Version 11.6 FRANCE 2.1

[rrob74]

Thoroughly enjoy France 2.1 map. There are times though where holding Paris, suburbs, foreign claim and domestic claim for one round doesn't always work. See Game 14152927 as example. Is this a glitch or am I overlooking something? Great work otherwise!

Cheers,

Rob

[Gilligan]

Thoroughly enjoy France 2.1 map. There are times though where holding Paris, suburbs, foreign claim and domestic claim for one round doesn't always work. See Game 14152927 as example. Is this a glitch or am I overlooking something? Great work otherwise!

Cheers,

Rob

make sure you hold all territories of the same flag, not just one

[HotShot53]

I really like this map... maybe because I've done well on it so far lol. I like the regional claims, it makes the borders of territories slightly more flexible. I dislike how many neutrals have to be killed to take paris... it basically makes the foreign claims useless unless you're going for a conditions win. If you have enough extra troops to take and hold paris, you're probably going to win normally anyway... so far I've never seen anyone even try to take it.

[rrob74]

Thanks Gilligan for the reply. Please look at Game 1415924. I've had GREEN hold both flags / both territories in HAU for several rounds. Plus I've held all 5 Foreign Claims. Do I also need to hold all of BAS since it has same Regional Flag in HAU? If so then this should be added to the explanation because it is not intuitive. As it stands, I'm unable to win because I can't hold off. Had I known I would have won this game several rounds ago. Please confirm and thanks in advance!

[Donelladan]

The game number you gave us is wrong rrob74.
But yes you need to hold all flag in BAS, and HAU.
It is written on the legend, regional claims, holding all of the same flag +1.
So you don't hold a regional claim unless you have all the flag of this claim.

[rrob74]

See game 14152924. I interpreted as holding all flags = extra troop. But the winning criteria does state "one regional claim" which I thought was just one regional flag.

[rrob74]

Thanks for clarifying. This is very helpful!

[josko.ri]

This is very good map, thanks for putting effort in making it be.

One thing I like about the map: A lot of regions have border with a lot of other adjacent regions. Pretty similar than Hive map, but pretty different than other similar geographic maps. In terms of unlimited fort team/polymorphic game, which is my favorite settings and which I have played so far in this map, many connections among regions increase skill level needed to properly play this map, which I very like.

One thing I dislike about the map: Value of bonuses is not properly balanced. For example, LOR bonus which is worth +3 is overestimated. It is not so hard to take (no neutrals there) and it is dead edge so king of works as Australia bonus on Classic map. Maximum value for that bonus should be +2. If you compare that with BZH bonus which is worth only +2, you get huge discrepancy. Both bonuses has 4 regions, and BZH can be broken from 2 sides while LOR can be broken from only one side (I do not count the way through 3,3 neutrals as smart way to go break any bonus). That is just one example, but there are some similar ones, such as FRA (2), it has also 4 regions like LOR and BZH, but it has neutral which need t be taken, and it can be broken from many adjacent regions.

[facet]

[beta map challenge]

I loved this map, thank you. I love the scale of it, Paris seems a long way away from the south coast!

I didn't like so much how the Paris victory hasn't come up yet in any of the games I have played.

[CMetternich]

I played this map several times now and I really love it, Thank you.

One thing I dislike:

The southern regions are a bit overvalued in my mind, whereas the regions Paris and Central are not so important. As I played this map I found out that nearly everytime the winner got the southwest under his control and then is unstoppable. So one suggestion:

Mid has a bonus of 8 (!), Cen has a bonus of 6, just exchange this bonus.

Historically the Central with the Loire regions and Paris was always of high importance, so there is also a logic behing my suggestion (otherwise for reasons of playability).

And again thank you for your efforts.

[Lancelot du Lac]

Hello to everyone,

Thank you for your feedback.

Here is a series of four polls. The first topic will be updated for each new poll.

Polls:
1) The suburbs 3 and 4 must be connected.
You can vote from April 15 to April 20.

2) Create a Connection Between Paris and suburbs 4.
You can vote from 21 April to 25 April.

3) Number of neutral troops on Paris's will be reduced to 7 troops
You can vote from April 26 to April 30.

4) Foreign claims can be attacked This from adjacent territory
You can vote from 1 May to 10 May

Following these polls, I will change the graphics and XML.

Thank you to you to play the game

[Lancelot du Lac]

The first poll is started.

[Lancelot du Lac]

There was a mistake in the question of the first Poll.

It is in the suburbs 3 and 4 must be connected, not 4 and 5.

[BigBallinStalin]

Hello to everyone,

Thank you for your feedback.

Here is a series of four polls. The first topic will be updated for each new poll.

Polls:
1) The suburbs 3 and 4 must be connected.
You can vote from April 15 to April 20.

2) Create a Connection Between Paris and suburbs 4.
You can vote from 21 April to 25 April.

3) Number of neutral troops on Paris's will be reduced to 7 troops
You can vote from April 26 to April 30.

4) Foreign claims can be attacked This from adjacent territory
You can vote from 1 May to 10 May

Following these polls, I will change the graphics and XML.

Thank you to you to play the game

"No," to all. The map is fine as it is.

It's not suppose to be easy to hold a +6 with the least terries.

[Leehar]

I'm ambivalent, haven't really considered the merits between suburb 3&4 being connected (and the question merits why sub 2&4 shouldn't also be connected?)

[Lancelot du Lac]

This connection facilitates access between the north and south of the map.

[The Bison King]

I say other. Connect Paris and 4.

[Lancelot du Lac]

It will be the next poll, you can change your vote

Hello to everyone,

Thank you for your feedback.

Here is a series of four polls. The first topic will be updated for each new poll.

Polls:
1) The suburbs 3 and 4 must be connected.
You can vote from April 15 to April 20.

2) Create a Connection Between Paris and suburbs 4.
You can vote from 21 April to 25 April.

3) Number of neutral troops on Paris's will be reduced to 7 troops
You can vote from April 26 to April 30.

4) Foreign claims can be attacked This from adjacent territory
You can vote from 1 May to 10 May

Following these polls, I will change the graphics and XML.

Thank you to you to play the game

[deejones]

Love the map.
I also will say as someone else has. If you have enough troops to take Paris and what have you to win, then the odds are you have enough to win anyways.

[welshbean]

enjoy the map

[killboy108]

I'm sure people would have pointed this out, but I don't have time to read all the notes....

The Auto-deploys don't work.

[Gilligan]

I'm sure people would have pointed this out, but I don't have time to read all the notes....

The Auto-deploys don't work.

Code: Select all

<territory>
<name>Wallonie</name>
<borders>
<border>Nord</border>
</borders>
<bombardments>
<bombardment>Paris</bombardment>
</bombardments>
<coordinates>
<smallx>463</smallx>
<smally>63</smally>
<largex>620</largex>
<largey>75</largey>
</coordinates>
<neutral>3</neutral>
<bonus>1</bonus>
</territory>
<territory>
<name>Jura Suisse</name>
<borders>
<border>Jura</border>
</borders>
<bombardments>
<bombardment>Paris</bombardment>
</bombardments>
<coordinates>
<smallx>609</smallx>
<smally>365</smally>
<largex>817</largex>
<largey>483</largey>
</coordinates>
<neutral>3</neutral>
<bonus>1</bonus>
</territory>
<territory>
<name>Monaco</name>
<borders>
<border>Alpes-Maritimes</border>
</borders>
<bombardments>
<bombardment>Paris</bombardment>
</bombardments>
<coordinates>
<smallx>651</smallx>
<smally>528</smally>
<largex>869</largex>
<largey>708</largey>
</coordinates>
<neutral>3</neutral>
<bonus>1</bonus>
</territory>
<territory>
<name>Catalogne</name>
<borders>
<border>Pyrénées-Orientales</border>
</borders>
<bombardments>
<bombardment>Paris</bombardment>
</bombardments>
<coordinates>
<smallx>441</smallx>
<smally>684</smally>
<largex>579</largex>
<largey>912</largey>
</coordinates>
<neutral>3</neutral>
<bonus>1</bonus>
</territory>
<territory>
<name>Pays-Basque</name>
<borders>
<border>Pyrénées-Atlantiques</border>
</borders>
<bombardments>
<bombardment>Paris</bombardment>
</bombardments>
<coordinates>
<smallx>183</smallx>
<smally>676</smally>
<largex>240</largex>
<largey>903</largey>
</coordinates>
<neutral>3</neutral>
<bonus>1</bonus>
</territory>

all 5 territories are coded to have an auto of 1. i can't look at your games because they are fog.

[Lancelot du Lac]

I'm sure people would have pointed this out, but I don't have time to read all the notes....

The Auto-deploys don't work.

Never see this problem. Wich game ?

[Lancelot du Lac]

The first poll is finished.

Result :

Yes 14 votes 33%
No 25 votes 58%
no opinions 4 votes 9%
other (s) 0 vote
total 43 votes

[Lancelot du Lac]

The seconde poll is open

Hello to everyone,

Thank you for your feedback.

Here is a series of four polls. The first topic will be updated for each new poll.

Polls:
1) The suburbs 3 and 4 must be connected.
You can vote from April 15 to April 20.

2) Create a Connection Between Paris and suburbs 4.
You can vote from 21 April to 25 April.

3) Number of neutral troops on Paris's will be reduced to 7 troops
You can vote from April 26 to April 30.

4) Foreign claims can be attacked This from adjacent territory
You can vote from 1 May to 10 May

Following these polls, I will change the graphics and XML.

Thank you to you to play the game