Moderator: Community Team
grifftron wrote:Not sure if this was said yet or not.. but here is a thought if it wasn't, you guys might not give a rip but its just an idea
You guys have the Anti Fog deal going on for Fog games, why not make these spoils work for both fog and non fog games, kinda like how nukes work for every type of game, even when we don't want them (because we end up having to nuke ourselves). Fog, in Sunny games could add fog to the board for all players... might get kinda annoying but just throwing it out there guys
-griff
yeti_c wrote:grifftron wrote:Not sure if this was said yet or not.. but here is a thought if it wasn't, you guys might not give a rip but its just an idea
You guys have the Anti Fog deal going on for Fog games, why not make these spoils work for both fog and non fog games, kinda like how nukes work for every type of game, even when we don't want them (because we end up having to nuke ourselves). Fog, in Sunny games could add fog to the board for all players... might get kinda annoying but just throwing it out there guys
-griff
That could work...
C.
fumandomuerte wrote:yeti_c wrote:grifftron wrote:Not sure if this was said yet or not.. but here is a thought if it wasn't, you guys might not give a rip but its just an idea
You guys have the Anti Fog deal going on for Fog games, why not make these spoils work for both fog and non fog games, kinda like how nukes work for every type of game, even when we don't want them (because we end up having to nuke ourselves). Fog, in Sunny games could add fog to the board for all players... might get kinda annoying but just throwing it out there guys
-griff
That could work...
C.
Brilliant idea, like throwing smoke bombs over the field.
TheForgivenOne wrote:I don't see enough upside to this, as this is only limited to Fog of War games.
DoomYoshi wrote:It is quite interesting. Would be nice if it also revealed territories around.
DoomYoshi wrote:I don't think it has to be a New Spoils. Could be an addon to all existing spoils, really.
DoomYoshi wrote:I don't think it has to be a New Spoils. Could be an addon to all existing spoils, really.
greenoaks wrote:i don't like it, these games would be just like No Spoils and drag on forever
Sniper08 wrote:DoomYoshi wrote:I don't think it has to be a New Spoils. Could be an addon to all existing spoils, really.
i think it does have to be a new kind of spoils, like nuclear was a new kind.
DoomYoshi wrote:Sniper08 wrote:DoomYoshi wrote:I don't think it has to be a New Spoils. Could be an addon to all existing spoils, really.
i think it does have to be a new kind of spoils, like nuclear was a new kind.
Why?
Sniper08 wrote:greenoaks wrote:i don't like it, these games would be just like No Spoils and drag on forever
ever heard of round limits?
greenoaks wrote:Sniper08 wrote:greenoaks wrote:i don't like it, these games would be just like No Spoils and drag on forever
ever heard of round limits?
if the only way this is worth playing is with round limits then it is not worth implementing. the number of games is too small .
Sniper08 wrote:DoomYoshi wrote:Sniper08 wrote:DoomYoshi wrote:I don't think it has to be a New Spoils. Could be an addon to all existing spoils, really.
i think it does have to be a new kind of spoils, like nuclear was a new kind.
Why?
because you already get something for cashing other spoils.
greenoaks wrote:the reason we play spoils is to add something to the game, this does not.
first , being able to see across the map in fog games "adds something to the game"
+ the more dominant you are the more useless this option becomes
same can be said for nuclear,no spoils,esc,flat rate and pretty much any other setting as people who ar dominant tend to win
++ totally useless in Sunny games
and escalating games are useless on city mogul, there is always a flaw in something but this sugg is for FOG games
+++ very little impact on maps such as the Age Of Realms trio that are full of neutrals
same can be said for nuke spoils, should we remove them cause they have little impact on these maps
in short, the impact this option would have as an alternative to the current spoils options is so small it is not worth implementing.
DoomYoshi wrote:But why can't pu get more than one thing? Is it such a problem that you get +2 troops OR the fog revealed.
Yes, it is totally useless in sunny. So, the onlyway it makes sense to me is if you make it:
Fog? Yes No Spoils
As opposed to your suggestion of
Escalating Flat Rate Nuclear No Spols Fog Spoils
I wouldn't play it very often as a standalone spoil.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users