Page 1 of 2
Part 2: What's your favorite Floyd album?
Posted:
Sun Dec 16, 2007 11:35 pmby static_ice
Hopefully an easier choice now?
I picked The Wall easily, and I'm pretty sure I know which will win but as always, different people (quite understandably) love different albums.
Every album is listed except the soundtrack Music From the Film More, and the 3 albums after Waters watered his ego too much.
Posted:
Sun Dec 16, 2007 11:37 pmby muy_thaiguy
muy_thaiguy wrote:Sorry, not really a fan of theirs, and this will probably be my last valid post in this thread.
Posted:
Sun Dec 16, 2007 11:38 pmby static_ice
muy_thaiguy wrote:muy_thaiguy wrote:Sorry, not really a fan of theirs, and this will probably be my last valid post in this thread.
Did I ask for the opinion of you or any other non-floydian-fans?
Posted:
Sun Dec 16, 2007 11:39 pmby Strife
muy_thaiguy wrote:muy_thaiguy wrote:Sorry, not really a fan of theirs, and this will probably be my last valid post in this thread.
Posted:
Sun Dec 16, 2007 11:41 pmby muy_thaiguy
static_ice wrote:muy_thaiguy wrote:muy_thaiguy wrote:Sorry, not really a fan of theirs, and this will probably be my last valid post in this thread.
Did I ask for the opinion of you or any other non-floydian-fans?
Just had to do it.
Posted:
Mon Dec 17, 2007 12:14 amby strike wolf
The Wall. Dark Side of the Moon is a close second.
Re: Part 2: What's your favorite Floyd album?
Posted:
Mon Dec 17, 2007 2:56 amby Fircoal
static_ice wrote:Hopefully an easier choice now?
nope, not really.
Actually it's a little bit easier, but between, Dark Side, Wall, and Animals it's hard to pick.
Posted:
Mon Dec 17, 2007 11:05 amby kalishnikov
Either Animals, Dark Side or The Wall; it's a very hard choice, they are all quite good.
I voted Animals though because it's the most obscure of my favorites by them.
Posted:
Mon Dec 17, 2007 11:07 amby diddle
strike wolf wrote:The Wall. Dark Side of the Moon is a close second.
QFT except, the other way around
Posted:
Mon Dec 17, 2007 11:16 amby Heimdall
Hard call between Meddle, DSOTM and The Wall
Posted:
Mon Dec 17, 2007 12:55 pmby UselessTriviaMan
I learned to love Pink Floyd from watching and listening to The Wall. It'll forever be my personal favorite, though I can see why many would argue for DSOTM. Dark Side holds a record that'll likely never be broken - it spent over 1100 weeks on Billboard's Top 200 Albums chart. That's over
fourteen years! 
Re: Part 2: What's your favorite Floyd album?
Posted:
Mon Dec 17, 2007 1:28 pmby Gozar
static_ice wrote:Every album is listed except the soundtrack Music From the Film More, and the 3 albums after Waters watered his ego too much.
Why did you leave Music from More off?
And Final Cut was not so bad.
And Division Bell....that is good too.
I voted for Dark Side though, although I almost picked Wish You Were Here.
Re: Part 2: What's your favorite Floyd album?
Posted:
Mon Dec 17, 2007 1:45 pmby Fircoal
Gozar wrote:static_ice wrote:Every album is listed except the soundtrack Music From the Film More, and the 3 albums after Waters watered his ego too much.
Why did you leave Music from More off?
And Final Cut was not so bad.
And Division Bell....that is good too.
I voted for Dark Side though, although I almost picked Wish You Were Here.
huh? Why didn't you mention laspe of reason? That's good.
And Division Bell is terrible.
Posted:
Mon Dec 17, 2007 2:06 pmby unriggable
Animals, quick and effective.
Re: Part 2: What's your favorite Floyd album?
Posted:
Mon Dec 17, 2007 2:12 pmby Gozar
Fircoal wrote:huh? Why didn't you mention laspe of reason? That's good.
And Division Bell is terrible.
Division Bell was much better than Lapse of Reason.
Posted:
Mon Dec 17, 2007 2:39 pmby comic boy
Dark Side is one of the greatest albums of all time - enough said
Division bell is much better than some of you are indicating though.
Posted:
Mon Dec 17, 2007 2:45 pmby Fircoal
comic boy wrote:Dark Side is one of the greatest albums of all time - enough said
Division bell is much better than some of you are indicating though.
no it is not. Laspe is way better then Division Bell. Division Bell is horrible.
Posted:
Mon Dec 17, 2007 2:48 pmby Backglass
I guarantee 90% of those reading this thread didn't even know Floyd HAD albums before DSOTM. Of course the Wall will win because of the age of the voters and it's commercial appeal.
I voted for Meddle with DSOTM as a close second.
(BTW...one of these days...I'm going to cut you into little pieces.)
Posted:
Mon Dec 17, 2007 2:50 pmby The1exile
DSoTM, followed by Wish You Were Here, followed by Animals, followed by AMLOR, followed by The Wall. Haven't listened to most of the rest, unfortunately - is on the list of things to do before I die though.
Posted:
Mon Dec 17, 2007 2:54 pmby Fircoal
Backglass wrote:I guarantee 90% of those reading this thread didn't even know Floyd HAD albums before DSOTM. Of course the Wall will win because of the age of the voters and it's commercial appeal.
meh, I've heard some of them and I'm 14 years old. But meh, Meddle, and Unma are good, but I don't know about piper and saucer of secrets, that time I heard them I didn't think much about it, but I should probably get it a re-listen
Posted:
Mon Dec 17, 2007 3:06 pmby Backglass
The1exile wrote:Wish You Were Here
Another awesome album by The Floyd.
Fircoal wrote:meh, I've heard some of them and I'm 14 years old.
Thanks for making my point.
Posted:
Mon Dec 17, 2007 3:30 pmby Gypsys Kiss
Wish You Were Here is musically better than Dark Side. I usually have to be drunk to listen to Piper and SoS. All their albums have high spots particularly Meddle, but my vote goes to WYWH
Re: Part 2: What's your favorite Floyd album?
Posted:
Mon Dec 17, 2007 6:02 pmby unriggable
Gozar wrote:Fircoal wrote:huh? Why didn't you mention laspe of reason? That's good.
And Division Bell is terrible.
Division Bell was much better than Lapse of Reason.
Division bell was good in a much different way.
Posted:
Mon Dec 17, 2007 6:03 pmby Fircoal
Backglass wrote:Fircoal wrote:meh, I've heard some of them and I'm 14 years old.
Thanks for making my point.
How did I make your point? I thought you point, was that people around my age wouldn't of heard the earlier stuff.
Posted:
Mon Dec 17, 2007 6:52 pmby Arbustos
Animals, with WYWH and TPATGOD close seconds.