The following is an excerpt from the article "Are the Ica Stones fake or real?" This article can be read in it's entirety at...http://www.creationliberty.com/articles/icastones.phpAre the Ica Stones fake or real?
Author: Christopher J. E. Johnson
Published: Sept 12, 2011
In some of our CLE seminars, I show pictures of large stones with drawings carved into them called "Ica Stones." Originally collected by a man named Dr. Javier Cabrera, these Ica Stones portray clear and detailed dinosaurs, as well as complex medical surgery, and other devices such as telescopes and magnifying glasses.
To take an absolute stance that they are all real or all fake would not be wise
because there are some fakes out there, but vice versa, just because some fakes and frauds have been made, doesn't mean the real ones are discredited. However, there are many evolutionists that take the position that they are all fakes and frauds because one of these stones being real would disrupt the entire evolution religion
, and that is a scary thought for many people who scoff at the Bible.
There are many articles and documentaries made that have, in their own words, "proven" these Ica Stones to be fakes, but the whole truth is not told.
[Viceroy63: if something is a half truth, then it is a whole "LIE!"
] Most of these shows and documents are simply not well-researched because there is a presuppositional bias
that wants to prove them fraudulent. For example, a man by the name of Philip Coppens wrote an article on his website that attempts to squelch any credibility to the Ica Stones, but the extent of his research is seen in his labeling of Dr. Cabrera's father:
Dr. Cabrera's father's name is Dom Pedro. This may not seem that important, but I say this to emphasize the lack of research
that is being done, and this is but one of many such mistakes in articles written on the subject of the Ica Stones. [Viceroy63: To not really look into a subject and then post it as truth or self evident, is a "LIE!"
For a fraud to carry on from one generation to the next is a very Mayor undertaking for a small town community where every knows your business even before God Himself knows it. I know this because I live in a small town. This is truly an elaborate hoax???
Those that say all the Ica Stones are fake have to find a way around the scientific and archeological evidence
. For example, these stones were first discovered and reported by the Spanish in 1535.
"Father Simon, a Jesuit missionary, accompanied Pizarro along the Peruvian coast and recorded his amazement upon viewing the stones. In 1562
, Spanish explorers sent some of the stones back to Spain."[Note:]
Ah yes, 1562; Of course! That was the year that the "Dentist Drill" was invented???
Are we to believe that 500 years ago
someone, living in South America, was carving thousands of these stones, just to fool the evolutionists? However, they must believe such things in order to reconcile their theory with the evidence.[Note]
Man, are those evolutionist smart. Even 500 years ago, they were already plotting the debunking of these Ica stones as fackes!
, Dr. Cabrera picked 33 stones out of his collection and sent them to Maurico Hochshild Mining Company in Lima, Peru to be examined for age
, and test to see if they had been recently deposited by a grave-robber who was carving them just to make extra money. Eric Wolf, geologist who worked at the MHMC laboratory sent back his signed analysis which read:
"The stones are covered with a fine patina of natural oxidation which also covers the grooves, by which age should be able to be deduced..."
Erich von Daniken analyzed these stones on a microscopic level
, and found the following:
"Right angled clean scratches showed on the new stone under the microscope, whereas microorganisms could be seen in the grooves of Cabrera's stones under a fine glaze... that was the tiny major difference between genuine and false stones
Though shows, like NOVA, will attempt to convince an audience that the stones' cuts have been made recently
, F.G. Hawley, an experienced chemist and archaeologist, said:
"Many [artifacts] in dry western country show little or no patina after seven or eight hundred years."[Note]
How Shocking that LIES would be spread on the airwaves influencing the minds and thoughts of our little children to believe in a LIE!
Under microscopic analysis, we can see that the real Ica Stones can be verified. Yet, commonly, evolutionists will still attack the authenticity of the Ica Stones without the evidence
, and commonly I find they do not provide any references to what they are talking about.
Another common evidence used against the Ica Stones is the farmer Uchuya, who was said
to be making the stones and selling them to tourists. However, before we analyze this story, let's assume it to be true for the moment.
If it is true that he is making some stones and selling them, does that account for the stones found 500 years ago? Do his fake stones account for all the Ica Stones discovered over the past few decades?
Using this admission of forgery does not disprove the Ica Stones altogether.
This is about the same as someone taking a picture of a stick in the water, claiming it as a picture of the Lochness monster, and then when it is proven fraudulent, the evolutionists will jump on it and say that all accounts are disproven because one person lied. (This is also called a "false dilemma" logical fallacy, claiming they're either all real or all fake.) This emphasis on forgeries, without considering all the evidence, is an immature childish tactic used to persuade an audience, not a method used by researchers seeking the truth.
In addition, Dr. Cabrera alone had over 11,000 stones
in his collection, so where is the gigantic crater that would be required to have dug up that many stones? And how could these two people have done all this by themselves without anyone noticing
? Hamilton Forman, archaeologist researching the Ica Stones, said:
"If one family did this, they must have had an army of elves
A Peruvian jail sentence is almost the same as an American death sentence
. They don't feed you. They don't cloth you. They don't help you in any way. If your family does not come to give you food and assistance, you will die in a Peruvian jail. Selling Peruvian treasures without government authorization is against the law, so when police officers brought in Irma and Basilio, both said they make the stones and sell them, because if the two confessed to digging up the stones and selling them, they would be immediately thrown in Peruvian jail.
[Viceroy63: Sure they did! That makes perfect sense when you put it like that???
Even Philip Coppens, who writes against the authenticity of the Ica Stones, wrote:
"When von Däniken visited the farmer in 1973, Uschuya confirmed to him that he had faked the stones; but later on, in an interview with the German journalist Andreas Fischer, Uschuya claimed the opposite. They were genuine, he insisted, and he admitted to a hoax to [u][b]avoid imprisonment.
Oh, Come on People; Does any reasonably intelligent person really believe that any police, any where on the planet, would try to coerce a confession from a suspect? Ha, ha, ha, Get real???
There is still a lot to be learned by the Ica Stones, but few people are willing to pay for the research because, after all, these stones completely destroy the general theory of evolution
Who would want to pay for research that destroys the only presupposition evolutionists have to help them reject true Biblical history?If the skeptics would do a little research, they wouldn't have to be so skeptical.