Star Wars

[Dukasaur]

I just don't know. Episode VI was pretty bad. Episode I was a mild improvement but still suffered from suckage. Episode II was so bad I refused to go to episode III but then we bought the DVDs and watched them all. Episode III was actually good and now possibly my favorite.

Disney has made lots of decent movies I'm hopful they will make good on the franchise.

You're on glue.

None of the SW movies was actually "bad". Some are better than others, and Episode II is the weakest in the bunch, but none could be called bad.

[Haggis_McMutton]

Episode VI was pretty bad.

Are you serious? Episode VI was the best one. That's where Vader redeems himself and the emperor finally gets whats coming to him.

I was rooting for the emperor. :(

But seriously, the way he died was so fucking disappointing.

[Funkyterrance]

Are you serious? Episode VI was the best one. That's where Vader redeems himself and the emperor finally gets whats coming to him.

Now I really mean no offense by this but this opinion sounds like it's influenced mainly by fandom. You described what happened in the movie but no mention in regard to how. As a hardcore fan it probably was enough just to see certain things come to play that you had always wanted to see on the big screen but from a non-diehard point of view I found that all of the new movies were more or less terribly done. If you were to have zero preconcieved notions about the new movies and just watched them in and of themselves would you still think they were any good?

[Symmetry]

Are you serious? Episode VI was the best one. That's where Vader redeems himself and the emperor finally gets whats coming to him.

Now I really mean no offense by this but this opinion sounds like it's influenced mainly by fandom. You described what happened in the movie but no mention in regard to how. As a hardcore fan it probably was enough just to see certain things come to play that you had always wanted to see on the big screen but from a non-diehard point of view I found that all of the new movies were more or less terribly done. If you were to have zero preconcieved notions about the new movies and just watched them in and of themselves would you still think they were any good?

Episode VI was Return of the Jedi dude, it wasn't one of the new movies. I agree with your general assessment though.

[Funkyterrance]

Are you serious? Episode VI was the best one. That's where Vader redeems himself and the emperor finally gets whats coming to him.

Now I really mean no offense by this but this opinion sounds like it's influenced mainly by fandom. You described what happened in the movie but no mention in regard to how. As a hardcore fan it probably was enough just to see certain things come to play that you had always wanted to see on the big screen but from a non-diehard point of view I found that all of the new movies were more or less terribly done. If you were to have zero preconcieved notions about the new movies and just watched them in and of themselves would you still think they were any good?

Episode VI was Return of the Jedi dude, it wasn't one of the new movies. I agree with your general assessment though.

Ooops.
Obviously I don't follow the movies that closely. Out of curiousity, how much involvement did Lucas have in Return of the Jedi?

[Symmetry]

Are you serious? Episode VI was the best one. That's where Vader redeems himself and the emperor finally gets whats coming to him.

Now I really mean no offense by this but this opinion sounds like it's influenced mainly by fandom. You described what happened in the movie but no mention in regard to how. As a hardcore fan it probably was enough just to see certain things come to play that you had always wanted to see on the big screen but from a non-diehard point of view I found that all of the new movies were more or less terribly done. If you were to have zero preconcieved notions about the new movies and just watched them in and of themselves would you still think they were any good?

Episode VI was Return of the Jedi dude, it wasn't one of the new movies. I agree with your general assessment though.

Ooops.
Obviously I don't follow the movies that closely. Out of curiousity, how much involvement did Lucas have in Return of the Jedi?

He wrote it and produced it, but wasn't the director if memory serves.

[2dimes]

Yeah Ewoks are really great. Nothing bad about the acting during Anakin's love story either.

[thegreekdog]

I enjoyed IV, V, and VI. Obviously Empire was the best. I liked Jedi better than New Hope though.

I did not enjoy I and II, but III was as good as Jedi.

[jimboston]

Jedi wasn't the best... but the opening segment, the rescue of Han from Jaba's fortress, was perhaps the best segment from any of the six movies.

[2dimes]

Starwars is good and at the time changed film making for ever. But face it, it's pretty dated.

The Empire Strikes Back was so good it is still a decent movie. the special effects are acceptable and the story is good. Hello?... Yoda!

Return of the Jedi is nice for the kids. Like if Sesame Street had blasters, space ships and light sabers, only not quite as cool. Sorry I give coked out princess in slave outfit a 5. Though I have seen cos play knock offs that approach 10. The end party with those Hollywood purse dogs. Terrible.

Qui Gon Jinn saved episode I. Though he certainly should have smacked Jar Jar Binks around, a lot.

After the opening sequence of Episode II, Anakin Skywalker slowly gets worse until the whining and bad acting spirals into barfarific.

Episode III finally was as good perhaps better than the Empire Strikes Back.

That's my opinion, eat it. I've got to go huff some pam.

[Symmetry]

Jedi wasn't the best... but the opening segment, the rescue of Han from Jaba's fortress, was perhaps the best segment from any of the six movies.

Aye- that and the bike fight on Endor at the end are stand out moments from the original trilogy.

[jimboston]

Jedi wasn't the best... but the opening segment, the rescue of Han from Jaba's fortress, was perhaps the best segment from any of the six movies.

Aye- that and the bike fight on Endor at the end are stand out moments from the original trilogy.

We agree?

Well at least on the opening sequence of Jedi.

The bike fight was cool (especially for it's time)... though it set a precedent that they have tried to copy over and over. It was cool and made for a great game theme... so they copied it in other movies just so they would have good game opportunities.

[Symmetry]

Jedi wasn't the best... but the opening segment, the rescue of Han from Jaba's fortress, was perhaps the best segment from any of the six movies.

Aye- that and the bike fight on Endor at the end are stand out moments from the original trilogy.

We agree?

Well at least on the opening sequence of Jedi.

The bike fight was cool (especially for it's time)... though it set a precedent that they have tried to copy over and over. It was cool and made for a great game theme... so they copied it in other movies just so they would have good game opportunities.

Yup- we agree.

[Attila the Fun!]

Sadly, the real next Star Wars might not be any better.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PyQ6uG6v0KU

[nagerous]

[AndyDufresne]

The absurdity and creativity of this shot by shot recreation from the CineFix guys is pretty great, and so is the side-by-side comparison and the behind the scenes too!

"Homemade" Version:


Side-by-side Comparison:


Behind the Scenes



--Andy

[betiko]

How old were you guys when you first saw the original trilogy? And how old were the films?

[thegreekdog]

How old were you guys when you first saw the original trilogy? And how old were the films?

I saw Return of the Jedi in theaters when I was 4. I do not remember that experience. I saw the rest probably sometime in 1984/1985. So the movies were a few years old when I saw them.

[betiko]

How old were you guys when you first saw the original trilogy? And how old were the films?

I saw Return of the Jedi in theaters when I was 4. I do not remember that experience. I saw the rest probably sometime in 1984/1985. So the movies were a few years old when I saw them.

Yeah i saw them all between 86 & 88, and i was between 6 & 8. I loved those ewoks at the time.

[muy_thaiguy]

I saw them in the 90s at various times on VHS. Still have toys of some of those floating around. C-3PO, R2D2, Luke, Han, even a Ton ton. X-Wing, snowspeeder, and sand speeder too. All heavily played with. What can I say? I believed toys were meant to be played with, not sit uselessly in a box forever.

*giggles as Star Wars collecters flinch at the last few sentences*

[Woodruff]

Still have toys of some of those floating around. C-3PO, R2D2, Luke, Han, even a Ton ton. X-Wing, snowspeeder, and sand speeder too. All heavily played with. What can I say? I believed toys were meant to be played with, not sit uselessly in a box forever.

You, sir, are clearly a dangerous Communist.

[betiko]

I had some of those vintage toys but not that many.. A star trooper, an x wing pilot, an imperial guard (those red ones with capes, was my favorite!), a princess leia with that robot disguise when she goes to jabba, a luke skywalker with a fake hand..

[Nobunaga]

Anybody remember the original Star Wars video game, I mean way back in time, where you pilot an X-Wing Fighter down the trench on the Death Star? Graphics were very simple, with no color - only green lines.

I loved that game.

[tzor]

How old were you guys when you first saw the original trilogy? And how old were the films?

I was a sophomore in High School. More or less I saw it when it first came out.

The other two movies of the original series came out when I was in college.

[thegreekdog]

a princess leia with that robot disguise when she goes to jabba

It wasn't a fucking robot. Seriously though, f*ck you.