Page 1 of 1
[Site] List of Top 20 Most Popular Maps
Posted:
Tue Jul 23, 2013 9:04 pmby EmperorTigerstar
Concise description:
A simple list or page that shows the top 20 most popular maps based on number of active games using them. That way, people can see which maps will attract more gamers.
EDIT: You can also have it to where you can click the map and then get sent to a list of all games awaiting players using that map so that way people don't have to look through pages and pages to find their favorite map.
Re: List of Top 20 Most Popular Maps
Posted:
Tue Jul 23, 2013 9:19 pmby SaviorShot
Game finder tab in the top left. You can find anything you want there
Re: List of Top 20 Most Popular Maps
Posted:
Tue Jul 23, 2013 9:34 pmby spiesr
Re: List of Top 20 Most Popular Maps
Posted:
Tue Jul 23, 2013 9:47 pmby DoomYoshi
Without fail, the most popular map is JRR Tolkien's map of Middle Earth.
The best map though is definitely:
- Click image to enlarge.
Re: List of Top 20 Most Popular Maps
Posted:
Thu Jul 25, 2013 7:52 pmby stahrgazer
SaviorShot wrote:Game finder tab in the top left. You can find anything you want there
Game finder didn't have a "20 most popular maps" option last time I looked.
Interesting idea. Why not?
Re: List of Top 20 Most Popular Maps
Posted:
Sun Jul 28, 2013 1:32 pmby EmperorTigerstar
DoomYoshi wrote:Without fail, the most popular map is JRR Tolkien's map of Middle Earth.
The best map though is definitely:
- Click image to enlarge.
I meant top 20 most popular conquer club maps.
Re: List of Top 20 Most Popular Maps
Posted:
Sun Jul 28, 2013 9:56 pmby DoomYoshi
I understand, just adding some levity since I thought the question was already answered. There have been polls determining the most popular maps and people keep various lists of the number of games played on maps.
Re: List of Top 20 Most Popular Maps
Posted:
Tue Aug 27, 2013 9:26 amby OliverFA
I think this is a very good idea. And in fact, would provide valuable feedback for the foundry on what to suggest to new mapmakers.
Re: List of Top 20 Most Popular Maps
Posted:
Tue Aug 27, 2013 1:55 pmby DoomYoshi
OliverFA wrote:I think this is a very good idea. And in fact, would provide valuable feedback for the foundry on what to suggest to new mapmakers.
I disagree, for the same reasons that you can't tell a musician what makes a hit song.
Re: List of Top 20 Most Popular Maps
Posted:
Tue Aug 27, 2013 2:15 pmby OliverFA
That's almost a philosophical debate, but lets say that some factors in art can be told and some can't. By looking at the most successful songs its possible to tell some of the factors that make a good song. With maps it's the same.
Of course there is the question about the different audiences (some like big maps, some like small maps, some like simple maps, some like complex maps) however a top 20 list would be very informative and useful. Specially if it was about the last year, which would eliminate old maps advantage
Re: List of Top 20 Most Popular Maps
Posted:
Fri Sep 13, 2013 9:43 pmby EmperorTigerstar
DoomYoshi wrote:OliverFA wrote:I think this is a very good idea. And in fact, would provide valuable feedback for the foundry on what to suggest to new mapmakers.
I disagree, for the same reasons that you can't tell a musician what makes a hit song.
I meant maps used the most...
For example:
1. Classic (732 ongoing games)
2. Napoleonic Europe (440 ongoing games)
Re: List of Top 20 Most Popular Maps
Posted:
Sun Sep 15, 2013 2:37 amby agentcom
There's something in the works on the test site that would effectively provide this information.
Re: List of Top 20 Most Popular Maps
Posted:
Thu Sep 19, 2013 11:38 pmby EmperorTigerstar
agentcom wrote:There's something in the works on the test site that would effectively provide this information.
I hope it happens then.
Re: List of Top 20 Most Popular Maps
Posted:
Thu Sep 19, 2013 11:54 pmby patrickaa317
EmperorTigerstar wrote:agentcom wrote:There's something in the works on the test site that would effectively provide this information.
I hope it happens then.
http://www.conquerclub.com/public.php?mode=maps&sort=games
Re: List of Top 20 Most Popular Maps
Posted:
Fri Sep 20, 2013 10:57 pmby agentcom
EmperorTigerstar wrote:Concise description:
A simple list or page that shows the top 20 most popular maps based on number of active games using them. That way, people can see which maps will attract more gamers.
EDIT: You can also have it to where you can click the map and then get sent to a list of all games awaiting players using that map so that way people don't have to look through pages and pages to find their favorite map.
As pointed out above,
IMPLEMENTED!
The edit you made is a good point though. There are a couple changes that need to be made to that page anyway, so I'll bring it up.
Re: [Site] List of Top 20 Most Popular Maps
Posted:
Sat Sep 21, 2013 2:59 amby DoomYoshi
That list is wrong. USA was a launch map. Game 6 was played on it.
Re: [Site] List of Top 20 Most Popular Maps
Posted:
Sat Sep 21, 2013 6:31 amby agentcom
DoomYoshi wrote:That list is wrong. USA was a launch map. Game 6 was played on it.
Interesting. For other reasons, I suspected that the list might be a little bit screwy. I'll post something and figure out where the data came from.
Re: List of Top 20 Most Popular Maps
Posted:
Sat Sep 21, 2013 11:27 amby EmperorTigerstar
Thank you so much for implementing this! Is there a way to show how many games using that map are being played at the current moment?
Re: [Site] List of Top 20 Most Popular Maps
Posted:
Mon Sep 23, 2013 12:10 amby DoomYoshi
agentcom wrote:DoomYoshi wrote:That list is wrong. USA was a launch map. Game 6 was played on it.
Interesting. For other reasons, I suspected that the list might be a little bit screwy. I'll post something and figure out where the data came from.
When I first started I made a list of the maps in order they came out by selecting all maps, going to the first game numbers, seeing what was there and then unselecting them for the next iteration. I did this for every map on the site and like a year later realized there was actually a list.
This page may not be perfect, but it is such a step in the right direction.