Page 1 of 1

Potter minus Potter and where to find Who?

PostPosted: Fri Dec 09, 2016 12:15 am
by Symmetry
Anybody else see the new Harry Potter minus Hogwarts?

I really liked it. Eddie Redmayne was very much doing a Matt Smith Dr Who. I liked it better than most of the Harry Potter's though.

Re: Potter minus Potter and where to find Who?

PostPosted: Fri Dec 09, 2016 4:39 am
by waauw
I read the movie script/book. It was awesome, simply awesome. I found the later Harry Potter books were better though.

Re: Potter minus Potter and where to find Who?

PostPosted: Wed Dec 14, 2016 9:44 am
by PLAYER57832
Symmetry wrote:Anybody else see the new Harry Potter minus Hogwarts?

I really liked it. Eddie Redmayne was very much doing a Matt Smith Dr Who. I liked it better than most of the Harry Potter's though.

Loved it. Looking forward to more!

have a neighbor boy, slightly autistic, who missed my son's birthday party (his dad's fault, he was invited, but his dad got the time wrong -- though we reminded him just the day before). I knew the boy loved Harry Potter, so we invited him to come with us the next day as half compensation. My son, not normally a Harry Potter fan loved it as well (he was up for going as a favor to his friend).

Re: Potter minus Potter and where to find Who?

PostPosted: Wed Dec 14, 2016 6:27 pm
by Symmetry
PLAYER57832 wrote:
Symmetry wrote:Anybody else see the new Harry Potter minus Hogwarts?

I really liked it. Eddie Redmayne was very much doing a Matt Smith Dr Who. I liked it better than most of the Harry Potter's though.

Loved it. Looking forward to more!

have a neighbor boy, slightly autistic, who missed my son's birthday party (his dad's fault, he was invited, but his dad got the time wrong -- though we reminded him just the day before). I knew the boy loved Harry Potter, so we invited him to come with us the next day as half compensation. My son, not normally a Harry Potter fan loved it as well (he was up for going as a favor to his friend).


That's pretty awesome. I think this movie was a lot more complicated in terms of its messages than the earlier books and movies. Kids (and adults, for that matter) seem to like a bit of moral ambiguity.

I don't want to read too much into it, but I liked the way that magic made characters either obsessed with power, or basically perpetual children. Having a central character who is kind of childish in his social interactions, but is still very deep, noble and torn made it for me.

I probably read too much into it, but I was impressed. Good casting too. Took me ages to figure out who was doing the voice of the goblin in the speakeasy.