Re: [Official] R/B Holiday Mafia - Day 2 [15/16] Run Run Rud
Posted: Thu Jan 31, 2013 7:41 pm
Iron Butterfly wrote:superkeener wrote:My N1 roleblock pick was not really backed by anything substantial due to the lack of D1 information. However, I did choose spiesr and I was not told if any action was indeed blocked. But since he has claimed to be the snow miser and maybe does not have any night action I can not comment any further on that.
Several things bother me. By themselves they seem small. When combined it raises more questions.
1) There was no need to claim but we could perhaps chalk that up to not knowing the CC protocols. that being the case claiming when there is no need can seem suspect.
I agree
2) You half claimed and when asked to claim said you needed time because you were busy at work, which i can understand BUT your claim was but one sentence and half of it you had already stated. You typed one sentence.
Seems odd, but TBH I wouldn't hold this one over him. My roles are very organized, I could look up a role from any game in the last year in 30 seconds. His was likely in some random inbox pile
3) claiming a town role blocker is not a good claim if one is claiming later in the game as its to easy to get caught in a lie. However day two is a different story. Its also a remarkable coincidence that you role blocked an already claimed character who has no night actions.
Agreed on all points, however, he will have to back up these actions later on. Since he has claimed it would be good for him to claim actions on subsequent nights
4) just my opinion.... Rudolph was a re directer, which kinda makes sense. But Why would baby new year be a blocker? It just doesn't fit. If superkeener is telling the truth then roles don't have to fit the character.
I agree tbh I'm feeling scum roleblocker