respected then getting 2nd or Top 4 in the CL PD, I mean. Say you won’t it all you want but imo it doesn’t move the needle much towards earning you “top 10 clan of all time”. Your most recent dip into 2nd division you didn’t even win, you came 2nd? There’s lots of ways to break it down, but some of those listed achievements aren’t really all that impressive compared to others. Which is why you still earn points, but not the same. You won it and can’t take that away but in the grand scheme of things idk of many top 10 clans of all time that think winning 2nd Div title or such as all that impressive.
If you ask people what (mainly) encompasses "clan life" they would say Cup, League, and possibly Random League mainly. If you like lists, heres a couple for you to compare:
Top 2 Finishes in the Two Major Events (Cup and CL)
FALL 5
LHDD 3
FOED 2
Expand that to Top 4 in Cup and Top 3 in League:
FALL 7
LHDD 6
FOED 4
Add in Random League Top 3 Finishes:
FALL 11
FOED 8
LHDD 7