Page 10 of 25
Posted:
Sat Dec 23, 2006 12:48 pmby lackattack
I'll ignore the secondary suggestion about multiplied armies for missed turns because it's been debated a zillion times.
Right now double turns are blocked in Freestyle and double turns are only considered double turns when the round ends prematurely:
the instructions wrote:The player who triggers a new round is not allowed to take a second back-to-back turn and must wait for someone else to play.
Anything else is considered a "fake double turn" because the round ended naturally and all players were aware of the exact time when the new round begins. So theoretically they could go online at that moment and prevent the double play.
Having said that, fake double turns are considereed by many to be unfair and is something I've been meaning to re-visit for a long time now. Hopefully I'll find time to do something about it in the upcoming update.
Posted:
Sat Dec 23, 2006 5:45 pmby zip_disk
err. suggestion
Posted:
Sat Dec 30, 2006 7:21 pmby khazalid
<Subject>:
* Concise Idea. Closing the freestyle loophole that allows double turns (see flame wars rev kyle and johnnyrotten)
<Body>:
* Suggestion Idea: see above
* Specifics: letting a turn time out and then being able to take another straight after
* Why it is needed: many reasons. most obviously because it is twisting the game mechanics to gain an unfair advantage. the usual retort is that because it is in the game mechanics, it should be exploited. this is bullshit.
* Priority** (1-5): 5
Posted:
Sun Dec 31, 2006 9:07 amby nyg5680
to do that i think they would hafta elimnate freestyle all together so wut u hafta do is play like the ppl that do that or just dont play freestyle
Reseting the 24h limit in Freestyle
Posted:
Mon Jan 29, 2007 9:09 pmby Marxwell
Suggestion: in a freestyle game, the 24h limit for each turn should be reset after the first person begins his turn, in order to ensure the person who finished the previous round will have 24h to play too.
Why it is needed: when playing freestyle with a lot of players normally there shouldn't be any problem, but when playing doubles or triples freestyle, the team who should start might start at the very last minutes, thus forcing the opponent team to lose its turn. This can be heavily abused, since not only would the opponent lose a turn, but the first team would also have a double turn!
Specifics: if the first player (or team) misses his turn, the other team should not miss the turn too (since they never had a chance to play!). They should be entitled another 24h to play the same turn, instead. In a standard game these 24h should be entitled only to the player who didn't have a chance to play.
Priority: 4
Posted:
Mon Jan 29, 2007 10:11 pmby spiesr
As long as you get armies for missed turns this isn't much of a problem...
Posted:
Tue Jan 30, 2007 3:49 amby yeti_c
spiesr wrote:As long as you get armies for missed turns this isn't much of a problem...
Surely you are wrong here - the guy mentioned that the opposing team could take Double Turns - In a triple player game this could mean 6 turns of death raining down on your team and being wiped out...
I like the suggestion - it's especially prevalent in a triples game or a 4player doubles as there are only one set of opposing forces.
C.
Posted:
Tue Jan 30, 2007 7:23 amby Wisse
spiesr wrote:As long as you get armies for missed turns this isn't much of a problem...
well you got a continent, and you can't take a turn because of this, and they concer your continent next turn, you don't get the armies of holding that continent the turn before...
Stop Double turns in freestyle
Posted:
Tue Feb 20, 2007 6:03 pmby bedplay
This has probably been said before, but in all of my freestyle realtime games, there has been some jackass who waits till the end of the turn, then uses everything hes got to conquer a continent (or some other thing to his advantage.)
Then refreshes the game every 2 seconds to effectively get a double turn.
There is nothing you can do about it, apart from team up on that player which tweaks the game, and makes games not fun to play.
in Freestyle, I propose that the rules are changed. if a player ends their turn last in freestyle, they not only have to wait for 1 other player to start their turn, but they have to wait till either another player ends their turn or until 1-2 minutes after another player ends their turn.
This is the thing that really bugs me about the game, It is a cheap tactic and basically it sucks/ makes games crap.
Re: Stop Double turns in freestyle
Posted:
Tue Feb 20, 2007 6:04 pmby Wisse
bedplay wrote:This has probably been said before, but in all of my freestyle realtime games, there has been some jackass who waits till the end of the turn, then uses everything hes got to conquer a continent (or some other thing to his advantage.)
Then refreshes the game every 2 seconds to effectively get a double turn.
There is nothing you can do about it, apart from team up on that player which tweaks the game, and makes games not fun to play.
in Freestyle, I propose that the rules are changed. if a player ends their turn last in freestyle, they not only have to wait for 1 other player to start their turn, but they have to wait till either another player ends their turn or until 1-2 minutes after another player ends their turn.
This is the thing that really bugs me about the game, It is a cheap tactic and basically it sucks/ makes games crap.
especily when it was a no-card game...
Posted:
Tue Feb 20, 2007 8:50 pmby Evil Semp
Thats part of freestyle.
If I understand what you are saying the person who finishes a round can't take his turn until two players have started their turn and one has finished?
Posted:
Tue Feb 20, 2007 8:53 pmby AAFitz
Evil Semp wrote:Thats part of freestyle.
If I understand what you are saying the person who finishes a round can't take his turn until two players have started their turn and one has finished?
its more when they wait till the end of the round take the turn, dont finish the turn and then can go again at the beginning of the round...essentially a double turn i believe is his complaint...
all you can do is start your games at a time thats good for you and wait till the end of the round and make your moves to counter it if your against someone who does it a lot
Posted:
Tue Feb 20, 2007 8:56 pmby DemonHunter
It bugs me when people do that, (Unless it RT) but I think it's worth it to play a fast game.
Posted:
Tue Feb 20, 2007 8:58 pmby sully800
This has been discussed to death.
I'm pretty sure that a semi-freestyle game is a pending addition. Where you can start your turn at any point but can't play at the same time as others. Many people like freestyle the way it is, so I wouldn't like to see simultaneous turns dissappear completely....just an option eventually.
By the way, its not hard to defend against the tactic you just mentioned. Just don't take your turn immediately after someone has conquered a big continent. Wait like half an hour and you will almost always get the 2+minute headstart that you need. If you're more dedicated, check the forum to see when they're on...or look at what country theyre from and try to play when its the middle of the night there (desperate situations only, like when you have a single man, they own the entire map....but you win anyway).
Posted:
Tue Feb 20, 2007 9:32 pmby Evil Semp
You can also check the game log and see if they usually take their turns at around the same time.
Posted:
Tue Feb 20, 2007 9:56 pmby Kugelblitz22
sully800 wrote:This has been discussed to death.
I'm pretty sure that a semi-freestyle game is a pending addition. Where you can start your turn at any point but can't play at the same time as others. Many people like freestyle the way it is, so I wouldn't like to see simultaneous turns dissappear completely....just an option eventually.
By the way, its not hard to defend against the tactic you just mentioned. Just don't take your turn immediately after someone has conquered a big continent. Wait like half an hour and you will almost always get the 2+minute headstart that you need. If you're more dedicated, check the forum to see when they're on...or look at what country theyre from and try to play when its the middle of the night there (desperate situations only, like when you have a single man, they own the entire map....but you win anyway).
While your definitely right, it has been discussed to death, that's why I don't play freestyle anymore (or at least not often) It kind of kills the spirit of freestyle if you have to take your turns under cover of darkness or lurk around the website to see if your opponent is on. For me CC is about solid, enjoyable game play not calculating when it will be 4 in the morning in Australia so you can take your turn. If theres people that like that, more power to ya. But I am eagerly awaiting a fix to what I see as a broken game mechanic.
Posted:
Wed Feb 21, 2007 12:44 amby Unit_2
dude, its fair, you can wait till everyone edns ther turn then do your but its fair
Posted:
Wed Feb 21, 2007 1:31 amby Jamie
Don't play freestyle, I don't. Sequential, or nothing for me.
Posted:
Wed Feb 21, 2007 2:26 amby sully800
And everyone always does what Jamie says
Posted:
Wed Feb 21, 2007 9:11 amby Kahless
I can't play sequential unless its RT, takes far too long tor your turn to come round.
Double Turns
Posted:
Sat Mar 17, 2007 7:17 pmby hawkeye
Having two turns in a row on freestyle games.
Bring it back.
It was used by so many people it was crazy to take it away as an option.
Priority: 4 out of 5.
Posted:
Sat Mar 17, 2007 7:20 pmby hecter
I like it the way it is. It's cheap to get two turns in a row.
Posted:
Sat Mar 17, 2007 7:22 pmby hawkeye
Hecter you don't know what I'm talking about. It used to be an option and I played it a lot. I know I'm not the only one. I also want to know why lack took it away.
Posted:
Sat Mar 17, 2007 8:05 pmby wacicha
because alot of new people lost alot of points trying to figure why
Posted:
Sat Mar 17, 2007 8:08 pmby hawkeye
Wasn't it in the faq?