Pikanchion wrote: Ragian wrote:unvote
my joke vote.
At this point, I'm keeping my eye on whoever says a lot without saying anything. There are a few candidates already. Also, I'd like to add that I'm out of town till tomorrow, so my activity might dwindle a bit till Thursday evening.
Right now, my eyes are fixed on MM. I can't find any input from him that's beyond setup guesswork or irrelevant lore. DDS and Pika have also seemed guilty of that, but in my view, they have also added somewhat to actual discussion (Pika > DDS).
Therefore, Vote MM
Let's get some information at least! I think MM is a good place to start cf. above.
I could be persuaded, however, to vote for Thor. The main reason for that would be his unwillingness to add anything about any player. It feels as if he tries very hard to not say anything that could be used against him later. I.e. it seems as if he's playing for himself, not a team. Also, twice I have seen him call his own play "not scummy". Like saying, "I have perfect social skills," in an interview. Moreover, this logical phallacy screams to high heaven:
Thorthoth wrote:So far my strongest suspicion is against you, PIka. If you're completely fine with losing a townie on Day 1 you'll probably try for that again on Day 2.
The opposite argument would be that since you won't lynch D1, you probably won't lynch D2.
To be honest, I don't care if some think that a no lynch is preferable to a lynch. I have my opinion, they have theirs. One can always force the opponent's argument ad absurdum, but I have faith in those proposing a no lynch not being fanatical (as DDS has expressed for instance).
I don't have any sure fire town picks at this moment, but I like the cut of the jib of the following: Flores, Zabeast, and Pika. On the other hand, I'm suspicious of BuJ. I don't like it that he doesn't find me scummy. Something is off. Also, he calls three people suspect, but doesn't vote. What gives?
Another thing that caught my eye is the weirdness of these two posts:
Skoffin wrote: My completely random, totally doesn't mean anything picks for the scum today are:
I'm amending my list. Both Pika and MM are being removed; the rest of the list stands as it was.
Why amend a list that is completely random and totally doesn't mean anything? If the list is indeed random and means nothing, then why bother? If you're being sarcastic, then please follow up with some thoughts on why DDS, dakky, Flores, and I are on your list.
Just a brief bit for clarification as I was drunk in Liverpool and probably missed something concerning this quote:
BuJaber wrote:DDS, I can assure you I am in this game.
Does this mean that you're claiming the role that DDS left out?