Alien: First Contact - town win!!

[madmitch]

I vote you Ice as my 2 pick, nothing weird about that,

[IcePack]

I vote you Ice as my 2 pick, nothing weird about that,

I didn't say weird, I said questionable. Questionable because you haven't provided a reason at all for voting that way.

Ragian said it was because "something was odd" but you've provided no justification

[Samlen]

Sorry I haven't been able to give you a proper response, ragian. It's mostly gut. With that said, my two top suspects are close to being lynched and I didn't realize the deadline was two days away. Worse case scenario, mitch is town and I get lynched quickly, leaving dds with a *hopefully* decent read on the queen. Otherwise, Vote Mitch.

[Ragian]

Right. So, if we lynch Samlen and Mitch and both flip science officers, DDS gets to shoot before the Alien Queen gets to convert someone?

[Samlen]

As far as I know, yes.

[benga]

VOTE COUNT
madmitch 3/skoff, DDS, sam
Skoffin
Ragian
Samlen 2/mitch, IP
IcePack 2/Rag,mitch
DirtyDishSoap

with 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch

little over 48h to deadline!

vote in red pls!

Right. So, if we lynch Samlen and Mitch and both flip science officers, DDS gets to shoot before the Alien Queen gets to convert someone?

shot will go thru, queen can still convert
otherwise I should have told the queen about strikes death

[DirtyDishSoap]

Got a question, if the Queen targets me and I target her, will her convert supersede my shot?

Also, can we agree on lynching somebody? At this rate, with almost less than 24 hours, we're going to not lynch anyone.

[Skoffin]

What's every's top two suspects? We may have to just go by whichever is majority. While normally I don't like voting for lynches I don't really believe in, cult games are different.
My top two suspects are Ice and Mitch. I am willing to move a vote just to make sure we get a lynch through, but I absolutely want to lynch at least one of them.
In the meantime

My two options
Vote Mitch
Vote Icepick

[Skoffin]

Here are a few scenarios that could play out. This was basically unnecessary but since I wrote it to help me think, may as well post XD
If we don't get the Queen today

6 players, 1 is queen

We lynch two townies today
DDS shoots a townie
Queen recruits.
Result: Cult win

We lynch two townies today
DDS no shoots
Queen recruits.
Result: Cult win

We lynch two townies today
DDS shoots an alien
Queen recruits, but queen or recruit is killed
Result: 3 way vote with two townies and 1 alien

We lynch 1 townie today
DDS shoots townie
Queen recruits
Result: 3 town, 2 aliens

We lynch 1 townie today
DDS shoots alien
Queen recruits, 1 dies
Result: 3 town, 1 alien

We lynch 1 townie today
DDS sno shoots
Queen recruits
Result: 4 town, 2 aliens

Ehhh either way DDS absolutely has to shoot tonight for town to stand a chance. Difference in using both lynches or not and him shooting is whether we could lose this night or the next if we eff up.
Either way we need to choose correctly so this just reaffirms to me that I'd rather stick to both ice and mitcxh unless someone has a better reason for why someone other than those two are likely the queen

[DirtyDishSoap]

Mine have been Samlen and now more recently with Ice.

I think Sam's been lurking about.
Ice made one odd post that I found suspect.

But Mitch is mitch and I don't see a pattern. If you do, I'll trust you on that.
Rage is in there only because of the mass claim spiel earlier, but I think that was more curiosity than anything.

[DirtyDishSoap]

Who would everyone recommend I shoot after the first lynch, assuming we do lynch, and why?

I feel like this could help me decipher more info.

[benga]

Got a question, if the Queen targets me and I target her, will her convert supersede my shot?

Also, can we agree on lynching somebody? At this rate, with almost less than 24 hours, we're going to not lynch anyone.

They happen at same time, queen is dead, but you become alien.
So game isn't over, it will still be 2 SO and 1 Alien (if you make the 2 lynches).



VOTE COUNT
madmitch 3/skoff, DDS, sam
Skoffin
Ragian
Samlen 2/mitch, IP
IcePack 3/Rag,mitch, skoff
DirtyDishSoap

with 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch

[benga]

Who would everyone recommend I shoot after the first lynch, assuming we do lynch, and why?

I feel like this could help me decipher more info.

Each night, you can make a "kill".

[DirtyDishSoap]

Who would everyone recommend I shoot after the first lynch, assuming we do lynch, and why?

I feel like this could help me decipher more info.

Each night, you can make a "kill".

Not what I'm asking here.

I'm asking after the first lynch, assuming we don't get the queen, who would people in this game recommend I shoot at night, or would they prefer to leave it up to my judgment?

Does that clear up the air a bit?

[Samlen]

Icepick is my second pick. I was actually hoping the game woulda ended with my vote but forgot ice's vote was in green. I didn't vote ice as well right away on the off-chance I was wrong on both accounts and that skoffin/ragian would end the day suddenly. If me and dds vote ice now, the day would end. Hopefully the game too, if we're right.
Vote icepick

Ninja'd by Skoffin
If we want to not end the day suddenly, either you or dds will need to unvote before voting off ice. I'm up for lynching both mitch and ice, but if were to lynch one i'd rather lynch mitch. Your post earlier on mitch, skoffin, put him higher on my lynch preference than ice.

Ninja'd by more posts. If both are not the alien queen, i'll be very very sad in my gut but i'd say skoffin for being so convincingly helpful. But, to be fair, you should use your judgement as you are pretty much the only confirmed town.

[DirtyDishSoap]

Well, ice is lynched if I'm reading the vote count correctly. Mitch would be after since it takes 3 afterwards

[benga]

VOTE COUNT
madmitch 3/skoff, DDS, sam
Skoffin
Ragian
Samlen 2/mitch, IP
IcePack 4/Rag,mitch, skoff, sam
DirtyDishSoap

with 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch

IcePack - Science Officer has been lynched


VOTE COUNT
madmitch 3/skoff, DDS, sam
Skoffin
Ragian
Samlen 2/mitch, IP
DirtyDishSoap

with 5 alive it takes 3 to lynch

madmitch Alien Queen has been lynched

TOWN WINS!!!

[madmitch]

shoot Skoffin , we gave Skoffin the benefit of doubt because of sickness, looks like I am gone ,another science officer put to rest ,good luck team.

[benga]

Well, I hoped for day 3 and a bit more action!

Thanks all for playing in mine first game!

[madmitch]

shit too late, nice game guys , good play DDS ,that changed the game in towns favor, lets play again.

[benga]

shit too late, nice game guys , good play DDS ,that changed the game in towns favor, lets play again.

I need to work out some more details, it really helps the game run smoother.

[DirtyDishSoap]

That's an incredible read Skoffin lol.

Good game guys.

[Ragian]

Holy balls!

Well done, Skoffin! And well done, DDS. Both are MVP.

I can only find solace in the fact that I didn't want Skoffin or Samlen.

Also, well played, Mitch. I never really suspected you...

Cheers for the game, Benga. This is more of a mind f*ck than regular mafia, I feel.

[IcePack]

Thanks that was fun sorry about the green vote didn't realize